In the early hours of Monday morning, January 3, five small boys from Leeds were taken into care. They were brothers, aged between six months and six years, their mother was only 22, and they lived together in a council house which was said to be so dirty, so littered with dog mess, that police were physically sick at the smell and senior social workers compared it to a toilet.
It was not a big story but it ran in all the nationals – another case of Home Alone At Christmas, another horror story from the underclass, another single mother spawning children at the expense of the state, another good reason to go back to basic family values. In reality, however, it was not quite like that.
The story was catapulted into the headlines by sheer fluke. The foster parents who were called in to look after four of the boys were due to appear on BBC Radio Leeds later that Monday and when they phoned the radio show’s presenter to explain that they couldn’t appear because they had suddenly inherited four more children, he told them to come on in and tell everyone about it. So they did. That night, Radio Leeds piped it down the line to Radio Four’s Today programme and, by Tuesday morning, it was a national story.
Back in Leeds, the social workers could hardly believe it. There was nothing special about the case at all. In an average week, they were used to dealing with 50 cases of children in need of protection – 2,500 of them a year – some not so bad but some much worse than this one. And when they saw the angle that the story was taking, they began to feel angry.
According to one senior official: “This was not a Home Alone case at all. The mother was with the children all the time. The concern here was neglect, and society reacts in a very odd way to cases of neglect. People prefer not to know about it. Sex abuse is different: they can blame someone. But with neglect they can’t, because it is linked to poverty and to changes in the benefit system, and people do not want to admit that. It opens up too many questions. So, if a case like does this does become public, they look for scapegoats – either the parents or the social services.” In this case, it was the parent.
From the dual carriageways that sweep through the suburbs of Leeds, the sprawling red-brick housing estates look like the models of welfare planning which they were when they were built in the 1950s and 60s. Closer up, they are a portrait of deprivation.
The house where Tina Sampson lives has two front windows on the ground floor; both of them are boarded up. The chunks of broken glass still lie where they fell on the concrete path in front of the house with a couple of broken beer cans and an old towel. The back garden is littered with the remains of two burned-out cars and several charred bed frames. Inside, there are holes in the hall walls that go clean through the brick work, puddles of water in the bathroom from three leaking pipes, mould running up the front wall, no source of heat in any of the upstairs rooms, no carpets, no curtains, no lampshades, no wallpaper, almost no furniture.
But this place is the end of the story, not the beginning. Tina Sampson’s troubles began in 1979, just at the start of the great sea change in social policy that was to transform her surroundings. That was the year that her mother put her into care. She was seven. “My mam broke up with my father, and he went off and I never seen him. She got another man, and he used to batter me. She did try and stop him, but he just wanted to batter me. So I got took into care and I never saw my mam for three years then. She had four more children, but they all stayed with her.
“I was in care till I was 13. I had seven different foster parents. I’d get one lot, and then they’d need to take in some different children so I had to move on to make room. There was one lot of foster parents I was with for three years, but when I was 13, they said I had to choose. Either I could stay with the foster parents or go back to my mam. So I went back to my mam. Wrong choice.”
She swivels her head away to stare at the bare plaster on the wall for a moment. She is very thin with pinched cheeks and baggy blue Levis. “I was leading a normal life when I was 12 or 13. I was a right little snob really but I had nice things and a nice house. When I came back here, I just got scruffy. I went down hill. I suppose it’s my fault for mixing with the wrong people. When I came back, I wasn’t close to my mam. We used to have arguments, and I’d go right up against her. I’d say ‘All right, hit me if you’re gonna hit me.’ The social workers got involved. I’ve had social workers all my life – loads of different ones.
“I started to skive off school. I used to take overdoses of paracetamol so I could get time off school. I had my stomach pumped three times. Since I were taken off me mam, when I was little, I’ve always had a certain thing for dying. I used to cut myself, slash my arm.”
She rolls back her left sleeve and twists the underside of her forearm into the light of the naked bulb that hangs down from the ceiling. There must be 50 scars there and she points them out, the ones that dug right down into the thin blue vein until the ambulance came, the ones that were only looking for attention.
“The first time I fell pregnant, I were still at school. I were 16. Everything changed for me when I had kids. I had something to do. You know? It weren’t just me on me own any more. I don’t know if I loved the boy’s father. It was half and half really. With me never having had a father when I was a kid, I was more into my boyfriends being one for me. He was 23, this one, quite a bit older than me. But he never wanted to stay. He was always off behind the sheds with me mates. Shagging. So that was that, really.”
