Another October Surprise?

The Scotsman and The New Zealand Dominion, 14 October 1988

Mr Mark Goodwin, a spokesman for Vice President George Bush, adopted his most scandalised manner. “Someone who articulates that ought not to be allowed to operate heavy equipment,” he declared.

The idea which had so shocked Mr Goodwin was the suggestion that the release in Beirut last week of an Indian American who had been held hostage since January 24 1987, had in some way been contrived in order to help Mr Bush on his journey to the presidency. “The whole premise is silly,” added Mr Goodwin. “We are not going to play politics with the hostages.” In the corridors of Congress, they are not so sure.

The anxiety of Congressmen is two-fold. First, they fear that in their determination to secure a Republican victory, Bush supporters may be tempted into the unpardonable sin of trading with terrorists in order to release American hostages. Second, old fears have been revived that something very similar may have taken place back in 1980 when it was Ronald Reagan whose supporters were determined that he should win.

The full version of the idea which Mr Goodwin is so keen to lay to rest is known in Washington shorthand as the October Surprise – the release on the eve of this November’s election of all nine remaining American hostages in Beirut, possibly with the five other Westerners thrown in, in order to register a headline-grabbing, poll-swinging victory for the White House and its candidate.

The superficial evidence cuts both ways. Bush’s defenders say he wants nothing to do with the hostages and that their release would only revive unwanted questions about his role in the Iran Contra scandal. They say the country is not worried about the hostages and that Bush will win the election without having to take such a dangerous risk.

His detractors, however, say that Bush needs all the help he can get and that the intelligence community is particularly keen to secure his victory. They insist that Bush was up to his ears in dealing arms for hostages in 1985 and 1986. And they point to the French Presidential contender, Jacques Chirac, who used his position as Prime Minister to engineer the release of three French hostages days before the presidential election there this summer.

But the most flammable fuel for the fire is the steadily growing pile of evidence of some far-reaching conspiracy along similar lines back in 1980, when the idea of the October Surprise was born.

At that time, President Jimmy Carter was in the White House with his administration bleeding to death from wounds inflicted by the Iranian people, particularly the imprisonment of 52 Americans in the US Embassy in Tehran. Carter’s best hope of winning the November 1980 election was to get them out before polling day – to stage the October Surprise. But this hope was also the worst political threat for his opponent, Ronald Reagan.

The suggestion which has shadowed Reagan for the last eight years is that his aides intervened to keep the Tehran hostages in captivity until he was in the White House and that Reagan’s willingness to sell arms to the Iranians goes back beyond the 1986 scandal to this desperate pre-election plot.

It is only in the last few weeks that Jimmy Carter has publicly put forward his own view. In a television interview, the former President recalled: “There were reports made to me before the election that this was going on – that the hostages would not be released and that weapons sales would be restored to Iran, either directly or through the Israelis.”

In a subsequent interview, Carter repeated his fears and touched on what is the simplest and most striking clue – the timing of the eventual release of the 52 imprisoned Americans. “The last three days I was in the White House,” he said, “we’d negotiated every detail of the release of the hostages. And when I left the White House on the way to the inaugural stands, where I would go out of office and Reagan would be sworn in, all the hostages were in an airplane at the airport ready to take off. I had been notified that they would leave at about ten o’clock that morning. But for some reason, the Iranians held the plane until 12 noon exactly, and then the hostages took off.” By the time the hostages landed, Ronald Reagan was President.

President Carter’s suspicions are backed by the Palestine Liberation Organisation, whose chief spokesman, Bassam Abu Sharif, said explicitly last month that a senior Reagan official had contacted the PLO during the 1980 election. “He wanted the PLO to use its influence to delay the release of the American hostages from the embassy in Teheran until after the election. We have the proof if it is denied.”

The PLO, however, have not produced the proof they claim to have, and Jimmy Carter does not claim to have any. There are, however, some fragments of evidence which tend to support Carter’s suspicions.

In the background, there is compelling evidence that Reagan’s 1980 election team succeeded in planting spies in the opposition camp. This came to light in 1983, when it was disclosed that Reagan had obtained a copy of Jimmy Carter’s briefing notes before the presidential debate. A congressional inquiry found that the Carter campaign had been infiltrated by agents working for William Casey who was then chairman of Reagan’s campaign and subsequently became head of the CIA.

The importance of this is that the inquiry also found that the principal target of Casey’s spy network was not Carter’s briefing papers but the day-by-day progress of Carter’s attempts to liberate the hostages from Tehran. Through September and October 1980, the American press was fed one damaging leak after another: Carter’s supposed contingency plan to invade Iran; his alleged attempts to swap the hostages for military spare parts; and then an attempt to swap them for military equipment. It is suggested – but not proved – that all these leaks were procured by Casey to kill each of Carter’s attempts to stage his October Surprise.

Beyond this, it is suggested that Reagan’s aides moved in to make their own deal with the Ayatollah. Two men who subsequently became National Security Advisers for President Reagan – Richard Allen and Robert McFarlane – have previously admitted that that they met with Iranian officials in October 1980.

The precise purpose of the meetings is not clear, although Allen was approached at this time by Israelis who wanted to sell parts of F4 fighter planes to the Iranians. Two other witnesses point in the same direction. The former Iranian President, Abolhassan Bani-Sadr, now exiled in Paris, has said he believes that a deal was struck between Reagan and Ayatollah Khomeini which cut out Carter and himself.

But most striking of all, Barbara Honegger, who worked under William Casey in the 1980 Reagan campaign, and was subsequently hired by the White House, says that late in October 1980, a senior Reagan supporter met Iranian officials in Paris to strike a deal. That senior supporter, she says, was George Bush, whose campaign records show he had no public engagements between October 21 and 27 1980.

The conjecture is that if the Republicans were willing to offer military support to the Iranians in exchange for an electoral boost in 1980, they might now dangle the promise of future economic aid to help Iran recover from the Gulf War and to help themselves at the ballot box. The counter case is simply that no American politician in his right mind would go within a million miles of trading for hostages.

Bani Sadr was one of the few last week who would put his name to the conjecture. He claimed from Paris that a former intelligence officer, Richard Lawless, acting on George Bush’s behalf, had been negotiating the release of hostages with Iranian officials. In Washington, Lawless poured scorn on the claim. The State Department denied that any negotiations had taken place but acknowledged that private citizens had been reported to be negotiating without official authority.

It is all a long way from proof, which is one reason why the Democrats have not dared to accuse Bush publicly either of playing a role in the 1980 venture or of now using the same connections to plan his own October Surprise this year. A second reason for their silence is that if the whole truth comes out, they may well find that if President Carter was innocent of trading arms for hostages, it was only because the competition offered a better deal than he did.

Last week, Mr Mark Goodwin was still holding the line. Asked if it was true that the release of the Indian-born America Mithileswar Singh in Beirut followed secret negotiations in Geneva, he said: “It is totally ridiculous and untrue to assert that anyone representing the Vice President would be involved in such a discussion. In fact, it’s laughable.”

Cynical reporters pointed out that last week’s release was the first time an American hostage had been set free since 1986 when David Jacobsen was released – just 48 hours before the Congressional elections.