Gordon Brown is beaten back by the rich

The Guardian, 14 October 2002

Wealthy foreigners in the UK are celebrating a first-round victory in their battle to stop Gordon Brown closing the non-domicile tax loophole which allows them to avoid paying millions of pounds in UK tax each year.

Following the Guardian’s revelation that the richest man in Britain, Hans Rausing, had used the loophole to pay UK tax on only a fraction of his wealth, the chancellor announced in his Spring budget that he would review the law and make an announcement in time for his pre-budget report this autumn. City accountants and foreign chambers of commerce were told to expect a series of meetings with Inland Revenue officials to discuss possible changes.

But, following intense lobbying by Greek shipping millionaires and a handful of specialist financial advisers, the meetings have not taken place. Treasury sources say there is now no chance that the consultation can take place before the chancellor’s report, due before the end of November.

According to one source, there has been an internal struggle between the chancellor’s office, where political advisers support a change in the law; and the Treasury’s council of economic advisers, where specialists with strong links to the City have tried to suffocate the initiative.

The loophole allows some 60,000 UK residents to pay no tax at all on income and gains in the rest of the world simply by claiming that their true domicile is the country of their family’s origin. The law – which is unique to this country – has turned the UK into a tax haven for Greek shipping magnates, Saudi princes and American corporate heirs. Mohammed Al Fayed, the controversial owner of Harrods, and Lakshmi Mittal, the Indian steel magnate, are among those who use it.

A Guardian investigation in April revealed that Britain’s richest man, Hans Rausing, who made a fortune of more than £4,000 million by selling his share of his family’s Tetra Pak packaging company, was avoiding tax with such success that he and his UK businesses were receiving more from the Treasury in VAT refunds and grants than they were handing over in tax. Rausing, who has lived in Sussex for 18 years, has been allowed to claim that for tax purposes he is domiciled in Sweden, where he was born.

Following this revelation, the chancellor announced in his budget: “The Government is reviewing the residence and domicile rules as they affect the tax liabilities of individuals… As this is a complex area, all those affected should have the opportunity to contribute to the discussion. The Government will report on this issue in time for the pre-budget report.”

According to City sources, the Inland Revenue’s attempt to follow the chancellor’s lead, has been mired in delaying tactics. Shortly after the budget statement, Revenue officials are said to have submitted plans for a series of meetings, but the Treasury first failed to reply for weeks and then replied only with a series of questions. Although ministers have continued to declare that a series of meetings would take place, the consultation has never happened.

As shadow chancellor, in 1993, Mr Brown warned that the Treasury could be losing £1 billion a year as a result of loopholes in the law on domicile and residence. He said then: “The question is ‘Is Britain’s tax system in need of being cleaned up?’ The answer is Yes, but the Tory party doesn’t have the will to do it.”

In the weeks after he announced his review, the Treasury and the Inland Revenue were bombarded by hostile letters from wealthy foreigners and their accountants. Twice in the past 15 years, the Treasury has considered changing the law only to back down in the face of this lobby. Officials then privately blamed Treasury weakness on the fact that Greek shipping millionaires were key funders of the Conservative party.