It is easy to miss the truth. For example, you could stand in the middle of the Bahnhof Am Zoo in the centre of Berlin and imagine that it was simply a railway station – warm light, the smell of food, trains clattering in from all over Europe. Indeed, you might think it was positively a comforting place, even for the old men with broken teeth, who shelter there and fish for titbits in the wastebins. You have to look closer to see what is special here.
From time to time, as the trains rattle in to the platforms, an adolescent boy will appear. Sometimes he has come from one of the provincial towns of the former East Germany like Meck vor Pommern or Brandenburg, old farming communities now ravaged by poverty. Sometimes he has come from much further afield, stumbling into the light from all parts of the desperate upheaval in the old Soviet bloc. Always, he has about him the mark of the refugee – the sagging bag of belongings and the deep fatigue – and he slips through the crowd, quite unnoticed by all of those around him.
And yet, to a few of those here, he is instantly of consuming interest, and so he finds himself entangled in a subtle ritual.
He will be approached by a man who will offer him help. More than that, this man will offer him the stuff of his dreams – a room to stay in, warmth and clothing, food and drink, alcohol if he would like it, cannabis if he would be interested, cocaine perhaps, computer games, all kinds of games. Sometimes the boy will sense the danger and refuse the dream, but other times he will be diverted.
Every day, this invisible game is played, the watchful men hovering outside the Teehaus in amongst all the ordinary people, spotting their target like an owl on a mouse, making their move, and then the boy slipping away beside them with a shrug. Such a gentle abduction.
It was a social worker who made this visible to me, a young man with a battered beard named Wolfgang who works for an organisation called Subway which specialises in trying to help young people on the streets of Berlin. He told me stories about these boys which were pure Dickens – for example his experience with the little gang of eleven-year-old Romanians who had been found wandering around the Bahnhof. Wolfgang and his colleagues found that years earlier each of these boys had been sold by their impoverished parents to a gang of Polish pickpockets.
One boy had fetched a price of $300, a genuine fortune in the financial dereliction of rural Romania. Another, he said, had been sold cut price, for a bottle of vodka. All of them had been herded together by their new owners who had taken them up to Poland and taught them to steal and put them to work in various cities, bringing them finally to Berlin where, for some reason, this urchin rabble had been abandoned to fend for themselves on the streets.
Wolfgang told me, too, about the Polish boys who come from villages where a man must live on only a hundred Deutschmarks a month ($50); about the Bosnians who wash up on the banks of the Bahnhof Am Zoo not only financially destitute but also emotionally mutilated; about the steady trickle of lost boys from Turkey and Kurdistan, the latter periodically scooped up for some unknown purpose by Kurdish nationalists from the PKK.
But more than that – and this is why it was so important to heed the covert ritual in the Bahnhof – Wolfgang explained what happens to the boys who agree to go with the men.
To begin with, he was really only confirming my common sense conjecture. These men had a sexual interest in young boys and so they took them away and seduced them (‘groomed’ them, in the jargon of this world), keeping them discreetly in their apartments, perhaps introducing them to trusted friends who might provide their own boys in exchange, until they reached the age of 13 or 14, when they were no longer so attractive to them, and they were pushed back out on to the streets from which they came.
Many of them then would become prostitutes. Wolfgang estimated that there were now some 700 boys selling themselves on the streets of Berlin, twice the number that had been doing so only three years earlier. Most came from Eastern Europe, some came from the West, all shared a history of poverty and distress.
This was an unpleasant picture but, in truth, not such a shocking one. In Britain, over the last decade, I have watched the growth of just such a trade. Children who have been emotionally damaged by the new poverty in which they have been reared, have started to collude willingly in the sale of their bodies as a source not only of income but also of some kind of perverse consolation.
In search of affection, they find the punter’s touch. In search of power, they settle for being wanted, if only as sex objects. Fertilised by the growth of poverty in Britain, this market has now reached the point where it is a simple matter for a man to drive into almost any city in the country and, on the pavements of the traditional vice areas, to buy a boy or girl to have sex with. Wolfgang, however, had something else to say.
He started to hint at the existence of an organised industry. He explained that while there might be some 700 boys who had ended up on the streets of Berlin, there were many hundreds of others who had been taken off on a kind of underground railroad which fanned out to major cities across Europe, to Zurich and Hamburg and Frankfurt and, most of all, to Rotterdam and Amsterdam in Holland.
There, he said, these boys were being sold quite overtly in child brothels (that Dickensian note again). And, in talking about this, Wolfgang used one particular word which was especially poignant because it was so peculiarly inappropriate to the lives of children. They were, he said, being trafficked.
*
The idea of a traffic in children is one that has taken on a special power in northern Europe since the arrest in August 1996 of the Belgian Marc Dutroux. As he awaits trial for the abduction and rape of six young girls, four of whom are said to have died in his suburban dungeon, Dutroux is surrounded by an intense speculation that he was part of a much wider conspiracy, reaching into the heights of the Belgian church and political hierarchy, and that he was merely a humble supplier of adolescent sex objects for the consumption of the rich and powerful.
Wolfgang was not suggesting that there was any concrete link between Dutroux and the boys in the Bahnhof Am Zoo. Rather, he appeared to have some knowledge of an entirely separate network of men who had created a commercial enterprise in children and who had been trafficking these boys from Berlin into the sex industry in Holland.
