A criminal on Ward 4 was killing babies, court told

The Guardian, 16 February 1993

“It was clear that there was a criminal at large on Ward 4,” the prosecution said at the opening in Nottingham crown court yesterday of the trial of Nurse Beverley Gail Allitt, who faces 26 charges of murder, attempted murder and grievous bodily harm.

As the gaunt, 24-year-old nurse sat impassively in the dock, the prosecuting counsel, John Goldring QC, told the jury: “Nothing like this had ever happened before. Nothing like this has happened since.”

Most of the charges relate to children who were in Miss Allit’s care on the children’s ward, Ward 4, of Grantham Hospital, Lincolnshire, during a 58-day period in the spring of 1991.

The jury of seven men and five women were told that she had assaulted the children with injections of insulin and potassium, and that police believed she may also have injected one child with air, and possibly held her hand over the mouth and nose of others. Four children died. Nine survived, although some suffered permanent damage.

Opening a prosecution speech which is due to last for more than two days, Mr Goldring said the children had collapsed with heart attacks and respiratory arrests. The motive for the attacks, he said, remained a mystery.

It took the clerk of the court more than five minutes to read the indictment which alleged that between February 23 and April 22, 1991, Miss Allitt murdered Liam Taylor, Tim Hardwick, Becky Phillips and Claire Peck; and attempted to murder and caused grievous bodily harm to Kayley Desmond, Paul Crampton, Brad Gibson, Yik Chan, Katie Phillips, Michael Davidson, Christopher Peasegood, Christopher King and Patrick Elstone; and that later that year she also attempted to murder and caused grievous bodily harm to Dorothy Lowe and Jonathan Jobson. She denied all the charges.

Mr Goldring said that when the children first started collapsing, the hospital staff had been puzzled. “It couldn’t simply be chance that child after child was collapsing. There must be some medical explanation for it.”

But when the police were called to the hospital on April 30, they found that one child, Paul Crampton. had been injected with almost the entire contents of an adult-sized syringe of insulin. “It was now clear – incredible as it might seem – that there was a criminal at large on Ward 4.”

In their attempts to identify this criminal, the police looked at an old diary which Ward 4 nurses used as a notebook. “But someone had tampered with it. Someone didn’t want the police to see all the pages. Someone had taken a pair of scissors and had cut out a number of pages. These pages contained among other things, the period of Paul Crampton’s stay in hospital.”

Police then drew up a chart to find out who had been on duty during each of the collapses. They found “a chilling pattern” The only link was Miss Allitt: “There was no suspicious collapse when the defendant was not on duty.”

The police arrested her, searched her home and found in a bag at the bottom of her wardrobe another Ward 4 record book. “What on earth was it doing there?” Mr Goldring said the explanation she offered the police was totally unsatisfactory.

He warned the jury that the prosecution was unable to offer any motive. “Why should a nurse do these things? The short answer is that we do not know. We may never know why. But that doesn’t mean that she didn’t do them, nor that she is not responsible in law for what she did.”

He said Miss Allitt had been a student nurse on Ward 4 and had failed two interviews for a full-time job. After one, she had been told that she needed more experience with very sick children. The next day, the key to the Ward 4 fridge, where insulin was stored, vanished. Miss Allitt reported it missing.

Four days later, on February 18, she was given a short term contract. On the Thursday of that week, the first suspicious collapse took place. The child was Liam Taylor, aged seven weeks, who had been admitted with bronchiolitis.

Miss Allitt was looking after him when, early that evening, he suddenly become very ill. He recovered, but in the early hours of Saturday, Miss Allitt was with him in a side room when she alerted a student nurse. “He’s gone a funny colour,” she said. “Does he look blotchy to you?”

Miss Allitt gave the appearance of panic while doctors arrived to discover that Liam had suffered a heart attack. Alarms that should have rung, had failed. Liam died later that day.

“Although no one knew it at the time, this was the first of many occasions. There were many more calls from the defendant from one of these side rooms; many more occasions when a baby in her care had suddenly and surprisingly collapsed; more occasions when alarms were silent.”

The doctors who dealt with Liam’s death were puzzled. The post-mortem had shown that part of the muscle round his heart had died. “Something was
done to him. We don’t know what. A drug or a strange mixture of drugs may have been administered. A hand may have been placed over his mouth and nose. It is easy to do with a little baby.”

Ten days later, Tim Hardwick, aged 10, died on Ward 4. He was mentally and physically handicapped and had been admitted on March 5 after suffering epileptic fits that morning at his special school. On Ward 4 Miss Allitt looked after him. His fits stopped. His breathing and temperature were normal at 6pm. At 6.15pm his heart mysteriously stopped and he died.

The death of Liam Taylor was surprising enough, Mr Goldring said. “But a heart attack in a seven-week-old baby and also in a 10-year-old boy within two weeks was quite astonishing.”

The post-mortem concluded that Tim was killed by his epilepsy. With hindsight, it was obvious that that conclusion was wrong. “Every single doctor who has re-examined this case agrees that that diagnosis cannot be right.”

After Tim Hardwick’s death Miss Allitt had a few days off work. “In her absence Ward 4 worked as it had always done. There were no sudden unexpected collapses; no children died.”

On Friday March 8, she returned to work. On Sunday March 10, Kayley Desmond, aged 15 months, suffered two respiratory arrests in the early hours of the morning. Miss Allitt, Mr Goldring said, had been alone in the side room where Kayley was sleeping and called for help from Nurse Vowles, the only other nurse on duty. She told her that Kayley was a funny colour.

Kayley was mottled all over and had stopped breathing. She was revived but collapsed again before being transferred to hospital in Nottingham where she recovered speedily. X-rays revealed a patch of air in her body under the right armpit. “There was a lot of air. It is absolutely plain: someone took a syringe and someone deliberately injected Kayley with it, in all probability under the armpit.”

A fourth child, Paul Crampton, suffered a series of hypoglycaemic attacks when his blood sugar fell dangerously low. When the first attack occurred, on March 23, Miss Allitt was caring for him and suggested to a senior nurse that he was suffering a hypoglycaemic attack even though he had no such history and tests suggested his blood sugar was normal.

It was very plain: someone had given Paul Crampton insulin. It must have hurt a lot when he was being injected.” Miss Allitt was the only person present for all of the incidents.

The trial continues today.