She looks away again. “They’ve all got different fathers, my boys. Some of them had jobs and some of them didn’t. None of them wanted to settle down. Except one -the father of the third. We was going to get married. We was together a year or two and then one day I caught him in bed with me best mate and I threw him out. So…”
All the time she talks, she flicks the end of her cigarette, hardly bothering to smoke it, while the ash floats down to the dusty boards below. “I had trouble with looking after my first boy. I had stitches and piles and backache and I could hardly move and so my mam had to take over. Then my second one didn’t want to eat, he couldn’t get his food down and he kept being sick, so the health visitor said I should let my mam try with him, so she took over with him, too. They’re still my kids, still call me mam, but she looks after them. It was the same thing with the next two.
“I did have my own house for a while and I lived there with my third child. It was good there. I had a shagpile carpet and a cooker and a fridge and a washer, and there was a carpet in the boy’s room with all clowns and aeroplanes on it. Then I got burgled and they nicked it all. They didn’t take the shagpile carpet. But they nicked everything else and the water boiler, too, and when they was carrying it out, they spilled all oil and water all over the carpet, so it was ruined. I had to chuck it out. I had trouble with the neighbours and all. One of them used to batter her kids and I told her if she did it again, I’d bloody batter her, so she got all her mates on me. I just jacked it in and went back to my mam.”
Social workers have been involved with Tina continually since 1988. One of her boyfriends had a conviction for sexually abusing children and whenever he moved into the house, they registered the children as being at risk of sexual abuse. But, for the most part, they believed the family could survive as long as Tina’s mother was there to hold the loose ends together. It was in the summer of last year that it began to drift into its final crisis. That was when Tina gave birth to her fifth boy, Jason. She had moved in with a boyfriend called Donnie who thought he was the baby’s father. “I told him loads of times that he wasn’t, but he just wouldn’t take it in.” Donnie, who was only ten years old when he was first locked away for theft and violence, insisted that Jason belonged to him. When Tina tried to leave, she says, he threatened her.
“He’s always threatening me. I’ve broken up with him loads of times and he comes round threatening me, and my mam says ‘Look, we won’t get no peace till you go back with him.’ So I have to go with him. Then we break up again. It was him that broke the windows at the front of the house. He’s burned out stolen cars in the back garden, just chucks petrol at them and lights them to wind us up. He could have set the house on fire. He always makes trouble for me. I really hate him. And he’s not my baby’s dad.”
As Christmas approached, Donnie stepped up the pressure. “He was phoning ambulances to come up here and calling out the fire brigade and ordering taxis to come out here and pick me up. Just winding me up. Then he starts sending the police round. He told them there was drugs here. Then he told them there was stolen property here. So we get the CID up here asking loads of questions.”
Shortly before Christmas, she says, Donnie came up with a new tactic. “He started getting on to the police and telling them there was five kids left alone here, and then they’d come round and see me and my mam here and they’d go away. I don’t know why they listen to him. He always tell them he’s the baby’s dad. But he wasn’t. I know he wasn’t. He was in prison when I fell pregnant.”
But Donnie persisted and went to court to apply for an order for Jason to live with him. He lost. His lawyer applied for an interim order. Donnie lost again. Social workers and health visitors were still in and out of the house. On November 6, all five boys were examined by a doctor and found to be in good health. Visiting social workers found that the children were well-dressed and warm and that conditions, though poor, were adequate, although on the most recent visit, on Thursday December 30, Tina’s mother was fed up and threatening to leave.
The next day, Tina’s mother moved to another daughter’s house in search of peace. Two days later, on Sunday January 2, the crisis broke when, shortly after mid-day, Donnie turned up at the house once more. “He said he wanted to take the baby out. I thought, what with all these courts cases he was bringing, it would help me out if I let him. So I said he had to wait while I bathed him and changed his clothes but he wouldn’t wait, he said he had a taxi standing there, so he just took the baby. He never even took his milk.
“I told him to get him back by three. But he never turned up, so I started to get worried and I called the social workers and they said he’d taken the baby to hospital for nappy rash. I said I was treating it with baby cream. It was his fault, he wouldn’t let me change the baby’s clothes. I tried to get the baby from the hospital, but he’d taken him away by then. So I called the police and put them on to him. The next thing I knew, about midnight, they was on my doorstep and I says ‘Where’s my baby?’ and they say “You’re not having your baby, you haven’t been looking after him, you’re not getting him back.’”
