Somewhere in the offices of the Crown Prosecution Service, there is a file which will be of great interest to any independent inquiry which finally attempts to tell the truth about the behaviour of the Metropolitan Police in the phone-hacking scandal at the News of the World. The Guardian has read it.
The police were dragged into the centre of the scandal last week when the New York Times quoted unnamed detectives claiming that Scotland Yard’s ‘close relationship’ with the News of the World had hampered their inquiry. The charge against the Yard essentially falls into two counts: first, that they cut short their investigation; second, that they then failed to tell the truth to press, public and parliament. The police insist that they are innocent on both counts.
The unpublished file in the CPS shows that the inquiry started well. In December 2005, Buckingham Palace complained that somebody seemed to be listening to the voicemail messages of the royal household. Five months later, detectives had tracked the activity to the News of the World’s royal reporter, Clive Goodman, and, beyond him, to the paper’s contracted private investigator, Glenn Mulcaire. The detectives had analysed a mass of telephone data and, in a briefing paper dated May 30 2006, they presented the results to prosecutors.
They wrote: “A vast number of unique voicemail numbers belonging to high profile individuals (politicians, celebrities) have been identified as being accessed without authority. These may be the subject of a wider investigation in due course. A number of the targets of this unauthorised access have been informed.”
That day, there was a case conference between prosecutors and police, and a file note records an interesting suggestion: “The appropriate strategy is to ring-fence the case to minimise the risk of extraneous matters being included,” it says. The file makes it clear that this was a reference to supressing the names of particularly ‘sensitive’ victims of the phone-hacking, and that it was the police who were suggesting this unusual tactic.
We still do not know which victims were to be concealed. We do now know that Prince William and Prince Harry had their voicemail intercepted, and that this was never mentioned when the case came to court. We now know that members of the the military, the government and the police also were victims. None of those was mentioned in court. Scotland Yard has refused to name them nor even to say how many there were in each category. None of the military victims has been identified. Among government victims, we now know that Tessa Jowell, the minister then responsible for news media, had her voicemail intercepted; and unofficially, it is said that David Blunkett, the then Home Secretary, directly responsible for the police, also had his messages compromised, although this is not confirmed. Other ministers, including the then deputy prime minister, John Prescot; the former business secretary, Peter Mandelson; and and the former minister for Europe, Chris Bryant, show up in Mulcaire’s paperwork without any clear evidence whether Mulcaire listened to their messages.
Among the police targets whose names were suppressed, we now know that the then Commissioner of the Metropolitan Police, Sir Ian Blair, and two other former senior officers, Brian Paddick and Mike Fuller, showed up as targets of the News of the World’s private investigator, although it is not known whether their voicemail was successfully hacked. And last week, one police source suggested that senior detectives who were involved in the hacking inquiry may have discovered that they themselves had been targeted. That is not confirmed.
Six weeks later, on July 14 2006, the file again records the police pushing prosecutors to suppress the results of their analysis of mobile phone records: “The police have requested initial advice about the data produced and whether the case as it stands could be ring-fenced to ensure that extraneous matters will not be dragged into the prosecution arena.”
By August, prosecutors had agreed not only to suppress the names of ‘sensitive’ victims but also to focus the court case on a limited sample of victims, including two members of the royal staff, Jamie Lee Pinkerton and Helen Asprey, who were later identified in court with one other colleague, Paddy Harverson. A file note dated August 8 2006 says: “It was recognised early in this case that the investigation was likely to reveal a vast array of offending behaviour. However, the CPS and the police concluded that aspects of the investigation could be focussed on a discrete area of offending relating to JLP and HA.” The DPP has since said that this was done to make the case manageable.
On that same day, police arrested the News of the World’s royal correspondent, Clive Goodman, and the papers’ private investigator, Glenn Mulcaire. They seized a mass of paperwork, computer records and other material from the homes and offices of both men. The Guardian eventually established that that included the mobile phone numbers of 2,978 people as well as 30 audio tapes of voicemail messages and 91 secret PIN codes of a kind which are need to access voicemail for the minority of people who change the factory-set PIN code on their mobile phone.
