The mugging that robbed the law of its credibility

The Guardian, 21 December 1995

One quiet summer’s night this year, there was an incident in north London which captured, with almost perfect symbolism, not only the violence which has now be come a routine part of British life but also the paralysis of policy which has become a routine reaction to its occurrence.

It was about a quarter to eight, and a man was parking his car in a quiet residential road called Albert Street, which runs through the edge of Camden Town, near Regent’s Park. It is an elegant street with Volvos and Saabs parked under the trees and security bars on some of the basement windows.

The man was a well-dressed businessman, and he was manoeuvring a powerful car, an Audi 80, into an empty space. He picked up his brief case, stepped on to the pavement, locked the car door, and turned to walk the short distance down the road to his house, where his wife was waiting for him. Suddenly he was In deep trouble.

Half-a-dozen young men had surrounded him. Two of them started to push him. They demanded money, and he decided to co-operate, but he had no time, and before he had a chance to run or fight, several of them laid into him, leaning over each other to get at him, thumping and punching. Then they were gone.

For a moment he thought he was all right. He had lost his wallet, which was upsetting and a nuisance, but at least he was still in one piece. It was only when a woman ran over to help him and pointed to his red-stained shirt that he realised someone had stabbed a hole in his stomach.

To an outsider’s eye, this was merely another nasty scene on the streets of Britain – violence practised not simply for gain but also for the hell of it, not in some far-away ghetto but in the supposedly safe haven of a middle-class neighbourhood.

This was nothing unusual for Camden. On the streets of the same borough, earlier that month, gangs of youths had all but sliced a man’s ear off with a machete; smashed the head of a 14-year-old boy with a snooker cue; and battered a man so badly his pelvis shattered. A few hours before the stabbing in Albert Street, on that same quiet summer’s night, a group of young men had tried to attack an Asian motorist in the Daewood centre, been unable to get their hands on him and knocked all hell out of his car instead.

This was nothing unusual for Britain in general, where a crime of violence is now committed, on average, some 35 times every hour of every day and every night. Since 1979 the level of violence has soared upwards: the number of violent robberies, for example, has increased from 12,500 to 62,700 each year.

However, the point which would have escaped an outsider’s view – and the point which makes this incident so peculiarly symbolic – is the identity of the businessman who was attacked. He is John Mills, the husband of the Director of Public Prosecutions, Barbara Mills QC, and when finally he staggered to his doorstep, it was the most senior law-enforcement figure in the country who opened the door and reeled in horror at the sight of her wounded husband.

If violent crime is spinning out of control then, according to government policy, it is up to Mrs Mills and the criminal justice system to stop it. But the symbolism goes farther than that.

Apart from running his own distribution business, Mills is also a local Labour politician, one of the most senior members of Camden council. If there is an alternative to the Government’s hard-line law-and-order school of thought, it is most clearly represented by Labour-controlled urban authorities like Camden, which wants to use social services to attack the perceived causes of crime: the poverty and inequality and absolute hopelessness of life on the old council estates.

The message which emerges from this incident is the same as that which came loud and clear last week from the riot in Brixton; or the week before from the death of the London headmaster, Philip Lawrence, who was stabbed to death outside his own school gates; or from any of the other violent horrors on our streets: the forces of law and order are fighting a brave but losing battle.

Seen in close-up, the incident is a model of violent crime and an anatomy of police impotence. Anyone who is knifed in the stomach is likely to receive a swift response from the emergency services, but on the evening of May 30, as the identity of this particular victim became known, the police went off like a rocket.

A major incident room was opened with a dedicated Holmes computer system; a senior detective took over the inquiry with a team of CID officers and numerous uniformed men and women in support; the paperwork was handled at a high level in the Crown Prosecution Service. According to one of those closely involved, the operation was “completely without precedent for a mugging”. And yet it failed.

It began well enough. Uniformed police found three people in Albert Street who had seen what had happened and started driving them around the area in search of suspects. From behind the darkened windows of police vans, they pointed out youths who looked familiar and, within an hour, the police had arrested 13 young men. Since there were only six youths involved in the attack, it was clear some of these identifications were wrong. However, one of them, at least, was correct.

At the foot of Albert Street, about three-quarters of an hour after the incident, a teenaged girl in a police van pointed out two young men who, she said, had attacked Mills. The police searched them and, on one of them, a 17-year-old Filipino named Bernard Enerio, they found a blood-stained knife and Mills’s black leather wallet. Enerio rapidly confessed he had been involved and told the police how he and his friends had drifted almost carelessly into the attack. It was a tale of deadly boredom.

He and his friends had been wandering around all day, he said. About 20 of them had travelled up to Camden Town with half an idea that they would visit a friend who lived nearby, but then six of them had decided to go for a run instead. So while the others went on to the friend’s house, the six of them had hung on in the street but then they had changed their minds and decided to buy some sweets instead.

Enerio said he knew some of his friends had done a bit of robbing before. One of them had stolen some sweets from a shop by running out of the door without paying. A couple of them had done the same thing in a sports shop in King’s Cross. But he’d never done it himself.

Anyway, he explained, they had bought their sweets and, as they were coming out of the shop, one of his mates had spotted this man parking this really nice car. This particular boy, who was quite a bit bigger than him, had turned to him and told him to give him his knife.

