A few weeks before the start of the 2006 football world cup, the Press Association in London put out a story about an England fan named Paul Hucker, from Ipswich, who was so worried about the risk of England failing in the tournament that he had paid £100, plus £5 tax, to insure himself against emotional trauma.
The PA story explained that, if England went down badly and he could provide medical evidence that he had suffered severe medical trauma, Mr Hucker would receive a pay-out of £1 million from a web-based insurance company, called britishinsurance.com. “I find when it goes to penalty shoot-outs it gets very difficult and I wanted to insure myself against psychological trauma,” Mr Hucker was said to have said.
Any experienced journalist – and, indeed, any human being with their wits switched on – would look at that story and consider the very clear possibility that it was not exactly reliable. Was any football fan really that neurotic? And that greedy? And that stupid, to imagine that he could prove ‘severe medical trauma’? And what kind of insurance company would sell that kind of policy? One that wanted publicity perhaps.
It was easy enough to check. It took less than a minute to Google ‘Paul Hucker’; and only a minute or two more to find out that Mr Hucker had appeared in two other recent stories about insurance. Another couple of minutes revealed that in both of these cases, the policies which had so pleased him were being sold by a Mr Simon Burgess of Braintree in Essex – who also turned out to be the managing director of britishinsurance.com, which had created the policy for Mr Hucker in his state of anxiety about English football.
At the same time, Google revealed that Mr Hucker is a marketing director who specialises in promoting web-based companies, including those of Mr Burgess, with whom he has shared several business ventures.
So, within a maximum of five minutes, it became clear that the Press Association should not be running this story. It was a publicity stunt, a neat little tale designed to promote an insurance company. Five more minutes revealed that the story was not only unreliable, it was also old.
Mr Paul Hucker had appeared in exactly the same story before – as the football fan insuring himself with the same Mr Simon Burgess for fear of the same emotional trauma – in the run-up to the previous world cup, in Japan, four years earlier in June 2002. Mr Hucker was living in Newmarket then, not Ipswich, but the story in the Sun was the same and even the quote was similar. “I am scared that one day I will finally be pushed over the edge – especially if there is a penalty shoot-out,” he was said to have said.
Nevertheless, within 24 hours of its appearance in May 2006, the story about Mr Hucker’s world cup anxiety had appeared in print in the Western Mail, the Newcastle Evening Chronicle, the Hull Daily Mail, the Liverpool Daily Echo and the Daily Telegraph as well as on the websites of the Daily Mail, the Scotsman, the Guardian and the Times. It had broken into television, on the websites of the BBC, ITV and Sky as well as being picked up for radio bulletins by the BBC and commercial stations.
Then it went international. It was posted on Yahoo’s UK news website; and two American wire agencies, AP and UPI, started pushing it out to their clients around the world. Within 48 hours, it was running, either electronically or in print, in the Sydney Morning Herald, the Washington Post, the Malaysia Star, the Sunday Times of Zambia, the Financial Mail in South Africa and the Haveera Daily in the Maldives. It also found its way to India, Finland, New Zealand, Canada and Ireland.
It was translated into Italian and German, into Polish, Romanian, Dutch and Chinese. Here’s what the story looked like in Indonesia: “Paul Hucker membayar 100 pounds ditambah lima pounds untuk pajak asuransi untuk polis yang tidak biasa dari broker British Insurance Limited”. And in Turkey: “Ingiltere’nin Ipswich kentinde yaayan Paul Hucker, 100 sterlin ödeyerek kendisini ‘milli takım kökenli’ depresyona karı sigortalattı.”
You might think that Mr Hucker and Mr Burgess would have hestitated to put out a story which was so obviously flaky, knowing that the media were bound to check it and chuck it. But they knew better than that. They had played this game before, and not just on that earlier occasion, in 2002, when they put out the story about the neurotic football fan. Over the years, they had also dreamed up the story about the policy to insure yourself against becoming ugly; and the one to protect yourself against being kidnapped by aliens; and against being spooked by ghosts on Halloween; and against being turned into a werewolf or a vampire. All good stories. Not to mention their ‘party safe’ policy to protect people against not having a good time on millennium eve, or their Christmas present policy in case you didn’t like your gifts, or their ‘immaculate conception’ policy which was apparently taken out by three unnamed women from Inverness who were worried about giving birth to the new messiah. All these stories ran through the unguarded gates of the media with the ease of a Brazilian striker penetrating the England defence.
The story of the neurotic football fan contains within it the essential ingredients for the concoction of all Flat Earth News – an unreliable statement created by outsiders, usually for their own commercial or political benefit, injected via a wire agency into the arteries of the media through which it then circulates around the whole body of global communication. And, most important, at every stage, as it passes through the hands of all those journalists into all those outlets, nobody checks it.