The link lay in the possibility that despite all of the machinery of child protection, despite all of the sophisticated superstructure of police and criminal justice that spans northern Europe, these men, like Marc Dutroux, had got away with it. I set out to find out whether Wolfgang was right.
*
By mere chance, it turned out that there was a door which apparently led down into this underworld only a few miles away from the Bahnhof, in the old proletarian suburb of Tempelhof in east Berlin. This proved to be the point of entry into a scandal which has been growing in the darkness for more than five years but which finally this year has emerged into the press of northern Europe.
At the heart of this scandal is a 12-year-old boy named Manuel Schadwald, who lived in a small apartment in Tempelhof with his mother, Marion, pursuing a perfectly ordinary boyhood, making model aeroplanes and chasing around with his best friend, Kaj, until one sunny afternoon, on July 24 1993, when he disappeared.
It is not in itself unusual for children to disappear. They run off to upset their parents or to find adventure with such frequency that, in the absence of any objective sign of crime, police all over the world habitually refuse to react to a report of a missing child for 48 hours, confident that in nearly every case, the child will return and the family who were once so distraught will not even bother to contact them with the good news.
And so it was that when Manuel failed to come home that evening and Marion Schadwald went to the police, she was tempted to believe that they might be right, that there really was nothing to worry about. She told friends that she had had several fights with Manuel in the previous week, just silly domestic things, and then she had caught him stealing from her purse and she had slapped him. Perhaps he had run off to sulk.
But the days passed, and Manuel did not return, and the police continued to show an infuriating indifference to Marion Schadwald’s insistence that there must be something wrong. In the absence of any official activity, she and her mother set out to do what they could on their own and started distributing posters with a drawing of Manuel, with his fine features and his dark black hair, and an open letter from Marion forgiving him for anything he might have thought that he had done. “Take the fear from me,” she wrote. “Please get in touch. Your mother.”
However, the posters were greeted only with a terrible silence which lasted for nearly a year, until the evening of June 16 1994, when the telephone rang in the office of a Berlin youth group called Mannometer, which works with gay men and which had helped Marion Schadwald to distribute her posters.
Bastian Finke, who works there still, remembers how he came in to work the next day and heard on the answer machine the voice of a man who spoke German with a Dutch accent. When Finke heard what the man was saying, he played the message again and again until he had written down every word. “I have proof that little Manuel is in Amsterdam in Holland,” the voice said, “and that he is dead.”
He went on to give a detailed description of a man who, he claimed, spent many hours in the Bahnhof am Zoo and who could lead them to Manuel’s body. However, he offered no explanation as to how the boy might have reached Holland or why he might have been killed.
If this were a fictional story, the police would have rushed to the Bahnhof and followed a trail of clues, thus discovering either that Manuel was indeed dead in Holland or alternatively perhaps that the voice on the answer machine was lying to conceal the living truth. In the event, Bastian Finke handed over the tape, and… nothing was done. No one even told Marion Schadwald about the mysterious message. Finke did not want to upset her with news that might be false. The police apparently simply did not think to contact her.
Several weeks later, however, the police were forced once more to consider the fate of the missing boy when, from two quite separate sources, they were confronted with evidence not only that he was alive but also that he had been swallowed up by the hidden industry about which Wolfgang had spoken.
In August of that year, 1994, two young German men named Dirk Grund and Stefan Reijmuller, then aged 19 and 20, went to the police in Hamburg and told them a bizarre story. At the time, this received no publicity but subsequently it was leaked in a haemorrhage of police paperwork to journalists at the Dutch TV programme Network with the result that we now know exactly what they had to say.
They explained that earlier that year, they had been living on the streets of Hamburg, slipping into male prostitution to survive, and that on May 24 they had been approached by two Dutchmen who were carrying guns and who made them an exciting offer: if they would come with them to Holland, they could earn 5,000 Dutch guilders ($2,500) each for making a pornographic video.
The men offered each of them an immediate advance of 500 Deutschmarks ($250), and so the two young Germans took the money and sealed the deal. On June 2, they said, having spent their money, they were put on the train to Holland with six other boys, aged between 14 and 16, and transported to Rotterdam.
There, they were taken to a house in Hekelingenstraat where they were offered a very different deal to the one that had been proposed to them in Hamburg. The house turned out to be a brothel and, they claimed, they were forced to work there as prostitutes until they had repaid the 500 Deutschmarks which they had been given in Hamburg.
In their statement to police, they said that their passports were taken from them; they were made to sign a contract which they could not understand; and they were informed that they now belonged to the owner of the house, a 34-year-old German by the name of Lothar Glandorf. They added that there were other boys in this house, some of them much younger, and that they had been made to take part in a pornographic video with two 16-year-olds. Twice, they said, they had tried to escape and failed before finally, they had succeeded in eluding Glandorf’s grasp.
If the Hamburg police were tempted to invest little sympathy in two men who were, by their own account, professional sex workers, they were nevertheless compelled to pay heed to the allegation of force and, in particular, to its use against much younger boys.
When they asked the two men for more detail about these boys, they were told that there were several who were aged 16 or under and that there was one, in particular, who was only 13. He was a German boy who was being sold to Glandorf’s customers under the false name of Sebastian but who had told the two men privately that his real name was Manuel Schadwald.
The Hamburg police relayed this information to Berlin where it might conceivably have disappeared into a file if it had not been for a 17-year-old German boy named Alexander Quart who, on August 23, separately made his own statement to Berlin police, describing his experiences in Rotterdam at the hands of the same Lothar Glandorf.
