Let’s pretend that the two thousand grim old housing estates which now litter our inner cities are populated by men and women who have carefully calculated the relative merits of various welfare payments and then adjusted their lifestyles to maximise their income from the state.
Let’s pretend that, although life on these estates is hard, those who live there are no more vulnerable than those who live in the peace and security of, say, a village in the Cotswolds, with the result that they don’t have to live in constant fear of burglary and arson, that their children are not being sucked into prostitution and the black market in drugs, that they are not beset by depression and anxiety and stress, that they are not being pushed into the abuse of alcohol and speed and heroin and jellies and crack cocaine. Let’s pretend, in other words, that they control their lives.
In particular – because this turns out to be important – let’s pretend that the reason why so many unmarried adolescent girls have been having children is not that men poke them and then walk away, and that it has nothing to do with the fact that they live their lives as victims without planning or controlling anything, least of all contraception and abortion, and certainly that it would never have anything to do with a desperate search for affection and some dream about being happy with a baby. Let’s pretend, instead, that these girls have been systematically investing in any available local semen in order to jump the housing queue and then ruthlessly discarding their lovers in order to claim the single parents’ premium
Then let’s pretend, in the same way but on an even larger scale, that tens of thousands of unemployed young men and women are not alienated, angry and bereft of hope and that they give a toss about one of Gordon Brown’s unskilled, underpaid, temporary jobs and that they can’t earn ten times as much and score infinitely more prestige and excitement by working in their thriving local market in crack cocaine and heroin.
And so, in this way, adding one comforting dream to another, we may finally share the vision of New Labour as it confronts the greatest single domestic political issue of the next decade – the future of the millions of men, women and children who were left behind by the affluence of the last 20 years.
According to this vision, Labour will attack this new poverty by establishing a Social Exclusion Unit in the Cabinet Office under the watchful eye of Peter Mandelson and by the judicious use of reduced benefits and increased job opportunities in order to shift 250,000 single parents and young people from welfare into work.
It is a strategy which will fail to achieve its stated aim because it is constructed on a series of deeper failures.
There is, at base, a failure to acknowledge the scale of the problem, that this extends far beyond single parents or the young unemployed. It is not that Peter Mandelson does not know this. The government’s own figures, released in October, showed that 22% of the population now live below the nearest thing we have to an official poverty line: they survive on less than half of the average income of the rest of the country. This is not some statistical mirage. This involves most of the ten million men women and children who live in households where there is no wage earner and some three million others who have been swept into poverty by a tide of low pay. They live in the financial equivalent of an iron lung, encased in self-discipline, so that they never give in to temptation by spending the evening in a pub or giving their children new toys or buying new clothes or going out to the cinema. They are the 13 million poor – and most of them have been left in the wings while Mr Mandelson’s information machine pushes only single mothers and young people to the centre of the stage.
But much more important than that, there is a failure to understand the nature of this poverty, which is quite different in character from that of previous eras because of the surrounding circumstances with which it has combined: the vast and violent black market which has been created by Mrs Thatcher’s foolhardy war against drugs; the disintegration of stable communities which was provoked by the sale of council houses to absentee landlords; the surge in children excluded from education as schools who have been forced to compete in league tables reject delinquent and difficult pupils; the release of the mentally ill into communities who lack the resources to care for them; the relentless starving of the old institutions of care and control – from major bodies like social services and the police down to an entire level of community supervision which once consisted of park attendants, toilet attendants, bus conductors, petrol pump attendants – all of whom have been hammered by cuts in the public sector.
Harriet Harman apparently sees herself releasing single mothers from the trap of unemployment by restricting their benefit and offering them helpful advice. She has misunderstood the complexity of the trap. Ms Harman may cut their income to the point of starvation and offer them the best advice in the world, but what does she do when the single mothers say that they cannot go to work because their homes will be burgled if they leave them empty all day, and/or there is no one to look after their children, and/or they are addicted to heroin, and/or they have no skills, and/or they are crippled by depression, and/or they cannot get to work because they have no car and there are no buses any more?
One of the most alarming signs of the new poverty is the explosion of prostitution. In London, for example, the Vice Squad say that it has spread from the West End, where it was once contained, into every borough inside the M25 motorway. Poverty did that. With her present vision, Ms Harman will do it some more.
All this, in turns, relects a theoretical failure. New Labour and its cheerleaders in the universities and the press have bought the idea of ‘welfare dependency’, which contends that the symptoms of poverty have been created not by material hardship but by the easy availability of state handouts. The theory is self-serving in that it allows the affluent to justify more cuts to the welfare state which in turn will pay for more cuts in their own taxes.
It was produced by pundits and propagated by politicians who literally do not know what they are talking about – people who visit grim housing estates only rarely and officially, who have never seen the inside of a crack house or talked to the children who now sell their bodies on the streets of just about every city in this country or mixed with the gangs of wild kids who terrorise run-down neighbourhoods. These are invariably the same pundits who preached the discredited theories of the 1980s, of monetarism and trickle-down economics. Proved wrong, they have simply moved on, like sheep grazing too greedily to look around them.
Their claim to the truth of welfare dependency is entirely theoretical. However, the evidence that they are wrong is entirely real. Take, for example, the position of the unemployed 16 to 18-year-olds from whom Mrs Thatcher removed the general right to all benefits in 1986. If the theory of welfare dependency were right, these young people – finally liberated from the chains of welfare – would have found themselves jobs, opened up small businesses, signed on for colleges, generally learned to stand on their own two feet. None of this happened. On the contrary, those who warned her that she would simply push these young people out on to the streets and into crime and prostitution and begging, have been proved – unsurprisingly – to be right.
Gordon Brown is now poised to repeat the error, cutting benefits for those under 25 who resist the jobs which he offers them, apparently oblivious to the vast criminal enterprise of crack cocaine which is waiting with open doors to provide an alternative source of employment for those whom he punishes.
The reality is that New Labour cannot manipulate the poor back to work simply by flicking the switches of the benefits machine. The damage is deeper than that. The problem they are trying to address is much bigger and much more complicated than that. Their solution needs, too, to be bigger and more complicated.
Their real difficulty is that they are trying to solve the problem without attacking the policies which created it. They have no political appetite at all to review the war against drugs, the worst single social policy error since the war; and the appointment of Keith Hellawell as ‘drugs tsar’ is an alarming evasion. Equally, they are not about to review the sale of public housing, the use of league tables in schools, the release of the mentally ill into the community or any of the disastrous policy fall-out from the last 20 years.
But, most of all, they are explicitly and apparently irredeemably committed to making no change to the economic and fiscal policies which created the underlying poverty from which all this damage has flowed. This leaves them struggling to deliver the impossible, to cure poverty without redistributing wealth. They may claim that they can, but the truth is that they are just pretending.