Scotland Yard’s dangerous game

The Guardian, 12 December 2010

Here’s the riddle. If the Guardian, the New York Times and Channel 4’s Dispatches can all find numerous journalists who worked at the News of the World who without exception insist that the newspaper routinely used private investigators to gather information by illegal means, why can’t Scotland Yard find a single one who will tell them the story?

In their original inquiry, in 2006, detectives arrested the paper’s royal correspondent, Clive Goodman, and charged him with listening to messages on the royal household’s mobile phones. Goodman refused to answer questions. Scotland Yard then interviewed not one single other journalist, editor or manager from the paper. Detectives took this decision despite holding evidence that – we now know – clearly identified other News of the World journalists who were involved in handling illegally intercepted voicemail.

In their recent inquiry, which ended fruitlessly last week, they attempted to interview only three journalists, all of whom were identified for them by news organisations. They approached those three not as witnesses but as suspects, warning them that anything they said could be used to prosecute them: two gave interviews in which they declined to answer questions the third challenged them to arrest him in handcuffs, and so they never even spoke to him.

Scotland Yard appears to be playing a dangerous game. The latest inquiry was the third time police have looked at the phone-hacking saga: neither the prime minister’s media adviser and former News of the World editor, Andy Coulson, nor anybody else from the paper has any case to answer, they say. The police will say they are playing by the rules. The danger is that some of the 200 public figures who believe their voicemail was intercepted by the investigator, Glenn Mulcaire, will find the evidence that police have failed to find, in which case Scotland Yard is going to be accused of being involved in a cover-up.

This whole affair broke open last year because one of the few victims named in court, Gordon Taylor of the Professional Footballers’ Association, sued the News of the World. The judge ordered police to hand over relevant evidence, which implicated three journalists, and the paper paid £1m to Taylor and two others on condition that they kept it quiet. Which they did – until the Guardian revealed the secret settlement last year.

Police have been sitting on two caches of evidence for more than four years. The first is the data from phone companies, gathered by them in 2006. CPS paperwork records that this data revealed “a vast array of offending behaviour”. Police then arrested Goodman and Mulcaire, at which point they obtained their second cache, from Mulcaire’s home: computer records, notes, audio tapes, at least 3,000 phone numbers, as well as invoices on which Mulcaire had identified the public figures he had targeted. The original investigation simply filed the material seized from Mulcaire without even searching it properly.

When the Guardian revived the story last year, an assistant commissioner, John Yates, spent less than 24 hours ‘establishing the facts’ and announced his conclusion without knowing the contents of the seized material. The most recent inquiry, which ended last week, was tasked to consider only ‘new’ evidence and so once again ignored the material which the police have held for more than four years.

Quite why Scotland Yard should behave like this remains unproved.