It was at this point, according to the New York Times, that one senior investigator on the case was approached by a Scotland Yard press officer who was “waving his arms in the air, saying ‘Wait a minute, let’s talk about this'” and who went on to stress the value of the Yard’s long term relationship with News International, the company which owns the News of the World. According to the New York Times, “the investigator recalled becoming furious at the suggestion, responding ‘There’s illegality here, and we’ll pursue it like we do any other case.'”
Any future independent inquiry will want to understand the reasons for a series of decisions which were taken at Scotland Yard at around this time and which have since been uncovered by the House of Commons’ media select committee, the Guardian and the New York Times:
* When they raided the offices of the News of the World, police limited their search warrant to the desk of Clive Goodman. A journalist who was in the building at the time has given the Guardian the name of two senior staff who that day removed black bin bags full of paperwork from their office desks.
* When they wanted internal paperwork from the News of the World, police chose not to go to court to obtain a production order to require its disclosure but instead simply wrote to the paper asking for a list of documents, all of which were refused.
* The paperwork which was seized from Mulcaire included an email which had been sent from the News of the World’s office to the paper’s chief reporter, Neville Thurlbeck, containing the transcript of 35 voicemail messages which had been hacked from the phones of the chief executive of the Professional Footballers Association, Gordon Taylor, and his legal adviser, Jo Armstrong. Police did not pass the email to the crown prosecution service, even though Gordon Taylor was one of only five non-royal victims who were to be named in court.
* The paperwork also included a contract signed by an assistant news editor, Greg Miskiw, agreeing to pay the private investigator an extra £7,000 if he brought in a specified story about Gordon Taylor, in the course of which the investigator hacked Taylor’s voicemail. Police did pass this to prosecutors but chose not even to try to interview Miskiw about this contract. Nor did they interview Neville Thurlbeck about the email which he had been sent, nor the junior reporter who had sent it to him. Nor did they interview any other reporter, editor or manager from the News of the World apart from Clive Goodman.
* Although it is clear that police looked at the material which they had seized from Goodman and Mulcaire, they have now conceded that they did not fully analyse it until two years later, after Guardian stories revived interest in the affair. It was only then, for example, that they found the 91 secret PIN codes.
* They chose not to warn the vast majority of those whose names and personal details had been collected by Goodman and Mulcaire even though this meant breaching a formal agreement with the Director of Public Prosecutions that they would warn ‘all potential victims’.
Scotland Yard last week denied all wrong doing and claimed specifically that “the case was the subject of the most careful investigation” and that “the CPS had full access to all the evidence gathered.”
In January 2007, the case came to court. Goodman and Mulcaire pleaded guilty. The News of the World said both men had acted without their knowledge or authority. A total of only eight victims was named in court. There was no mention by police or prosecutors of the ‘vast number’ of victims recorded in the CPS file. The press complaints commission investigated and said they could find no evidence of any further wrong-doing. The case ended.
And then two and a half years later, it began to unravel. The Guardian disclosed that one of the eight victims named in court, Gordon Taylor, had sued the News of the World and obtained a court order which forced Scotland Yard to disclose paperwork which showed that, contrary to the official version of events, other News of the World journalists had been involved in handling voicemail intercepted by Glenn Mulcaire. The Guardian disclosed that, having originally denied all knowledge of this hacking, the News of the World had paid more than £1 million in costs and damages to persuade Taylor and two associates to settle the case and to seal the file so that nobody knew about it. We quoted unofficial sources at Scotland Yard who had told us that there were ‘thousands’ of victims.