His story echoed that of Grund and Reijmuller: he had been approached, 15 months earlier, and persuaded that he would earn good money and a roof over his head if he went to work in Holland; he had been transported to Rotterdam, with three other boys, aged 13, 14 and 18; and there he had found himself in a club belonging to Glandorf. He claimed not only that he had been paid to take part in a pornographic video with his 14-year-old travelling companion, but also that he had seen boys and girls of only nine years old being forced against their will to do the same.
Alexander Quart went on to describe to the Berlin police how he had spent some time in a vice area near the central station in Rotterdam, where several times he had seen a young German boy who was selling himself to men. This boy had spoken to him briefly. “He just wanted to know if I lived in Holland or if I was only visiting,” Quart reported. When the Berlin police asked him to identify the boy from a collection of photographs, Quart picked out the picture of Manuel Schadwald.
Faced with these two independent reports, the police finally began to move. The Berlin officers still said nothing to Marion Schadwald but they did speak to their counterparts in Rotterdam. The mass of leaked police paperwork reveals that the Dutch police had already received and ignored a series of complaints about the activities of Lothar Glandorf. Now, finally they decided to act. In September 1994, Rotterdam police set up a team of officers which was given two objectives: to investigate Glandorf; and to find Manuel Schadwald.
The Rotterdam officers began to tap Glandorf’s telephones and covertly to follow him as he moved around the city and eventually they produced an extraordinary report entitled De Handel In Kinderen – The Trade In Children – known colloquially as the HIK report. Together with the transcripts of their phone taps, the report caused a national furore when two years later it was leaked to Dutch TV. It was the first hard, detailed evidence that paedophiles had indeed created an organised industry.
The HIK team found that Glandorf and his partner, Henk Sniekers, owned two clubs, Euro Boys and Young Boys, both of which sold boys to customers; a chain of private houses where younger boys slept and were also sold to clients; an escort agency which sent boys all over Holland; and a pornographic video business.
All this flourished behind the mask of a company which claimed simply to be serving the gay community and to be working only with young men who were at least 18 years of age – the minimum required by Dutch law for those working in the sex industry. The truth was that this was a commerce in the sexual abuse of children, as the HIK report revealed.
The taps on Glandorf’s phones caught the voices of his customers whose demands were most clearly for children. One announced: “I’m looking for a young boy, a very young boy, a nice little blonde one, who can stay the night.” When Glandorf asked another caller what age boy he wanted, the man replied simply: “You know. No hair.”
The HIK police heard of hundreds of boys who had worked in Glandorf’s brothels but could trace the details of only 27 of them. Their report revealed that 12 of them – nearly half of those they traced – were not only under 18 but under 16, some of them by many years.
There was one particular boy who was only nine years old when he was delivered to Glandorf’s brothel by his own mother, an impoverished local woman who had been persuaded by Glandorf that her son could earn money for her by providing innocent entertainment. The mother duly waited downstairs in the bar while her son was taken upstairs to be ‘groomed’.
The child was put into a bath with a customer; he was then taken out and laid naked on a bed so that the customer could massage him while Glandorf promised him a trip to a theme park. When Glandorf came downstairs to pay the mother her fee and to tell her how much her boy was enjoying himself, she replied – in a conversation that was being secretly recorded by police – that, in that case, the boy could come again and she would bring her 14-year-old son as well.
Boys who tried to leave were threatened with violence, the HIK team reported, and also blackmailed with the promise that their work in the brothel would be revealed to their friends and family. One boy who tried to leave was told by Glandorf: “My boy, we have taken photos of you and, if you don’t come back, we will spread them all over the country and even all over the world, so your parents will not have anything to do with you again.”
Police taped a conversation in which Glandorf cooly told another boy that he would shoot his head off if he tried to run away.
This was a thriving business, with customers coming not only from Holland but also from Belgium, Britain and the United States. All of them were well-heeled middle class men. Most of them used false names, the HIK report concluded, because they were married or because they were afraid of jeopardising their ‘high social position’. One was a senior Dutch civil servant.
These men paid at the minimum 100 guilders ($50) for half an hour with a boy of legal age, more for a longer visit, much more for one who was much younger. The scale of their obsession was daunting.
On average, each of the regular customers visited Glandorf’s brothels twice a week. One managed to turn up once every week even though he lived across the North Sea in England. Another customer, who declined to visit the brothels but was happy to use Glandorf’s escort service, ordered up 400 boys over a period of two and a half years. Another spent 2.5 million guilders ($1.25 million) in a year.
The HIK report described how Glandorf would feed young boys to customers regardless of the danger to the child: “Even if Glandorf knew the perversions of a customer, he would still send a young boy to a customer who had a sexual preference for sadomasochism. Glandorf had one customer who specialised in deflowering young boys.”
Some of the customers were walking nightmares. One of them, Martin Smollners, from Arnhem, was particularly feared by the boys because of his violence. He liked to drug them and abuse them in sadomasochistic games and had cemented his reputation by raping a boy in Glandorf’s bar.
What the boys in the brothel did not know was that in 1986 Smollners had lost all control with one boy and murdered him, shooting him seven times. He had been jailed for this and then released after only three and a half years. Smollners now had learned to video his excesses and, on one occasion, wired a boy’s testicles to an electrical generator, lovingly recording the sound and sight of the generator’s whining excitement as he increased the current to the electrodes on the boy’s naked body.
