How cost-cutting squeezed the truth-telling out of UK news.

UK Press Gazette, 8 February 2008

Who needs the Press Association? In the world of churnalism – where so many of us are forced to spend so much time recycling second-hand, unchecked material – we all do.

70% of home news stories in our quality papers carry the product of this single news agency. As PA’s editor, Jonathan Grun, said in an interview for Flat Earth News: “The fact is we are the central heart of the media industry.”

But is the Press Association good enough? I believe PA is honest in intent, efficient in performance, cost-effective as a business – and entirely inadequate for the role in which it has now been cast.

To see this, you have first to recognise the background picture, in which the same corporate owners whose accountants have forced most national newspaper journalists to become mere churnalists, have also cut the supply lines which once fed raw news to them from around the country.

They cut the network of staff journalists in the regions. The old News Chronicle, for example, had nine district reporters scattered through the north of England, Wales and Scotland, all working to an office in Manchester, as well as staff reporters in Bristol, Cardiff, Birmingham and Southampton. Who now has that kind of staff cover?

But much worse, they inflicted death by starvation on the national web of freelance agencies. With their budgets cut, Fleet Street news desks ordered less copy and paid less for what they did order. All across the country, agencies started to shed staff and then to close.

In the Leeds area, for example, there were five agencies, harvesting stories from the city; only one survived. In Manchester, one closed, one shrank and only one survived at full strength. On Merseyside, three closed and one survived, its staff falling at one point from eighteen to only seven. In Sheffield, White’s agency cut back from ten staff to only two.

All over rural Britain, the one-man outfits which had covered village life went bust, while the bigger rural agencies shrank. Mid Staffordshire News was cut down to a one-man team. Kent saw two agencies fold and one survive. Anglia Press cut back from ten staff to four. Calyx in Dorset went from six staff to one. Specialist court-reporting agencies – a major supply line – went the same way.

There was one remaining major supply line – the reporters on the local newspapers who dug out stories for their own titles and sold the best of them up the line to Fleet Street. But they were taken over by the same corporations and subjected to the same treatment.

In the ten years from 1986, according to the Newspaper Society, 403 local titles were closed – 24% of the 1,687 which had been supplying news to their areas and to the nationals. Those which survived saw their staffing cut to the bone with just over half of the 8,000 journalists working in the provinces losing their jobs between 1986 and 2000; some local newsrooms were replaced by regional hubs, cut off from their communities; and senior reporters were replaced with low-paid trainees.

And to replace these thousands of lost staff and freelance reporters with all their contacts and all their local knowledge, the new corporate owners of Fleet Street turned for home news to the Press Association. And, in response, PA increased its district staff from 20 reporters to 70 and distributed them through offices in the Irish republic, northern Ireland, Scotland, Wales and major cities in England.

PA refused to confirm these numbers, but, according to staff there, the agency now attempts to cover the whole of Greater Manchester, Lancashire and Cumbria with just five reporters, including trainees, based in Manchester. The Newcastle area has only four. Leeds and Yorkshire has three. Merseyside, Cheshire and north Wales has two. Cardiff has four for the whole of south Wales and the Welsh Assembly. There are 15 for the whole of Scotland. And these reporters work shift patterns, so there is never a time when they are all at work.

I analysed five days of PA output of UK home news and found that, in place of the old network, PA on any one of those five days was deploying from London and its district offices a total of no more than 69 reporters to cover both houses of parliament, 410 local councils, the national network of criminal and civil courts, 43 police services and police authorities, the environment and transport, 151 primary care trusts, 150 local education authorities, consumer affairs, family finance, science and industry, sudden deaths, human interest, showbusiness, religion and the royal family. On the Sunday which I monitored, they used only 20 reporters to cover the whole nation.

And that skeletal staff can’t fall back on buying in copy from local freelancers, partly because so many of them have gone out of business; and partly because PA has cut back hard on its budgets for freelance copy. Internal PA audits suggest that, between 1992 and 1997, their use of local correspondents fell from 40% of their output to only 6%. One former head of a district PA office told me he had been instructed simply to buy no freelance copy at all.

My point is that PA cannot dig out anything like the number of stories which the old network covered. And that is why, for example, in most courts and council chambers around the country, you are more likely to see a rhino than a reporter. What once was news is now invisible.

And beyond that, can we trust PA to tell the truth? I don’t think I’ve ever spoken to a PA reporter who wasn’t peculiarly obsessed with accuracy. But that does not mean that they have the working conditions, the experience or simply the time to find the truth.

In 2005, the National Union of Journalists conducted a survey among PA staff and found them severely overstretched, working an average of five hours unpaid overtime every day and frequently stepping in to fill senior posts which were unfilled. The union quoted PA journalists: “Staff shortages are a big problem, and running such a tight ship means that when people are off or ill, the situation gets ridiculous…. Newcomers are dropped in at the deep end and left to sink or swim. Training is minimal…. I got the job because I was young and cheap. And the guy who replaces me will no doubt be even younger and even cheaper.” A third of the journalists were juniors earning less than £15,000 a year; some were on less than £12,000.

An NUJ assistant organiser, Jenny Lennox, told the union’s annual meeting about her own experience working in PA’s new hub at Howden, Yorkshire, where the agency sub-edits and packages material for a mass of clients: “I’ve spoken to people there who were firemen, who worked in cake factories and who used to sell cars. The only qualification is that they have a GCSE or equivalent pass in English, and they are subbing national and regional newspapers.”

PA reporters told me they routinely start the day by writing stories from press releases and other newspapers and, since they are doing this from 4.30 in the morning, they cannot possibly find anybody to check them with. One of their senior editors agreed that this happens. He had previously worked for a regional newspaper and told me: “We used to take what we were given from PA and accept it as fact but, once I went to work there, I realised that we couldn’t.”

One senior PA specialist said that when he first joined the agency 25 years earlier, he had written no more than three stories a day, whereas now he expects to write an average of ten in a single shift: “I don’t usually spend more than an hour on a story. Otherwise, I wouldn’t be able to write so many.”

Apart from the fact that PA reporters have so little chance to check their material, this churnalism in PA is built on a foundation which crucially – and generally unrecognised in Fleet Street – is inherently weak on the truth. PA is a news agency, not a newspaper. It is not attempting, nor does it claim to be attempting to tell people the truth about the world.

As its editor, Jonathan Grun, put it to us: “What we do is report what people say and accurately.” The PA reporter goes to the press conference with the intention of capturing an accurate record of what is said. Whether what is said is itself a truthful account of the world is simply not their business.

Indeed, PA reporters say they would be breaking their own in-house rules if they started challenging speakers. They would be accused of making the news instead of reporting it. Sleuthing, Grun said, is not PA’s role: “Our role is attributable journalism – what someone has got to say. What is important is in quote marks.” If the Prime Minister says there are chemical weapons in Iraq, that is what the good news agency will report.