Nurse “broke baby’s ribs” and then became her godmother

The Guardian, 17 February 1993

A children’s nurse attacked twin baby sisters, killing one with an injection of insulin and permanently damaging the other, apparently by shaking her and crushing her until five of her ribs broke, a court heard yesterday.

Having attacked the nine-week-old girls, who were in her care on the children’s ward of Grantham Hospital, Beverley Allitt was then said to have befriended their parents, who thanked her for saving the life of their surviving twin and asked her to become the child’s godmother.

Miss Allitt, aged 24, denies murdering four children and attempting to murder nine others while she worked as an enrolled nurse on Ward 4 of the hospital in Lincolnshire during the spring of 1991. She also denies attempting to murder a 73-year-old woman in her care at an old people’s home and her flatmate’s 15- year-old brother.

The jury was told that after dealing with one child who had stopped breathing twice in one day while she was alone with him, she had been in a jovial mood and had pointed out to other nurses that she had been present for a lot of attacks. “Maybe its a jinx,” she had said.

On the second day of his opening speech at Nottingham crown court, John Goldring QC, told the jury that Miss Allitt had been off work when one of the twins, Becky Phillips, was admitted to Ward 4 with a tummy upset on April 1. Three days later she had returned and there had been an odd incident.

Miss Allitt had told a student nurse that Becky was cold and clammy as if she were suffering from too much insulin. The student told Miss Allitt not to be paranoid. The next day, April 4, Becky was well enough to go home. Before she left, Miss Allitt fed her.

At home that evening, Becky was unwell, screaming and rolling her eyes. She fell asleep but woke at 2.30am with convulsions. Half an hour later, her parents realised she was no longer breathing. They took her to the hospital, but nothing could be done to save her.

A later police blood test suggested that she had been injected on Ward 4 with long-acting insulin whose effect had been delayed by feeding. At the time, doctors decided that Becky was the victim of a cot death and they advised Mr and Mrs Phillips that her twin sister, Katie, should be admitted to ward 4 for observation.

Mr Goldring said: “At the time that Katie Phillips was brought in to Ward 4, there was nothing wrong with her. When she finally left she was seriously and permanently disabled.”

Katie arrived on the ward at about 6am on April 5. At 1pm, Miss Allitt came on duty and was told to look after Katie. At 3.15, Mrs Phillips left her daughter alone with the nurse in a side room. Ten minutes later, Miss Allitt shouted “Cardiac arrest!”

Nurses found Katie lying in Miss Allitt’s arms. She was navy blue and did not seem to be breathing. An X-ray taken shortly afterwards is now said by an expert to show that five ribs had been broken. A scan of Katie’s head showed brain damage normally seen in child abuse.

On April 7, Miss Allitt again was asked to look after Katie when she came on duty at 3pm. Mrs Phillips left the side room to go to the canteen, leaving Katie in her cot. Again Katie started crying as if in pain, said Mr Goldring. She stopped breathing and went blue.

Katie recovered and then collapsed again in Miss Allitt’s care, Mr Goldring said. At one point, her heart stopped and her lungs collapsed. Finally, she was taken to a hospital in Nottingham where she slowly recovered. It was then that her parents befriended Miss Allitt and invited her to become Katie’s godmother.

Mr Goldring went on to describe how, at 5am on April 27, Alice Stewart, a care assistant at Lancaster House old people’s home in Waltham on the Wold, found Miss Allitt giving an injection to 73-year-old Dorothy Lowe, who was asleep in bed. Mrs Lowe later became unrousable.She was taken to Grantham Hospital where doctors diagnosed an insulin-induced hypoglycaemic attack.

In August, while Miss Allitt was staying with the family of her flatmate, Tracy Jobson, in Peterborough, Tracy’s 15-year-old brother Jonathan started to complain of dizzy spells. One Sunday, he collapsed.

Mr Goldring told the jury that Miss Allitt had made Jonathan a drink of juice and that the boy had complained that it contained “chalky stuff.” Jonathan’s diabetic grandmother later suspected that someone had been interfering with tablets she took to control her blood sugar.

The trial continues today.