In one of Glandorf’s houses, the HIK team found an unmailed letter from a boy called Attila, written to a young girl named Aysum. “Don’t feel sad about me,” he wrote. “Things are the way they are and there is nothing to be done about it. You can do what you want. Don’t be sad.” Attila, who wrote in German but was evidently Turkish by birth, was the boy under the electrodes in Smollners’ video.
*
There is a powerful cultural tradition among detectives that work with children is not real police work at all. Equally, however, there is a recurrent pattern among those few who are persuaded to leave the world of armed robbers and drugs barons in order to investigate paedophiles, that they find themselves overwhelmed with a ferocious desire to enforce the law against them.
The ruthless exploitation of boys in Glandorf’s sordid empire rapidly had this effect on the HIK team with the ironic result that they were so determined to arrest their man, that they were distracted from their search for Manuel Schadwald. This became clear in a dramatic sequence of events which began in the early hours of the morning on September 19 1994.
One of the HIK team’s phone taps picked up Glandorf talking about a boy who had no passport, who was wanted in Germany and who would need to be smuggled across the border. A little later, the surveillance unit which was covertly following Glandorf’s every move saw him leaving his home with a boy. He was slim with dark hair and striking features, and the officers who were watching immediately identified him as the missing Manuel.
Police surveillance logs show that three different officers made the same identification and that all three of them then hesitated – tempted to move in to rescue Manuel but nervous of ruining the operation against Glandorf by giving themselves away. They asked for orders. None came. That night, the officers observed silently as Glandorf took this boy to a cafe where three others boys were waiting for them.
The next day, the surveillance team – still waiting to be told whether or not they could intervene – watched in impotence as Glandorf put all four boys from the cafe into his car and drove them across the border to Germany. Paralysed by fear of exposing their operation, the officers held back, and they never saw the boy again.
Evidently embarrassed, the Rotterdam police said nothing of the sightings to anyone. They did not contact Marion Schadwald in Berlin to tell her that three of their officers thought they had just seen her son alive. And although finding Manuel was one of the two stated objects of their operation, they did not even mention the sightings in their final report. However, their own leaked logs confirm what happened.
*
Having uncovered this much of the story, I concluded that Wolfgang was right. There was an industry here. But two groups of questions were begging to be answered.
The first was about Manuel Schadwald. It was just conceivable that all of these sightings were false, that the boys who had gone to the police were merely hoping to cause trouble for Lothar Glandorf by claiming that he was harbouring the missing boy, and that the Rotterdam officers were simply mistaken in believing it was Manuel they had seen in Glandorf’s grip. Nevertheless, the coincidence of six different witnesses all placing Manuel in the same location was impossible to ignore. So how could he have got there? Was he still alive and, if so, where was he now?
The second group of questions concerned the numerous other boys in Glandorf’s empire, hundreds of them if the HIK Report was accurate. Who were they? Where had they come from? Once again, the answers began in Berlin.
*
Wolfgang had mentioned a bar where, he said, some of the East European boys went to work when they reached puberty and became too old to interest the men who had given them a kind of refuge in their apartments. It was down on Fuggerstrasse, about 15 minutes walk south from the Bahnhof Am Zoo, and it was called the Pinocchio.
The bar proved to be a cramped, dark place from whose ceiling, at various points, there dangled little Pinocchio puppets. Was that significant? A little boy on a string? A perfect boy who behaved badly? Whatever. The real boys who sat on bars left no doubt about what they were doing, catching the eye of men who came in to drink, sitting next to them, hunched over the ashtray to talk terms, then moving off together to a quieter place.
It turned out that there were several other ‘boy bars’ in the area, one of which, the PC Inn, had recently been closed down by police who had discovered Bosnian boys of only 12 and 13 years of age on sale to customers there.
Several social workers, in Berlin and in Holland, had suggested that the Pinocchio Bar was a meeting place for some of the men who were involved in trafficking these boys across northern Europe. There were two Berliners, in particular, who, they claimed, had earned an easy living in this way, and whom they named as Peter Goetjes and Lutz Edelman.
In Holland, digging into the background of the boy brothels in Rotterdam, I had found a police record for Peter Goetjes who had been convicted for stealing a car in Berlin and then selling it in Rotterdam – to Lothar Glandorf. Now, working my way along the Fuggerstrasse grapevine, I found a man who was on close terms with Peter Goetjes and his friend Lutz Edelman and who, on the condition of anonymity, was willing to talk about them.
He made it sound so casual. Sure, he said, Goetjes and Edelman used to do it a lot. They were were into a little crime, they were in and out of the Pinocchio, they had met Lothar Glandorf who often used to come to Berlin and they had agreed to do this work for him.
They had started in the autumn of 1991. It was simple. They had found a couple of boys at the Bahnhof and a couple more in the Pinocchio, they had given them the good news about the easy money in Rotterdam and then driven them to Holland where Glandorf had bought the boys at the going rate, two thousand Dutch guilders ($1,000) a head. One of the boys had been under 16. But who was counting? It was good money.
Before long, Goetjes and Edelman had been making regular runs. Sometimes they would do no business for several weeks and then, if they were short of money or if Glandorf was on the phone to them, they might make two or three trips in a single week. He guessed the two of them must have sold at least 150 boys that way, some of them pretty young. And there were numerous other men working just as hard in the same traffic.