There are different versions of the argument that followed. The police say Tina then ran out of the house and could not be found. Tina says the police ordered her out of the house because she was trying to stop them taking her other children. The police say they had to hunt for her for 48 hours. She says she was standing on the street corner in the cold. “I was just crying me eyes out there. I didn’t know what to do. About half past one, I saw ‘em bring my boys out. I could see ‘em all in the back of the car. I was screaming and crying. I didn’t know what to do.”
The next morning, the foster parents broke the story on Radio Leeds. By the time it reached the national newspapers, it had taken on a momentum of its own. Many reports suggested the children had been ‘home alone’. The Daily Telegraph produced the most extravagant account: “A young mother left her five children, all under the age of seven, to fend for themselves in appalling squalor for four days.” In spite of the evidence of social workers, The Independent reported that after being taken into care, “the children were given warm clothing, fed and bathed – possibly for the first time in weeks”.
The most shocking element in the story was the dog mess, which was said to have been spread throughout the house and over the children. Tina says that her sister’s puppy had made a mess in two of the bedrooms, that she had kept telling her sister to clear it up and was leaving it because it was her puppy. “It wasn’t all over the house. The downstairs was just like normal. I clean, I wash, I look after my kids. I’m not some rich snob, but I’m not dirty either.” Some papers reported that the children had been naked in the street, begging for food, but the same papers described Tina’s two sisters, who were living in the house, as men. These reports appear to have come from neighbours.
The courts issued interim care orders, sending the four oldest boys to a foster family and – to Tina’s despair – ordering that the baby Jason should stay with Donnie’s family. Social workers are now preparing detailed reports on the family for court hearings, which are due in February. The Social Services Department will not discuss the case, but they are clear about its context.
The city’s Social Services chairman, Councillor Michael Simmons, said: “We have seen a steady increase in poverty and a steady dismantling of the benefit system. The whole system has got tighter. They now get no benefits at all for their children aged 16 to 18. If their cooker blows up, they used to get a grant to replace it. Now all they get is a loan and they have to pay that back out of income support, which is, by definition, already at the level of poverty. This is deprivation. And I am afraid that deprivation and neglect go hand in hand.
“People in these circumstances become depressed – clinically depressed. Their physical health suffers: they eat bad food and wear inadequate clothing. They all suffer stress – children as well as adults. We have a young boy now who is literally chewing the ends off his fingers, breaking the flesh, drawing blood. We have numerous homes who live without electricity or gas, because the new privatised companies have put them on meters and they simply don’t have the cash to pay for fuel. In a few cases, we find they don’t even have water; they’re running a hose pipe from the house next door.
“Their kids can’t go to school because they can’t afford school meals or proper clothing, and they don’t have the know-how or the money or the energy to drag five children across Leeds to fill in complicated forms to get help. And now the schools have started turning them away. Since schools have been compiling league tables, there are head teachers in this city who are deliberately excluding children like this to avoid damaging their statistics. Some of these children just can’t cope with school. There was one family who simply couldn’t communicate. The children just cried all the time. Why? They were extremely unhappy. And who can blame them?
“It all flows from this extraordinary idea that we have to give rich people an incentive to work by giving them more money and poor people an incentive to work by taking money away from them. These people are not evil. If they’re bad parents, it’s not because they don’t care about their children. It is because they cannot cope.
“We see cases like this every day of every week. You are talking about a fairly routine occurrence, but it is an area which most people are quite happy to ignore. They leave it to one side until they become sentimental at Christmas. It’s the puppy dog syndrome.”
Tina Sampson sits alone in the bare bones of her house, behind the boarded windows. Her mother has not come back. She has no pictures of the children; she has never had a camera. She has nothing to do: there was a television but someone stole it after Christmas. The troublesome puppy has been given away. She’s dragged her few sticks of furniture and scraps of tired carpet out into the garden to burn them, in case anyone says they’re too dirty to be near children. She wants to get drunk and cut her arm, but she can’t in case anyone says that proves she’s a bad mother.
The other night, she was asleep on a mattress in the front room and she woke herself up because she was crying in her sleep. It was about half past four in the morning and there was no one around and, anyway, she knew by then that no one was interested in what she thought. So she took a biro and she went to the bare plaster wall of the chimney breast in her front room, and wrote the names of her five boys. Then she wrote them again, and again. Finally, she wrote in square capital letters “I love my kids” and then again “I want my kids” as if somebody might see it and do something for her.
* The names of Tina Sampson, Jason and Donnie have been invented to conceal the identity of the children.