The Metropolitan police have been accused of misleading behaviour in the phone-hacking scandal after handing over evidence which they had twice claimed did not exist.
The latest embarrassment for Scotland Yard was disclosed in the high court today in the case of Sienna Miller’s stepmother, Kelly Hoppen, who claims that a News of the World journalist, Dan Evans, attempted to hack into her voicemail. The court heard she was a target because of her friendships with former England footballer Sol Campbell and film director Guy Ritchie.
The case also threatens to embarrass the NoW because the alleged hacking occurred in June 2009 – three years after the arrest of its then royal correspondent, Clive Goodman, who was jailed with the paper’s private investigator, Glenn Mulcaire, on the basis that he was the only journalist involved in intercepting mobile phone messages. News International, which owns the paper, has repeatedly said that it does not allow illegal news gathering.
Hoppen’s barrister, David Sherbourne, told the court: “This case is enormously important because it drives a coach and horses through the claim that has been persisted in by News International and its executives, that the criminal activities of Goodman and Mulcaire were purely historic, the isolated actions of one rogue journalist and his private investigator.”
The court heard that Hoppen suspected her voicemail was being intercepted in 2009 because private information was being published while some phone messages were recorded as ‘old’ even though she had not listened to them. After the Guardian disclosed the scale of hacking at the NoW in July 2009, her lawyer, Mark Thomson of Atkins Thomson, wrote to Scotland Yard to ask if the evidence which they had gathered from Goodman and Mulcaire included any sign that Hoppen had been the object of unlawful interception. After three months, the Yard replied that they held no such evidence.
In April 2010, after receiving several alerts from Vodafone about unsuccessful attempts to access her messages, Hoppen’s lawyer wrote again to Scotland Yard. After a delay of more than eight months, they finally replied in January of this year, once again claiming that they held no such evidence.
But last week, Sherbourne told the court, Deputy Assistant Commissioner Sue Akers, who is leading a new investigation into the hacking, had contacted Hoppen to disclose that, in reality, the Metropolitan police was in possession of handwritten notes which were kept by Mulcaire detailing her phone numbers and two addresses, her mobile phone account number and the four-digit PIN code which was needed to access her voicemail. “This is the work of a professional hacker,” said Sherbourne.
Police had now handed over six different pages of Mulcaire’s notes about Hoppen which they had been holding since they raided Mulcaire in August 2006. Sherbourne said it was “regrettable, to put it mildly” that the police had twice denied that this material existed. “The fact is that they misled Ms Hoppen.” Edwin Buckett, representing the Metropolitan police, told the court that the police had acted in good faith.
In March 2010, Hoppen’s lawyers also obtained a court order requiring Vodafone to hand over material relating to unsuccessful attempts to access her voicemail. This disclosed that on 22 June 2009 – the day after the Mail on Sunday claimed she was having a relationship with Ritchie – her mobile had been contacted twice by a caller who withheld their own number. The caller hung up the first call when Hoppen answered; then called back, got no answer and dialled into her voicemail for 25 seconds. Vodafone disclosed that the calls were made from a mobile phone registered to News International in the name of Dan Evans, a feature writer.
Michael Silverleaf QC, representing Evans, said the evidence clearly showed that Evans had dialled Hoppen accidentally. The keys on Evans’s phone were inclined to stick and to dial numbers accidentally, he added. The one occasion on which he appeared to have dialled into her voicemail was “one rogue call which nobody has yet explained”.
Mr Justice Eady made an order for Scotland Yard to disclose to Hoppen all relevant material, redacting only the detail of PIN codes. Hoppen has also applied for disclosure orders against Evans and the NoW.