After a while, he said, they had begun to look further afield. Peter Goetjes had started driving across the border into Poland to a rundown industrial town called Gorzow Wielkopolski. Goetjes had soon found his way around. There was a shabby discotheque where young people used to hang about smoking cigarettes and killing time, and Goetjes had walked in there like an instant millionaire with his pocket full of Deutschmarks.
When he offered boys 50 marks to come back to his hotel room, it was too much money for most of them to ignore, and so he had his fun with them and then offered them the big deal – come to Rotterdam and earn big money and never spend another dull evening blowing smoke rings in Gorzow Wielkopolski.
Some of them changed their mind once they found themselves being driven across the border into a strange world, but Goetjes was tall and thin and muscular with a shaven head and armfuls of tattoos and so when he told them it was too late to change their minds, they didn’t argue.
He made a dozen or more of these trips to Poland, each time bringing back a couple of boys, before he was caught on the German border in the summer of 1992 with a boy stashed in the trunk of his car. He was charged with smuggling, released on bail and then simply drove away and never came back for his trial.
It was tempting to conclude that many of the boys who were wandering into this industry were willing victims, that they were choosing to escape poverty by becoming sex workers. However, the social workers who dealt with them insisted with some passion that this was not real consent, that only a small proportion of these boys was gay, that many of them reacted to their new life with signs of extreme psychological distress and that all of them were being compelled by the effects of poverty.
In Holland, Raphael Beth, a child psychologist who has specialised in the treatment of boy prostitutes, told me: “They live in an emotional prison. In my opinion, most boys in prostitution are not able to discover their own will, what they want to do with their lives. They are rent boys and this is the outcome of psychiatric problems earlier in life. They give consent, but it is not real consent.”
*
It was the summer of 1998 when I was in Fuggerstrasse, and by then the HIK Report had been leaked, and several journalists in Holland and Germany had started to search for Manuel Schadwald.
On June 6, a Dutch television programme called Nova broadcast a brief interview with an anonymous man, whose face was blacked out, who claimed to know the truth about the missing boy. This man’s anonymity was rapidly penetrated with the result that his word was taken very seriously.
He was identified as Robbie van der Plancken, aged 23, a veteran boy prostitute who had grown up in a chaotic family in the Belgian town of Boom before going to work – willingly or otherwise – in the brothels of Lothar Glandorf in Rotterdam. There he had become so embroiled in this world that he had attempted to sell his own twin brothers, then aged 14, to two of Glandorf’s customers. Robbie van der Plancken was an insider speaking out.
He said that he personally had been in Berlin on the day that Manuel had disappeared, five years earlier. What was more, he had seen Manuel – in the Pinocchio Bar in Fuggerstrasse. There, for some reason which he could not explain, the 12-year-old had been sitting, apparently waiting (as though someone had sold him a dangerous dream like the boys in the Bahnhof).
Robbie van der Plancken said he had seen Manuel being taken away and put in a car by a man he knew very well, a man who had just driven with him from Rotterdam to Berlin in the hope that they could find some suitable boys – Lothar Glandorf himself. Robbie was sure that Glandorf had taken him to his brothel, because later in Rotterdam, he had seen the boy there.
Finally, he said, he knew where the boy was now. Five years later, he claimed, Manuel was still alive, still working in the sex industry, but he had moved now, to Amsterdam.
*
It turned out to be easy to find the boy brothels of Amsterdam. Ask a taxi driver at the central station, walk south for five minutes into Spuistraat and look for the door plaques that make no secret of their business. And there they were. The Boys for Men Club at 44b Spuistraat, the Boys Club 21 across the road, the Blue Boy and the Why Not just next door.
Inside, they seemed at first to have a dull familiarity. There was a small, dark room with a bar full of spirits, a tiny dance floor at the far end, and some low-level rock music thumping in the background. It was nine in the evening but the place was nearly empty, just a Japanese man in a suit at the bar and a face or two at the tables in the shadows. It could have been any bar in any town, just another refuge for out-of-town businessmen.
Then the barman threw some switches, the remaining lights went down lower, the rock music came up louder, and two young men wearing nothing but groin thongs walked out on to the dance floor in a tide of dry ice. While they wriggled with the music, the Japanese man reached across the bar for a book that looked like a family photograph album and started flipping through the pages, quietly considering the pictures of naked boys inside. It was a catalogue, advertising the goods for sale.
Now, several more young men in thongs drifted into the room. One of them came and put his arm around my shoulder and smiled and told me his name was Gino. We engaged in a game of mutual deceit: he befriending me in search of my money; I leading him on in search of information about Manuel. Neither of us got very far.
He told me about the club, about the little rooms upstairs with the white towels on the beds, and the Punishment Room with the sadomasochistic gear, and the fees which started at 200vguilders ($100) an hour but if I wanted a slim young boy with fine features and dark hair, I would have to look in the book on the bar.
The Japanese man was finished with it now and was engaged in negotiations with the barman. I took the album and fingered my way through it – boys in bed, boys in jeans, boys in fields but none that looked like Manuel. The Japanese man took out his cash and headed for an appointment in a room upstairs. I left to find out more.
There proved to be no shortage of police officers and city workers in Amsterdam who knew all about the brothels in Spuistraat and who had settled into an ambiguous indifference towards them, born of deep cultural tolerance but also apparently of great indolence.