It wasn’t exactly Enerio’s knife. He had stolen it from his friend, Sam, a week or so earlier. He had been carrying it ever since. He didn’t have any particular reason for carrying it. He was just showing off: it was a Japanese knife with a little Ninja symbol on it.

So they walked by this nice car just as this man was getting out on to the pavement. Enerio said he had walked several paces past him before he realised that two of his mates – including the one with his knife – had started laying into the man, and he didn’t know why, he had no particular reason, but he had turned round and joined in. He had thumped the man in the face. The man was so much taller than him that he had to jump up to do it.

Then they had all run off and dived into this block of council flats about a I00 yards away, and one of the bigger lads had taken all the cash out of the wallet and then told Enerio to hide the wallet and the blood-stained knife in his jacket. He was a bit scared of them by now, so he had done as he was told.

Then they weren’t sure what to do. They thought maybe they’d go and join the others at their friend’s house nearby, but then they thought they might go to Burger King, but then they went to McDonald’s instead, and then they just went back in the street, for no particular reason, and they were just walking along Mornington Crescent wondering where their friends’ house was when they were stopped by the police.

The police believed Enerio’s story – it fitted with everything else they knew – but they told him it seemed pretty stupid to just hang around the area where they had attacked a man: they were bound to get caught. Enerio didn’t really have an answer to that. He wasn’t much of a criminal.

In the course of his confession, Enerio gave police the names of the five other young men who, he said, were involved in the attack. He identified one of them as the knife man. However, just as the inquiry seemed to be going so well, it hit the buffers.

The police had two lines of evidence against the five youths, but both of them were worthless. They had their eye witnesses, but more than half of their identifications had been wrong, and none of them had been made under approved conditions. And they had Enerio, but he was going to plead not guilty to robbery, so they could hardly present him as a witness of truth.

The police pulled in all five of the young men, but they denied having any part in the attack on Mills. They were carrying nothing to link them (though several were carrying unrelated stolen property). There was no blood stain or fibre or other scientific evidence to incriminate them. There was, in short, no evidence.

The police released them on ball and then called them back some weeks later so that Mills, who was now recovered, and the other witnesses could see them on an identification parade. Not one witness picked any of them out.

By this time, the seriousness of the crime had become clear as doctors at the Royal Free Hospital reported that the knife had severed Mills’s epigastric artery and pierced his liver. He had lost more than two pints of blood, and it was only as a result of an emergency operation that he had been prevented from bleeding to death. And yet, the police had no choice. They charged Bernard Enerrio with robbery and unlawful wounding and they let everyone else go free. Whoever he was, the man who nearly killed the DPP’s husband had got away with it.

Twenty years ago, it might have been different. If Camden police had given their suspects a good battering or questioned them relentlessly for days on end; if they had ‘verballed’ them by making up confessions; if they had grabbed at a fleeting glimpse from a witness and called it an identification; if they had indulged in any of the bad old ways, they might well have been able to manufacture a charge.

But after the scandals of Maxwell Confait and George Davis and the famous IRA miscarriages, the rules have changed, and, despite all the frustration that policemen very often express in private, there are few who seriously want to turn back the clock. The truth is that without resorting to barbarism, there is a limit to what the police can do. And that is the real message of this incident.

Professor David Dennison of Glasgow University chaired an inquiry into Crime and Social Policy for Nacro, the National Association for the Care and Resettlement of Offenders. He says the forces of law and order are easily losing the battle against crime. “More investment in police and courts and penal services is irrelevant to the prevention of crime. These are necessary and respected institutions which help to manage crime once it has occurred but they do not prevent it.”

In real terms, national spending on police has all but doubled since 1979, from £1,149 million to £6,987 million – an increase, after inflation, of 97.5 per cent. And yet, according to the Home Office’s own surveys of the victims of crime, only 2 per cent of crimes are cleared up.

Anecdotal evidence suggests that more and more often, victims simply fail to report crimes. In the face of those that are reported, police often lack the resources to mount an investigation; if they do investigate, they may well fail to find suspects; and, even if they do find credible suspects, as they did in the case of John Mills, they may be unable to produce workable evidence to secure a conviction.

Professor Dennison urges the government to attack crime in the long term by attacking unemployment and in the short term by putting training and resources into crime-ridden estates so that they can work on solutions themselves instead of relying on the police.

Even as Mills was being attacked, a group of his constituents were meeting less than half a mile away in a theatre hall in Crowndale Road, calling on the council to find a new policy for young people to ease the tension on their estates. One of their spokesmen, Harvey Bass, said there was a desperate need for money for facilities to take young people off the street. He told the Camden Chronicle: “Something is going to happen. We are sitting on a volcano.”

The council apologised. It was doing all it could, with a grand total of only £27,780 for spending on youth groups. The vice-chair of education, Councillor Penny Abraham, told the meeting: “It is very difficult. Each area has its problems. We wish we had more money.”

The difficulty for police is that, if a society has reached such a state of chaos and alienation that young people stab businessmen with the same casual clumsiness with which they steal toffees out of sweet shops; if a headmaster really isn’t safe in his own school; if all it takes to start a riot is a couple of loud-mother agitators, all the commissioner’s horses and all of his men really don’t have a hope. While the Government sticks to its law-and-order philosophy, a lot more young men with flash knives will get away with a lot more crime.