One of Scotland Yard’s most senior police officers has offered to face new questions from MPs next week over allegations that he misled parliament about the phone-hacking scandal at the News of the World.
The Culture Media & Sport committee will quiz John Yates, assistant Commissioner of the Metropolitan Police, following claims he made to MPs last year that there were only a small number of phone-hacking victims.
Yates told the Home Affairs select committee in September the Met had been able to identify only around 10-12 figures who were targeted using the technique, because the Crown Prosecution Service adopted a narrow interpretation of the legislation which outlaws it.
He said the CPS had advised the Met that phone-hacking convictions could be secured only if it was proved that voicemail messages left on mobile phones had been intercepted by a third party before they had been listened to by their intended recipient. He gave similar evidence to the Culture committee in 2009.
Labour MP Chris Bryant, who believes his own phone was hacked, said in the House of Commons last week that Yates had misled Parliament by claiming the Met’s hand were tied because of the advice it received from the CPS. His comments prompted an unusual public row between Yates and Keir Starmer, the Director of Public Prosecutions, who said in a letter published by the Guardian last week that it was ‘regrettable’ that Yates had taken comments he made ‘out of context’ in an attempt to justify his evidence. Yates had written to the Guardian defending his position and quoting a sentence from evidence submitted by the DPP’s office to one of the select committees.
Starmer made it clear he has since advised the police that charges could be bought under the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act (RIPA) regardless of whether voicemail had been heard or not by the intended recipient. He said the narrow interpretation of the law cited by Yates had played no part in the charging or prosecution of Glenn Mulcaire or Clive Goodman, who were jailed in January 2007 for hacking voicemail.
Now Yates has written to both committees telling them he wants to clarify his evidence. The Home Affairs committee will meet on Tuesday to consider its response to his request.
Yates reviewed the phone-hacking case in July 2009 after the Guardian revealed that the News of the World had paid out-of-court settlements totalling more than £1m to three hacking victims. He decided in less than 24 hours there was no reason to re-open the Met’s original inquiry into phone-hacking at the paper.
The High Court is now expecting a flood of civil actions over phone-hacking and has taken the unusual step of appointing a single judge, Justice Geoffrey Vos, to handle all the cases. Well-known figures who are currently suing Mulcaire and News of the World’s owner News Group include Sienna Miller, former culture secretary Tessa Jowell and football agent Sky Andrew, comedian Steve Coogan and sports presenter Andy Gray.
The chancellor of the High Court, Sir Andrew Marritt, was asked to appoint a ‘hacking judge’ by the Met and the various claimant solicitors. Dates have been set for several phone-hacking trials. The first, which will hear Andrews’ case, is due to be held in November.