On the one hand, they insisted that all of the boys who were sold there were over 18 (just as Glandorf liked to claim in Rotterdam) and that they worked there as a matter of free and adult choice. On the other hand, they acknowledged that these brothels and bars had spawned a series of alarming scandals, because for years the Dutch government had provided no law to control them.
It remains lawful in Holland to have sex with a child as young as 12, providing that the child’s parents approve. Without the parents’ consent, it can still be lawful if the child’s sexual partner is under 21 and the courts decide that the child is happy with the relationship. In any event, the offence is lightly punished by the courts.
As to the sex industry, Dutch law claims to forbid anyone under 18 from becoming a sex worker. Until recently, however, the maximum punishment in a Dutch court for someone who was caught producing or distributing child pornography was only three months in jail. The possession of child pornography remains no offence at all.
Police and city workers described how the 1990s saw this legal vacuum suck in a hoard of foreign men whose behaviour with children had led to their being driven out of their own countries.
Many of them were English. There was Warwick Spinks who worked at Boys For Men in Spuistraat and who was caught in the UK with a 14-year-old boy whom he had found homeless on the streets of London. Spinks had taken him to his apartment in England, raped him at knifepoint, photographed him, filled him up with drugs, ferried him across the North Sea and sold him into one of the brothels on Spuistraat.
There was Alan Williams, known as the Welsh Witch, who managed Boys Club 21 and who liked to boast of the ten-year-old boy he claimed he had raped and strangled.
And there was a sequence of disturbing reports that as a subsidiary to their brothel business, these men had invested in the production of pornographic videos of a peculiarly sadistic character. Four different informers told police that in one of these videos, a young boy had been killed for the camera.
Was it possible that Manuel Schadwald had fallen into the hands of these men?
A quarter of an hour’s walk to the east, just around the corner from the Rembrandstplein, where the tourists sit in the yellow light of the international cafes, I found a short, dark alley called Paardenstraat, a seedy place with tattered posters on the walls and crumpled scraps of garbage on the sidewalk. In the shadows of the doorways, well away from the streetlights, there were knots of boys standing and smoking, spitting and speaking what turned out to be Polish.
Occasionally, one of them would peel off and dip through a lighted doorway into a bar. There were three of them – the Festival Bar, the Music Box and the Cupido – all dark, all smokey, all well supplied with boys from Poland and Romania and the Czech Republic, sitting and waiting and drinking and chewing the skin around their finger nails. There were no little rooms with beds and towels here, no catalogues, no dancing shows – only the toilet at the back or the street outside where the boys did their punters’ bidding for a few guilders a time.
This was the bottom of the drain whose opening I had found half way across Europe in the Bahnhof Am Zoo. And in this place, certainly they had heard about Manuel Schadwald. Not that they wanted to share the secret.
I spoke to Cor, who owns the Cupido, who told me he was pretty sure he had seen Manuel once with the Englishman Warwick Spinks, but very quickly he bit his words and said he could easily have been mistaken.
I found a man who looked like Fagin in a flat hat. His real name is Karel Maasdam but he is known here as Alex Privee, owner of the Bell Boys escort agency, producer of boy pornography, close friend of Lothar Glandorf. He is a clever man.
He did not try to say he had never met Manuel nor that he had never been seen down here with him. He claimed instead that he had come across a boy who looked very like this Manuel Schadwald but he had checked it out and he was sure it was only a lookalike. For all their denials, it was hard to dismiss the possibility that Manuel had been here.
Serving drinks at the Festival Bar, Ricky the transvestite said quite simply that he remembered the German boy coming in. In an unbroadcast section of his interview with Dutch TV, I found that Robbie van der Plancken had claimed that some time after being taken from Berlin by Lothar Glandorf, Manuel had been sold to the Englishman Warwick Spinks in Amsterdam. These English paedophiles had been the core investors in the Amsterdam branch of the industry.
I found one of them at home in a small, terraced house in the south of the city – a chubby, bespectacled figure with a diffident air and a surprising willingess to dish the dirt on his friends. I sat on his sofa, next to the two black-and-white photographs of himself as a proud schoolboy in uniform, while he set up his ironing board and assiduously neatened his crumpled shirts and talked about life in the boy brothels.
He knew them all. He had used them all. They were part of his life and he ruminated on them just like another man might talk about his local supermarkets. He flattened his shirts and nodded his head and said he knew that most of these places sold boys who were under 18, and that some of the men who ran them were tied up with Dutch gangsters and drug dealers, and that they had made some pretty rough videos in there and that there had been rumours for quite a while about boys being killed for the camera. “The video business hit Amsterdam like a gun going off,” he said.
He explained about the trafficking. Most of the people who were involved in running the clubs and bars would drive over to Berlin from time to time to look for new boys, he reckoned. He’d been there often himself – to the Pinocchio Bar. And, of course, there was a bit of trafficking from other cities, Frankfurt and Hamburg, for example, they were always popular. Some of these boys were well under age, he said.
He recalled his friend, Norman Dunstance, who liked boys aged between 12 and 15 – he was quite a wealthy chap – and he remembered one particular time when Norman had bought a boy off some social worker from Berlin who had come over to Amsterdam. That boy was 12, and the social worker had been looking after him and had brought him to Amsterdam for a holiday and sold him to Norman. Norman’s dead now, of course, heart attack. He was a nice chap. But that’s the way it worked really. People met people and made little deals. “It’s a spider’s web, people criss-crossing and finding interests.”
