There is a point in most miscarriages of justice when a prosecutor becomes deliberately dishonest, hiding inconvenient facts, fabricating helpful ones in order to strengthen a bogus case. But miscarriages usually do not begin with dishonesty. More often, they are born of incompetence, a simple inability to find the real culprit.
And there is a reason for that: British detectives are not taught to detect. While their counterparts in the American FBI are sent off to Quantico, Virginia to learn their skills, British detectives are expected to pick it all up as they go along. From time to time they may be sent off to Bramshill Police College to learn about some speciality such as computers but they are never systematically taught how to do the job.
The case of the Lincoln axe-murderer, which ended this week, reveals these problems, not because the detective failed to find his man, but because he did so where most others would have failed. Stuart Clifton happens to be naturally very sharp. He is the detective who followed an obscure trail of chemical clues to uncover Nurse Beverly Allitt as she attacked children at Grantham Hospital.
In the case of the axe-murderer, Clifton started with no clues at all. There was simply Fred Maltby, a reclusive old man who lived alone in a farmhouse on the edge of Lincoln and who was found dead on the morning of October 2 1991. He was slumped in his armchair, apparently sitting peacefully, with four deep gashes swiped into the top of his scalp.
Clifton, who is a detective superintendent, did what he could but he made painfully slow progress. There was no obvious motive for Fred Maltby’s murder. Nothing of any great value was missing from his house. There were no fingerprints and no footprints. Clifton could find no witnesses of any kind. He appealed for help in the local press but heard almost nothing.
He reckoned it looked as though Maltby had known his killer: there was no sign of a break-in and he was apparently sitting quietly in his chair when he was attacked. Yet his elderly sister said he was unmarried, he had no close friends and he had never even had anyone to work for him on the little farm he owned.
There was only one tantalising hint of what had really happened to Fred Maltby. The killer had evidently stepped back from the murder and laid his weapon down on the sofa before picking it up and walking out into the darkness, leaving behind on a cushion a silhouette in blood of a full-sized axe. It was Clifton’s only clue. He took the cushion to his scientists but they could only tell him that the axe was square at one end and tapered at the other. He booked a slot on BBC Crimewatch and asked for help, but although he took 120 calls, none of the leads took him anywhere.
Clifton was still scratching in the dust when the killer found another victim, on a stormy night in January 1992. A bookmaker named Joe Rylatt, aged 62, was found on the floor of his betting shop in south Lincoln with the same pattern of jagged, red slash marks in the top of his head. And this time, Clifton found something to work on. Deep in the wounds in Rylatt’s scalp lay tiny fragments of paint which appeared to have fallen from the axe head.
Clifton sent them to the police lab and scoured the rest of the case for more leads. This time, there was a motive. The door to Rylatt’s safe was hanging open and there was something like £3,000 missing. And there were possible suspects. Rylatt was a womaniser. Clifton found his diary, with the names of his women friends, and started discreetly approaching them in search of an angry husband. It took him nowhere and, in the meantime, the police lab came back to say that the paint fragments contained a lot of zinc, but more than that they couldn’t say.
Searching through Rylatt’s possessions, Clifton’s men had found a small stash of stolen goods which the bookie was apparently fencing for local thieves. Clifton made more discreet inquiries, looking now for a burglar with a grudge. He still refused to give up on the paint fragments and started asking obsessively about the manufacture of paint.
By the time that he had established that no local burglar had attacked Joe Rylatt, Clifton had come up with a contact at an obscure body named the British Paint Research Foundation in Teddington, south London. And, in Rylatt’s papers, he continued to find more suspects, lists of people who had borrowed money from him when the banks refused them credit. His men combed through them, but there was no obvious suspect. The specialists at Teddington had not come up with anything, Clifton was contemplating a trip to Germany to check a register of paints there, when his luck finally turned.
Four boys who were boating on a lake had scrambled onto a little island and found an axe. They had heard Clifton’s appeals for help and so they handed it in to the police. It was blunt at one end, tapered at the other and, on close inspection, it turned out to have fragments of paint on the head – and traces of Joe Rylatt’s blood.