News International accused the Guardian of ‘lying to the British people’. The Press Complaints Commission held a second inquiry and again found no evidence of any wrong-doing. Scotland Yard’s assistant commissioner, John Yates, reacted within 24 hours of the Guardian revelations by saying that he had been asked by the commissioner to ‘establish the facts’. Any independent inquiry will want to understand
* why Mr Yates suggested that he had ‘established the facts around our inquiry’ when, as he later conceded, Scotland Yard had not yet fully analysed the mass of material which they had seized from Goodman and Mulcaire. Following his statement, Yates ordered officers to do so, and after several months of work, they produced a spreadsheet listing more than 4,000 names or partial names together with a summary of the material held on each one by Goodman or Mulcaire.
* why he made no reference to the Yard’s internal report to the CPS of ‘a vast number’ of victims and why he said that “potential targets may have run into hundreds of people but our inquiries showed that they only used the tactic against a far smaller number of individuals”.
* why he made no reference to Scotland Yard’s strategy, accepted by prosecutors, to ‘ring fence’ evidence to suppress the names of ‘sensitive’ victims.
* why he said that “this investigation has not uncovered any evidence to suggest that John Prescott’s phone had been tapped” but did not disclose, as the Guardian had already reported, that invoices submitted by Mulcaire to the News of the World in the spring of 2006 identified Mr Prescott as a target.
* why he said that “where there was clear evidence that people had potentially been the subject of tapping, they were all contacted by the police” but did not say that the Yard had breached their agreement with the Director of Public Prosecutions to warn “all potential victims”.
Mr Yates has denied that anything in his statement was misleading. He says that he did not claim to have read every line of evidence or to have reviewed all the material. In particular, he has said it is wrong to suggest that he was misleading in his comments on the low numbers of victims since police succeeded in finding full legal proof of interception in only one case.
The former assistant commisioner who had headed the original inquiry, Andy Hayman, by now had left Scotland Yard and gone to work for the organisation which he had been investigating, News International. As a regular columnist for the Times, he wrote about the Guardian’s disclosures, claiming that “we put our best detectives on the case and left no stone unturned” and that while there may have been hundreds of potential vicitms, “there was a small number – perhaps only a handful – where there was evidence they had actually been tampered with”.
Since then, senior officers from Scotland Yard have used press briefings to repeat the claim that there was ‘only a handful of victims’. Those briefings have also continued to include denials about the targeting of John Prescott. In February of this year – two months after Scotland Yard finally wrote to Prescott confirming that his name showed up on Mulcaire’s invoices – a senior Yard officer told journalists: “He doesn’t appear anywhere in Goodman’s material or in Mulcaire’s material. There is no reference to John Prescott at all.”
In private, Scotland Yard has begun to tell a different tale. In February this year, as Scotland Yard prepared for publication of the media select committe’s report, which criticised their failure to investigate all leads in the inquiry, John Yates’ staff officer, Dean Haydon, wrote a briefing note for government ministers in which he acknowledged that the material seized in police raids had not been properly examined – “minimal work was done on the vast personal data where no criminal offences were apparent”.
The briefing note, which is dated February 18 2010, went on to repeat a new claim which Scotland Yard had started to use in press briefings. Attempting to explain the discrepancy between their claims about ‘a handful of victims’ and the emerging evidence of ‘a vast number’ of victims, they had started to claim that the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000 allowed them to regard somebody as a victim only if it could be proved that the victims had not listened to their messages before somebody hacked them. Specialist lawyers say that this is a highly contentious interpretation of that law; and that, in any event, the Computer Misuse Act 1990 is entirely clear that it is an offence to intercept voicemail without authority, regardless of whether the intended recipient has or had not already listened to them.
The truth remains unclear. Senior officers at Scotland Yard now concede privately that they have evidence of ‘gross’ and ‘systemic’ interception of voicemail by the News of the World’s investigator. In private, they concede, too, that more could have been to investigate at the time. However, they say their failure to follow all available leads was simply caused by a shortage of resources at a time when their specialist detectives were stretched to breaking point in dealing with terrorist plots.