Renewed calls for a public inquiry into the Allitt case in which four children were murdered in hospital, were rejected yesterday after the Master of the Rolls said he believed the private hearings would be fair.
The Court of Appeal refused a plea by the families of the victims and two hospital staff unions for the right to challenge the decision by Virginia Bottomley, the Health Secretary, not to order a public inquiry with statutory powers to compel attendance of witnesses and production of documents.
Sir Thomas Bingham, the Master of the Rolls, said he had no doubt the inquiry being conducted by the former ombudsman, Sir Cecil Clothier, would wish to be scrupulously fair. Sir Cecil had gone a long way to reassure the interested parties, he added. “I hope that the concerns aired at this court hearing have now been in large measure alleviated.”
Mrs Bottomley decided Trent regional health authority should set up an independent inquiry after Beverley Allitt was jailed for life. She was found guilty at Nottingham crown court of killing four children, trying to murder three, and assaulting six others while nursing on a children’s ward at Grantham and Kesteven hospital, Lincolnshire between February and April 1991.
Mrs Bottomley said the findings would be published; Sir Cecil could ask for wider powers; and witnesses could make their evidence public.
The families, the Royal College of Nursing and the health union Cohse argued that a fully-empowered open investigation was the only way to restore confidence and protect staff who might face criticism. They accused Mrs Bottomley of allowing the question of cost to dominate her thinking in choosing the least significant form of inquiry open to her.
Sir Thomas rejected suggestions that Mrs Bottomley regarded the interests of Trent health authority as paramount and said she had been entitled to take into account the question of cost. There was virtue in taking evidence voluntarily rather than compelling witnesses to attend.
Later, the Royal College of Nursing said it had won concessions for witnesses. They would be given an indication of the areas the inquiry wishes to cover; have any potential points of criticism put to them while giving evidence; have the right to respond if criticised later in the inquiry; and the right to see and respond to the part of the report which relates to them before it is submitted.
Christine Hancock, the RCN general secretary, and Anne Alexander. the families’ solicitor, said they were disappointed but the challenges were successful because of the concessions.
Mrs Bottomley said in a statement: “The questions which the parents of Allitt’s victims and which the Royal College of Nursing and Cohse want answered are the same questions that I want answered.”