And Manuel Schadwald. Well, he had never heard the boy’s name until it started to come out in the Dutch press, but since then, he had heard a little bit about him. There was a boy – an escort who worked for Alex Privee’s agency, Bell Boys – and he had mentioned that he had seen this boy in Glandorf’s clubs in Rotterdam. And there were rumours that he had been used in videos, whether they had been made by Glandorf or by the people in Spuistraat. Perhaps that was a line worth following, he suggested, and carried on ironing.
It is a simple matter in Amsterdam to find such videos. Even though the law has changed now so that the sale of child pornography is a criminal offence, punishable with up to four years in prison, there is still a considerable reservoir of magazines and videos in private hands in the city. A couple of these, it turned out, had already been shown to Manuel Schadwald’s mother, Marion, by Dutch and German police who belatedly had taken up the search for her missing son.
One was called Steinzeitbengel – Stone Age Scamp. It had been made by a German pornographer named Sebastian Bleich who worked from a studio in Schwerin, 120 miles north of Berlin. It showed a slim, adolescent boy with dark black hair, naked, kneeling, embroiled in sex with another boy. The Dutch child psychologist, Raphael Beth, had seen the video in 1994 and thought that this might be Manuel. He had sent it via the Berlin police to Marion Schadwald, who watched it repeatedly and confessed that she could not be sure.
Her doubts were justified three years later when Sebastian Bleich was finally brought to court by the German authorities who logged the details of some 400 pornographic boy videos and who established that the boy in Steinzeitbengel was, in fact, one Patrick Moeller and that it had been recorded nine months before Manuel went missing.
The other video had no title. It showed a boy lounging naked on a sofa bed, masturbating for the camera. When this video surfaced, in November 1997, Manuel’s mother once again watched intently and this time declared that she had no doubt – this was her son. Yet when police experts examined it, they concluded that it had probably been made in Denmark in the early 1970s.
In amongst the claim and counter-claim, there was one intriguing loose end. Unknown to Marion Schadwald, this second video had surfaced after being passed through a short chain of paedophiles in Belgium and Holland, a chain which began in Rotterdam with Lothar Glandorf, who was now so strongly suspected of having harboured Manuel in his brothels. Glandorf had been accused by several boys of using them to produce pornography. Was it possible that he had used Manuel in the same way? If so, who would have made such a film?
The taps on Glandorf’s telephone revealed that Glandorf had been in touch frequently with the most prolific producer of boy pornography in Holland, Rudy van Dam.
In the old centre of Utrecht, not far from the hump-backed bridges of the Oudegracht canal, there is a short cobbled lane called Pauwstraat. It is a quiet street, lined with neat and solid homes built for the Victorian bourgeoisie, and when I knocked at the door of number five, a handsome grey-haired man with half-moon glasses came out to meet me.
He was apologetic. Rudy van Dam was not at home today, he explained; and, even if he were at home, he said, he would not feel like talking. The man with the half-moon glasses was quite sure of this. He was sorry that I had had a wasted journey. And yet, perhaps, as he listened to my explanation, as he considered the possibility that Rudy van Dam was a man who was much misunderstood, perhaps he himself might talk for just a moment.
Inside the house, the man sat down in the parlour, which was a sight of considerable strangeness. It was small and well furnished in conventional Dutch style: a sideboard, a cupboard and a large table, all of them in heavy dark wood; some brightly coloured porcelain fruit hanging on the wall; a picture here, a tapestry there; hand-made lace on the table; and on the sideboard, just behind the head of the man with the half-moon glasses, in the spot where a vase of flowers might well have sat, there was a collection of video-editing equipment, topped with a monitor screen on which two quite naked boys were having sex.
The man smiled slightly, quite indifferent to the moving display behind him, apparently oblivious, too, to the sideboard and the cupboard on his left which were clearly stuffed with video cassettes, rows and rows of them, with their hand-written titles on the spines – “Boys In Bed”, “Boys in Chains”, “Badminton Boys”, “Strip Poker Boys”, “Bravo Boys”. It took only a few minutes before the man relaxed enough to concede the obvious, that he was, in truth, himself, Rudy van Dam, professional pornographer.
He took off his glasses and let them rest on a cord on his chest and he spoke with ease and confidence, about his life and his career and about the mystery of Manuel Schadwald. He said he himself was sadly misunderstood, that he was simply a gay man who had opened his doors to boys who had nowhere else to stay and that really some of these boys were so obsessed with sex that he could hardly prevent them taking part in his videos.
All the time he talked so casually, the images of naked boys flickered frantically across the screen behind him.
He explained that he had invited the Utrecht police to hold a key to his home here so that they could come in whenever they liked, to check that none of the boys in his videos was under 18 years of age. “Look here” and he jumped up from his chair to fetch a thick file. “Look here, all identification papers for all boys, all 18 or more.”
But was it not true that he had been convicted several times of offences against children? He shook his head, a tired man in a tiresome world. There were so many misunderstandings. Yes, he had been convicted of gross indecency with a minor but that had been years ago, and it was only a technical offence. Yes, it was true he had been convicted of allowing his house to be used by men to have sex with minors, but this was a bad law that made him responsible for what other people did. And yes, he had been convicted only a few years ago of making a video with a 14-year-old boy, but the boy had lied to him. How should he have known that the boy was four years under age? So the conviction had been quashed by the court of appeal. See? He shrugged. All misunderstanding.
