Ward Four of Grantham and Kesteven Hospital was always a quiet place. Children used to go there with runny noses and broken arms and leave a day or two later with a grin and a badge saying they’d been brave.
So, in the spring of 1991 when Nurse Beverly Allitt attacked children there on 26 occasions in only 58 days, it was plain to all who worked on the ward that there was something desperately wrong. Yet nobody stopped her. The hospital’s failure – with all that it says about the management of the National Health Service – has fuelled a deep anger in the parents of Nurse Allitt’s victims.
They have spent two years living with confusion and distress and now they want nothing more than to retreat to their homes to grieve, but they say they cannot begin to recover while they fear that the health authorities are trying to conceal the truth.
If Beverly Allitt had worked anywhere other than in a hospital, her success in evading detection would not be so surprising. It is true that she was well-disguised – cloaked in the trust that doctors and patients alike bestow on nurses – but still she was working under the noses of the very people who ought to have made her crimes impossible, people who were trained and equipped to understand sudden illness.
Beverly Allitt always had a special talent for uncovering the weak points in those around her; and in getting away with murder, she exploited weaknesses all over Grantham Hospital.
The entire machine turned out to be running on moving parts which were worn out and tired. Under the normal stress of routine hospital life, they were more or less able to cope, but, confronted with a crisis, they simply collapsed under the strain.
On the very first occasion that she attacked a child on Ward Four, she did something which instantly exposed her to a grave risk of detection – she lied. She asphyxiated a seven-week-old baby named Liam Taylor and, when the child’s parents arrived at the side of his cot a few minutes later, she pretended that Liam had choked after a sudden and violent bout of sickness which had made such a mess, she claimed, that she had had to leave the ward to change her uniform.
Two years later, the staff nurse who was in charge of Ward Four on that day gave evidence that Allitt’s story could not possibly have been true: if the baby had been that sick, they would have called the doctor; if there had been that much mess, if Allitt had really left the ward to change, she would have known about it. But, at the time, the lie went undetected.
And the reason for that goes to the heart of the anger of the Ward Four parents and of their insistence that there should be a full public inquiry into the suffering of their children. Ward Four was desperately short of staff.
On some shifts, there were no staff nurses at all, only enrolled nurses like Bev Allitt to run the ward. On most shifts, there was no nurse who was specifically trained to care for children. On all shifts, the nurses were tired and demoralised – with neither the time nor the energy to stop and ask questions.
Simply: no-one from the hospital asked Bev Allitt why her first victim had suddenly stopped breathing and so they never heard the lie she was telling, and she got away with murder. This was merely the first fracture in a network of cracks that soon riddled the apparently stable hospital as Nurse Allitt worked her way through the children in her care.
Four times, her victims died and, on all four occasions, their bodies were taken to the hospital mortuary, where with unfailing inaccuracy, they were said to have died of natural causes. The pathologists concerned now admit that they were wrong and say that they had some doubts at the time. They plead that pathology is an inexact science.
The surviving children were variously diagnosed as suffering from asthma, choking, starvation, anxiety, unspecified infections, congenital heart illness and febrile convulsions. Every single diagnosis turns out to have been wrong: the doctors concerned admit it ,and the jurors at Allitt’s trial confirmed it.
Those errors were partly due to failures in the back-up departments which are supposed to feed raw information to doctors on the ward. There was the hospital pathology laboratory which took 15 days to handle an urgent blood sample containing the chemical clue which finally led police to the killer.
The lab also lost another sample from the same child, who had been poisoned with insulin; and mislaid the computer print-out of a crucial test on a I5-month-old girl, Claire Peck, who was poisoned with potassium.
There were X-rays which were lost and, in some cases, have yet to be found. One of them showed the torso of Kayley Desmond, aged 15 months, and contained vital evidence of foul play. Tucked away in her right armpit, there was a black smear, the result of Allitt injecting the little girl with air.
The doctors on Ward Four did not spot it. That was an understandable omission since the interpretation of X-rays is difficult, but all hospitals have a fall-back procedure, according to which every X-ray in the hospital must be seen by a consultant radiologist, capable of spotting the most subtle of clues. Kayley’s X-ray was not examined until the police found it.
For those who worked on Ward Four, there was nothing shocking about these weaknesses and about the underlying shortage of staff and equipment. They had often complained about them.
The two consultants who ran the ward had been warning for several years that they could no longer guarantee a safe service on the ward. The nurses and their unions had been pleading for help. Half way through the sequence of attacks, the night sister wrote to the hospital manager begging for more staff “before a tragedy occurs”. But nothing was done. At least, not then.
Once the police arrested Allitt and the smell of scandal started to settle over the hospital, the ward was deluged with money: the number of consultants was doubled; the number of nurses was increased by 60 per cent. For the children who were attacked by Nurse Allitt, this was all too late.
But for their parents now, the greatest concern is that the Secretary of State of Health has handed over the inquiry into the entire affair to the Trent Regional Health Authority – the same body which ran the hospital and which failed to remedy its fatal weakness for so long.
Murder on Ward Four The Story of Bev Allitt by Nick Davies, published today by Chatto & Windus at £9.99.