The difficult truth about the CIA and brainwashing

The Guardian, 28 October 1988

Review of ‘Journey Into Madness’ by Gordon Thomas

When the CIA set out to discover the magic arts of brainwashing and mind-control in 1952, its then Director, Allen Dulles, was clear about the kind of doctors he wanted to work on the project. “Each person’s ethics must be such that he would be completely co-operative in any phase of our programme regardless of how revolutionary it may be,” he wrote.

The key word is ‘revolutionary’, a gentle euphemism designed to conceal some barbaric practices. Dulles eventually found the kind of ethics he was looking for in the late Dr Ewan Cameron, one of the most prestigious psychiatrists of his day, a grey, professional man with a white coat and tortoiseshell glasses. At Dulles’s behest, Cameron turned the wards of his mental hospital in Montreal into a laboratory of human suffering in which helpless patients became sacrificial guinea-pigs for the grandiose fantasies of the CIA.

Cameron stuffed them full of LSD and watched them go crazy. He wired their heads up to generators and watched them shriek: in his peak year, 1961, he put 60,000 electric shocks into 1,000 patients. One woman had 1,300 shocks. One man died after taking 120 shocks through his brain in a fortnight. Nothing was too ‘revolutionary’.

When Cameron’s unbridled lust for research failed to demonstrate how human minds could be properly manipulated, the CIA sent doctors over to Vietnam to experiment on Vietcong prisoners. They planted electrodes in the brains of three of them, but they could not control their behaviour, so they got the US Green Berets to shoot them and went back to the drawing board.

This is rough stuff and there is plenty more where that came from in Gordon Thomas’s guided tour of medical torture around the world – sulphuric acid in open wounds in El Salvador, intestinal skewering in Syria, narcotic mind-bending for the hostages in Beirut, and all of it supervised by doctors who have taken the Hippocratic Oath. But is it true?

The question runs like a wrinkle through Thomas’s work. He says he has criss-crossed the globe talking to intelligence sources and, in particular, that he was helped by two former CIA directors – Allen Dulles and William Casey – and one key CIA officer, William Buckley, the CIA’s station chief in Beirut who died after being kidnapped. But the sources are hardly ever linked to the narrative. He quotes virtually no documents or eye witnesses. He simply tells his tale and trusts us to trust him. Maybe we should.

But it is not always easy. Does Colonel Ghadafy really persuade his prisoners to talk by having rats chewing into their stomachs? Does Ghadafy really like to put on Max Factor make-up, Gucci high heels and cuddle a teddy bear? Was Dr Ewan Cameron really particularly fond of Frankenstein books when he was a child? Maybe it is all absolutely true. But Thomas gives us no way of being sure.

The problem is aggravated by his habit of using fiction techniques – dialogue, stream of consciousness, tiny behavioural details – to write an investigative story.

The result of this is that when he makes a real belter of an allegation – for example, that the CIA sought and found ‘expendable’ people who could be killed during medical experiments – we are left with a fistful of Maybes. It is particularly troubling in his account of Dr Aziz Al-Abub, whom he names as the physician-torturer of hostages in Beirut, and whose role he reproduces in some detail without ever giving us a fragment of evidence to support the story.

Yet, it would be wrong to push this anxiety too far. The CIA’s flight over the cuckoo nest is confirmed in court papers from law suits brought by Dr Cameron’s former patients. Thomas is an experienced reporter, and he has tried to expose a story which richly deserves to be uncovered. The problem is inherent in his subject: torturers do not give press conferences, their victims have no chance to gather evidence, intelligence officers rarely talk on record. The truth is probably that Thomas is, to some extent, a victim of his own good intentions.