And Manuel Schadwald? The pornographer shrugged again. On his own estimate, he had made some 500 films in the last seven years – more than one a week, a great many boys. But he was sure he had never come across this Manuel boy. It was true that he knew Robbie van der Plancken, who was now saying on television that the missing boy was in the sex industry in Holland.
He had to admit he knew Robbie well. Robbie had made films here. He had stayed in the house for two years. Even now, Robbie was a friend and had been to visit only a few weeks before. But Robbie had never mentioned this Manuel boy. He did not think Robbie knew him really. He could not understand why he wanted to say these things on television. It was a complete mystery to him.
It was true, too, that he knew Lothar Glandorf who was supposed to have abducted this boy but now that he thought about it, he believed there was probably another boy who worked for Lothar who looked very like Manuel, a boy called Omar, who was at least 18. That was probably what had caused all the fuss, another boy who was quite legal. He smiled. Behind him, the screen flickered.
The next day, police in Rotterdam confirmed that a boy named Omar was among those who had been working for Glandorf but they added that this boy looked nothing like Manuel Schadwald.
Manuel remains lost. The police in Holland and Berlin, who finally this year mounted a special joint inquiry, say they can find no sign of him. Possibly this trail of footprints across Europe is merely a concoction of error and wishful thinking. Perhaps the unknown man who left his voice on a Berlin answer machine four years ago, claiming that little Manuel was dead, was telling the truth.
But perhaps at the end of all this, despite all the misery of his mother, Manuel is not the most important part of the picture. It is the industry itself that matters and the gathering flow of boys from the poor underbelly of Europe who have been procured as its raw material.
What Lothar Glandorf built in Rotterdam has now been expanded by new investors. At the end of the HIK inquiry, in November 1995, Glandorf was imprisoned for seven years for trafficking and abusing children, but the HIK Report recorded that “the moment that the main suspects were arrested, other club owners moved in immediately.”
In Amsterdam, many of the Englishmen who built the industry there have moved on since February 1997 when the Dutch finally made the production of child pornography a serious offence, punishable by up to four years in jail. But the brothels and bars in Spuistraat and Paardenstraat are still there, in different hands, and the paedophiles who created them have simply moved to Prague and resumed business as usual in a city where there is a ready supply of poor boys and very little law.
There is no reason to suppose that I uncovered anything like the whole picture. According to the President of Interpol, Bjorn Eriksson, there are now 30,000 active paedophiles who are linked in some way to the production of child pornography in Europe.
No one knows how many boys have been trafficked into the industry, from the Bahnhof Am Zoo or from the Pinocchio Bar in Berlin, or from poor families in Holland or Eastern Europe or elsewhere. It is a safe estimate that the number runs into thousands. Although Lothar Glandorf finally saw the inside of a prison, to this date neither Peter Goetjes nor Lutz Edelman nor any of the other traffickers has been convicted.
Looking back over this, it is tempting to see the history of police inaction as a story of corruption. That may play its part, but the reality is more significant. The sexual abuse of children is the most secret crime.
Whereas the victim of an offence against property will almost always go to the police, the child victim of abuse will frequently succumb to confusion or fear and say nothing. Whereas the adult victim of abuse can give powerful evidence of their assailant, the word of a child witness who does come forward continues to be considered suspect by justice systems all over the developed world, a problem which is aggravated by the failure of almost all of these jurisdictions to protect child witnesses from full-blooded cross-examination by highly-trained lawyers in adult courts. In other words, it is easy to indulge in the sexual abuse of children and easy to get away with it.
Sometimes, the confusion of these children will be so profound that they will begin to collude in their own abuse. It appears that Manuel Schadwald himself may be an example of this, that he may have been groomed by his abductors and coated in shame or doubt or fear until he was quite embedded him in this world.
The most frightening feature of the child prostitutes I met in England was their willingness to sell themselves. This was not because they had the most remote sexual interest in the men who were buying them but because they experience of growing up in poverty had wrecked their emotions.
This secret crime itself nestles in a framework of denial. You can see it in the policeman on the front desk who tells the mother that her missing child has surely only run away and will be back tomorrow. You can see it again in the culture of detectives who still think that bank robbers are more worthy opponents than paedophiles. Most of all, you can see it in the instinctive and entirely forgivable reaction of any reasonable outsider, that the civilised centre of Western Europe could not possibly be harbouring a network of men who are trafficking thousands of children into a paedophile industry. It is easy to miss the truth.
For those who are tempted to continue their state of denial, there is a footnote. A few weeks after he gave his anonymous television interview, Robbie van der Plancken left Holland for a holiday. He travelled to France and Italy with a Dutch businessman named Gerrit-Jan Ulrich with whom he had been living. Ulrich was a well-known customer down on Spuistraat who was said to be supplying Robbie with security, affection and considerable amounts of cash.
On Saturday, June 20, in a forest near Pisa in north-west Italy, police found Ulrich’s body. He had been shot. They arrested Robbie, who at first denied all knowledge of the death, but then agreed that he had shot him. He said it was an accident.
Several days later, at the request of the Italians, Dutch police went to Ulrich’s home in Zandvoort just outside Amsterdam where they found a collection of computer disks and CDs. On examination, they proved to hold pornographic images of children. Some of these children were adolescent, some were only four or five years old, one was so young that he was still wearing a diaper. All of these children were being used as sex objects, some were being used sadistically. In total, there were sixty thousand of them.