Pressure builds on Coulson

The Guardian, 5 September 2010

News International and David Cameron’s PR chief, Andy Coulson, face the prospect of a fresh parliamentary inquiry into phone-hacking by the News of the World after Labour MPs said they plan to press for the issue to be referred to the powerful standards and privileges committee of the House of Commons.

MPs who believe they have been the victims of hacking said they were considering asking the Speaker, John Bercow, to order the investigation on the grounds that there has been a breach of parliamentary privilege.

Scotland Yard said last night that it would examine allegations by a former News of the World reporter that hacking was widespread at the tabloid and that the then-editor Coulson knew about the practice. Assistant Commissioner John Yates said the Metropolitan police had not been aware of the allegations made by Sean Hoare before they were published by the New York Times last week. He said detectives were seeking further information from the paper and would consult the Crown Prosecution Service on whether to take further action.

The latest developments came on a weekend when:
* Lord Mandelson, the former business secretary, was named as another possible target of News of the World phone message hacking. He said yesterday he was not the source of the story and did not wish to comment.
* Pressure mounted on the Met over its failure to fully investigate leads in the original hacking inquiry, and to notify potential victims they had been targeted.
* MPs indicated they would press the home secretary, Theresa May, over the apparent inadequacy of the Met’s investigation of the issue during Home Office questions in the Commons today, and call on her to make an emergency statement.

At least three other former ministers believe they were the victims of News of the World phone hacking, including Chris Bryant, Lord Prescott and Tessa Jowell. Prescott has been pressing the police to give him details of its inquiry into whether his phone was hacked. Yesterday he produced detailed invoices showing that News International consultants were paid to make inquiries about him.

But Yates insisted last night there was no evidence that Prescott’s phone had been hacked by Glenn Mulcaire, the private detective working for the News of the World, or by Clive Goodman, the paper’s royal correspondent. Both were jailed for hacking the phones of members of the royal household. Yates said the Met could not hand over documents to Prescott unless it was ordered to do so by a court.

All five Labour leadership candidates in a Sky News debate yesterday demanded a fresh inquiry. Ed Miliband said: “These are very serious allegations which go to the heart of David Cameron’s Downing Street.”

The prospect of a further investigation by the standards and privileges committee emerged after MPs argued that a precedent may have been set by the decision to mount a privileges committee inquiry into the arrest of the Tory MP Damian Green at his Commons office in 2008 over the alleged leaking of documents from the office of the home secretary.

It would be for the Speaker to decide, but Labour MPs claimed there now appeared to have been a wholesale attempt to break into MPs’ phone messages, and the response of the Met had been shown to be inadequate. One Labour source said: “A precedent has been set with the Damian Green affair. This is about the conduct of government, and if it was good enough for the Tories in the case of Green’s arrest, it should be good enough in this case.” Detailed legal advice will be sought this week.

A previous culture select committee inquiry concluded that senior figures at News International management suffered from collective amnesia about the details of the hacking. The more powerful privileges committee could demand greater co-operation from witnesses.

Today the Guardian publishes a detailed account of the police investigation into the original hacking claims that shows how detectives sought to limit the scope of the inquiry and failed to alert public figures who had been targeted by Mulcaire.

A note of a case conference between police and the CPS records that detectives recommended “the appropriate strategy is to ringfence the case to minimise the risk of extraneous matters being included”. In a briefing note for ministers earlier this year, Dean Haydon, Yates’s staff officer, acknowledged: “Minimal work was done on the vast personal data where no criminal offences were apparent.”

The Conservatives continued to argue that the latest spate of allegations of widespread phone hacking, prompted by a four-month inquiry by the New York Times, did not break new ground or was based on unreliable witnesses.

The specific allegation that No 10 communications director Andy Coulson had known about phone hacking when he was editor of the News of the World was ‘recycled’, said a senior cabinet minister, Michael Gove. He said the police decided “there was no case to answer” over claims that public figures had their phones tapped while Coulson was editor.

Coulson resigned at the time saying he would take responsibility even though he had not been aware of the methods that were being used by one of his reporters. His claim of ignorance has been challenged by some former News of the World staff, including some unnamed reporters cited by the New York Times.

Rupert Murdoch, the chairman and chief executive of News Corporation, parent company of News of the World, refused to answer a question about the hacking yesterday on his Fox news channel.

Coulson has also been asked to attend a pre-trial hearing in a perjury case involving Tommy Sheridan, the former Scottish Socialist party leader. A letter was sent to Downing Street and is thought to centre around his time as editor of the News of the World and his role in the paper’s investigation in Sheridan’s private life. Sheridan won £200,000 in a successful defamation action in 2006 after the paper printed allegations about his private life. He was later arrested and charged with perjury over statements during the case.