Senior officers from Scotland Yard were enjoying private dinners with News of the World editors at the same time as they were responsible for investigating the phone-hacking scandal at the paper, it has been disclosed.
A list of meetings which the Yard has handed over to the Metropolitan Police Authority discloses eight previously unpublicised private dinners and five other occasions on which senior officers met with executives from the paper.
Two of the dinners came at particularly sensitive moments and are likely to revive fears that Scotland Yard’s handling of the phone-hacking may have been compromised by a desire to avoid alienating the biggest-selling newspaper in the country.
In September 2006, the then deputy commissioner, Paul Stephenson, accompanied by the Yard’s head PR man, Dick Fedorcio, dined with the News of the World’s deputy editor, Neil Wallis. This was only a month after Yard officers had arrested the paper’s royal correspondent, Clive Goodman, and at a time when detectives were still attempting to investigate whether other journalists or executives were involved in the interception of voicemail messages. In theory, Mr Wallis was a potential suspect in the inquiry.
Scotland Yard has since been criticised for failing to interview any News of the World employee other than Goodman, even though it is now known that detectives were in possession of material which suggested that named journalists may have been involved in the hacking. Police also opted not to seek a production order, which would have compelled the paper to hand over internal paperwork, but instead simply wrote to their lawyers requesting a list of information, all of which was refused.
In November 2009, the list also reveals, assistant commissioner John Yates dined with the News of the World’s new editor, Colin Myler, and the paper’s crime editor, Lucy Panton, who is married to a serving Yard detective. Yates had taken over responsibility for the case and, four months earlier, following revelations in the Guardian, he had decided not to re-open the inquiry.
It is not suggested that the officers and editors used the dinners to come to any improper agreement. Criticism will focus on the apparent friendliness between the Metropolitan Police as a whole and an organisation which it had been tasked to investigate. MPs have already raised concerns about the fact that the man who headed the original inquiry in 2006, assistant commissioner Andy Hayman, subsequently went to work for the News of the World’s parent company, News International, writing a regular column in the Times.
The list of meetings was disclosed today by Scotland Yard following a request to the acting commissioner, Tim Godwin, at the last meeting of the Metropolitan Police Authority, MPA, on January 27.
The list also discloses that in 2008 and again in 2009, Paul Stephenson had two dinners with Neil Wallis and one dinner with Colin Myler. In 2009, he also attended a News of the World reception. Stephenson was confirmed as commissioner in January 2009.
Dee Doocey, a Lib Dem member of the MPA, said: “I find it quite extraordinary that when allegations about illegal phone-hacking relating to the News of the World were still unresolved, the Met commissioner thought it was appropriate to be regularly dining with the News of the World. Imagine the outcry there would be if the commissioner was seen dining with a member of the public who was the subject of a police investigation.”
It is not clear that this is a complete list of all contacts between Yard officers and the News of the World. At the MPA meeting, Tim Godwin agreed to hand over details of “formal or informal meetings with officers on the investigating team and the News of the World”. However, the list published today includes only senior officers at meetings “whose purpose was for MPS officers to meet specifically with News of the World.”
The list excludes meetings arranged by the Crime Reporters Association on the grounds that the News of the World would not be the only paper present. It also excludes meetings at social events which were not organised by the paper. There is no mention for example of the Police Bravery Awards in July 2009, when – ten days after the Yard had elected not to reopen their inquiry into the hacking – Paul Stephenson and John Yates dined with Rebekah Brooks, the former editor of the News of the World and the then editor of the Sun, which sponsored the awards.
Complete list, as provided by Scotland Yard:
Criteria:
• Must be meetings whose purpose was for MPS officers to meet specifically with News of the World.
• The MPS holds regular briefings and presentations with the Crime Reporters Association, which are events attended by representatives from all national media, including journalists from the News of the World – these are not included in the information provided.
• Social events at which News of the World journalists or executives may have been present are not included as they are not hosted by NoW.
• Timeframe is 5-year period, January 2006 to present
2006
September – Deputy Commissioner Paul Stephenson: dinner with Deputy Editor, News of the World and Dick Fedorcio.
2007
November – Deputy Commissioner Paul Stephenson: dinner with Deputy Editor, News of the World and Dick Fedorcio.
2008
February – Deputy Commissioner Paul Stephenson: dinner with Deputy Editor, News of the World.
October – Deputy Commissioner Sir Paul Stephenson: meeting with Deputy Editor, News of the World and Dick Fedorcio.
October – Deputy Commissioner Sir Paul Stephenson: dinner with Editor, News of the World and Dick Fedorcio.
2009
February – Commissioner Sir Paul Stephenson: dinner with Deputy Editor, News of the World and Dick Fedorcio.
May – Commissioner Sir Paul Stephenson: dinner Editor, News of the World and Dick Fedorcio.
June – Deputy Commissioner Tim Godwin: participation in News of the World Save our Streets Roadshow alongside the Rt Hon Jack Straw MP.
June – Commissioner Sir Paul Stephenson: attendance at News Corporation reception.
June – Commissioner Sir Paul Stephenson: dinner with Deputy Editor, News of the World and Dick Fedorcio.
November – Assistant Commissioner John Yates: dinner with Editor and Crime Editor, News of the World.
2010
August – Assistant Commissioner Cressida Dick: at request of Commissioner, met with Deputy Editor and Chief Lawyer of the News of the World, together with two Detective Superintendents where they were handed material alleging Pakistan Cricketers Spot Fixing allegations which resulted in arrest and searches later that day.
June – Commissioner Sir Paul Stephenson: attendance at News Corporation reception.