Clifton immediately sent more fragments of paint to the police lab, hoping that the sample now would be big enough to yield something. Again they said No. So he tried once more with the Paint Research Foundation in Teddington and this time, they came up with something. “It’s nothing much,” they said. “We can’t tell you what the paint is. But we can tell you what holds it together.”
They had found traces of an unusual binding agent, named Epoxyester D4. It was manufactured in Essen in Germany. They had also noticed that the zinc in the paint was not new, it was reconstituted. It was not much, but Clifton had nothing else to work with, so he went for it.
From Essen, he started to trace the distribution lines of the binding agent, which was sold into paint factories in other parts of Germany and in France and in Belgium and in Holland. He tracked the chemical from country to country, from factory to factory, always asking two questions: do you use this binding agent in a paint that contains reconstituted zinc; and do you export it to Britain?
It took weeks of tripping in and out of foreign tongues, repeatedly running into dead ends, until one fine day, he discovered a factory in Holland that not only made the right kind of zinc-based paint but also sold it to Britain.They had made just one shipment to Britain, through an agency in Wolverhampton. Now, Clifton knew he was on to something.
In Wolverhampton, the shippers scoured through their records. There was only one firm anywhere near Lincoln to whom they had sold the paint, a building supplier named Hykeham Forum in the suburbs of the city. They had sold them 36 tins. When the detectives went to Hykeham Forum, they discovered that 12 of the tins were still on the shelves there – and all the other 24 had been sold to a firm next door, which had only a couple of dozen staff, which meant that Stuart Clifton now had a couple of dozen potential suspects.
Checking through the names and details of the staff, Clifton noticed one name that was vaguely familiar: Denis Granville Smalley, an engineer, then aged 48. They had questioned him earlier in the inquiry. He was one of the people who had borrowed money from Joe Rylatt – and the detectives who had been to see him had not liked his manner. He had given them an alibi for the night of Joe Rylatt’s murder. He said he had been babysitting while his wife was out at work. But had he lied?
Smalley was now a suspect. And within days, Stuart Clifton was sure he was the right man. He discovered that Smalley had once worked part-time for Fred Maltby, the dead farmer. Maltby’s sister had told them her brother had never hired anyone, but she had meant full-time not part-time. Smalley was the only person who the police could link to both murder victims.
Having found his prime suspect, Clifton now set officers to trawl through his background, and they came back with two startling bits of information. First, they found that Smalley was drowning in debt, dodging banks and building societies, to whom he owed nearly £25,000 and yet, within days of Joe Rylatt being killed and robbed, Denis Smalley had suddenly had enough to cash to start paying off debts.
Then, Clifton’s team found Mrs May. She lived opposite Denis Smalley and she didn’t like him. She couldn’t help noticing how he used to go out at night and leave his children alone in the house. She thought something ought to be done about it, and so she had started to keep a record of his comings and goings. And on the night that Joe Rylatt died, she had spotted Smalley leaving the house at five past eight and then returning at ten to ten. Clifton knew that Joe Rylatt had been murdered between half past eight and ten o’clock.
Clifton now arrested Smalley, who denied everything but when they searched his house, his men found a pot of paint in his garage – made of reconstituted zinc and Epoxyester D4.
Clifton believed that Smalley had killed both men in search of money to pay off his debts. He had chosen Fred Maltby because he had heard rumours that the old man had sold some of his farmland for a quarter of a million pounds and that he kept the cash at home. The rumour was wrong. He had chosen Joe Rylatt because he knew he kept cash from his betting shop in his safe.
At Lincoln Crown Court this week, Stuart Clifton watched as Denis Smalley was convicted unanimously of both murders. It was a good moment for a detective, spoiled only by one thing.
In its efforts to restore public confidence in criminal justice without making any fundamental changes in the system, the Home Office has ruled that all detectives must be moved out of CID after four years. The result is that, regardless of his 25 years experience and his unusual understanding of detective work, Detective Superintendent Stuart Clifton is being put back into uniform.