MPs demand action on GCHQ law-breaking

The Guardian, 17 July 1991

The Government was under pressure last night to introduce new controls on the security and intelligence services in the wake of disclosures that they had been engaged in apparently unlawful operations.

Roy Hattersley, shadow home secretary, said the allegations by the Guardian and Granada Television’s World in Action about the telephone tapping of British citizens raised questions of fundamental importance. He demanded to know whether Kenneth Baker, Home Secretary, was aware of the interceptions and whether he would set up an inquiry into what appeared to be illegal actions.

“Is the Government prepared to justify intercepting telephone calls to British citizens who clearly represented no danger to national security?” Mr Hattersley asked.

Mr Baker – who is understood to take the view that eavesdropping by the Government Communications Headquarters, which is nominally under the Foreign Office, is not his responsibility – refused Mr Hattersley’s request for a Commons statement.

“So much for all the promises about accountability which were made during the passage of the new official secrets act,” Mr Hattersley said.

This is the second time in two months that Mr Baker has refused to issue a statement on telephone tapping. In June, he refused to make a Commons statement on a Guardian report that the security services were tapping up to 35,000 telephones a year.

The Guardian/World in Action inquiry disclosed that GCHQ tapped the telephone of a 93-year-old peace campaigner and intercepted the communications of Campbell Christie, secretary general of the Scottish Trades Union Council. British Telecom tapped the phones of the family of Lieutenant Robert Lawrence, the Falklands war hero whose story was told in the film Tumbledown.

Yesterday, Stuart Randall, Labour’s spokesman on the security services, said the 1985 Interception of Communications Act was a complete charade. New technology had produced a “terrifying Orwellian reality”. The issue was how to square the need for security services with privacy and the dangers of intrusive technology.

Barry Sheerman, Labour’s home affairs spokesman, said the disclosures showed the need for “radical change and a democratic system to get a grip on the intelligence network”.

Merlyn Rees, the former Labour home secretary, called for an investigation into the allegation by Robin Robison, a former civil servant, that the intelligence community was out of ministerial control.

The Prime Minister’s office said it had not considered the claims.

Mr Robison, who worked in the Joint Intelligence Committee until last year, said last night: “I am convinced that the vast majority of civil servants act with the utmost probity. The problem with our system is that the prevailing attitude is one of ‘everything will turn out all right in the end’. The evidence is that it does not.”

Labour’s Scottish home affairs spokesman, Brian Wilson, tabled a Commons motion expressing “astonishment and disgust” at GCHQ’s interception of formal greetings from an east European union organisation to Mr Christie. Mr Christie has written to Mr Major insisting that any intercepted material held on him be destroyed.