Vice President Bush pulls ahead (with or without the unions)

The Scotsman and The New Zealand Dominion, 12 September 1988

America has come to recognise the many faces of George Bush. He is the benign grandfather and the tough conservative, the brave ex bomber pilot and the smart Yale graduate, the millionaire businessman and the loyal deputy, and, of course, the President’s closest pal. But last week, he unexpectedly pulled a new disguise out of his wardrobe.

It happened in Portland, Oregon where the Vice President had arrived down in the docks to address a gathering of workers who had been given time off from their labours to share his thoughts. For once, his advance party of fixers and fakers had failed to do their job properly, and George was suddenly confronted with one very hostile crowd.

“Bush, go home!” they chanted. George looked offended. “Bring back Carter!” they shouted. George looked astonished. As the cat-calling and the booing rose up from the rows of hardhats and dirty overalls, Bush gritted his teeth, shed the image of the moment and reached into his back pocket to find a new persona.

Suddenly, he was waving his wallet at the crowd and shouting: “Let these guys do the yelling. How many guys running for President of the United States has been a member of the steelworkers’ union? You’re looking at one.” With that, he grabbed one of the guys and showed him his wallet which turned out to contain card number LU2470 of the United Steelworkers of America, the property of George Herbert William Bush.

It was unfortunate for the future of the new Working Man’s George that the card which he so proudly flourished had expired in 1950, when he was a humble oil equipment salesman, and, despite launching an impromptu and very aggressive attack on the economic record of Democratic presidents, he was unable to quell the hostility which his presence had aroused.

In the four weeks since the Republican convention in New Orleans, Bush has silenced many critics by rebuilding parts of the mighty block of voters who supported Ronald Reagan in 1980 and 1984, principally by using symbolic issues like abortion and the pledge of allegiance to smear his opponent as an Unamerican and untrustworthy ‘liberal’.

Yet a crucial group of Reagan supporters still eludes him – the trade unionists who deserted their traditional home in the Democratic Party in the hope of finding economic security under Reagan. The jeers in Portland, Oregon are only one indication among many that American workers have walked out on their brief marriage of convenience to the Republican Party.

This must worry Bush, but what should worry him more is that, against all the odds, the American Labour Movement, which has spent the last eight years on the ropes, appears to have found new strength and to be ready to come back punching: the AFL-CIO union organisation is richer, more organised and better led than it has been for years and it is spoiling for a fight with the Vice President.

The Reagan years have been hard for American unions. Their membership has fallen to an all-time low so that only 18% of the working population is now unionised and their recruitment of new members has been so pitiful that only 7.3% of workers under 25 now belong to unions.

That, in turn, reflects a steady political assault from the White House which began in 1981 with Reagan sacking 13,000 striking air-traffic controllers and which ended this summer with the president blocking a new law which would have compelled employers to give workers 60 days notice before closing a plant. But the unions have suffered even more from an economic assault.

In the first three years of ‘Reaganomics’, unemployment in America climbed rapidly from less than seven per cent to nearly ten per cent of the working population. Across the country, union negotiators agreed to limit their demands in the hope of saving jobs; many were so vulnerable that they accepted pay cuts. Strikes and stoppages fell to the lowest level since records were started forty years ago.

Even in the last twelve months, with unemployment sinking back to its pre-Reagan level, union negotiators have still been on the defensive. While the cost of living has risen by 4%, pay rises are running at only 2.1%. Fear of job losses is still a potent factor: shop workers in Oklahoma and Kansas City have just agreed to a 20% pay cut from Safeways rather than risk seeing their stores closed; rubber workers in Wisconsin have agreed to cut their pay by 63 cents an hour, to give up a week’s holiday and all cost-of-living increases to take the pressure off the Uniroyal Goodrich Tyre company.

But while individual unions are still weak, the national organisation has found new strength, in part because the experience of eight years of Reaganomics has unified their members in opposition to the White House. A Washington Post poll this summer found that 59% of the electorate regarded Reagan as “a rich man’s President” and that 55% believed he had been unfair to the poor.

But, more important, the AFL-CIO union umbrella, which has in the past been the home of idle bureaucrats and corrupt mobsters, is now in the hands of a canny and pragmatic leadership under its president, Lane Kirkland. Their handling of the presidential election has been slick and disciplined and extremely successful.

Two years ago, they were demoralised and directionless. They bore much of the responsibility for the humiliation of Walter Mondale, whose total failure to dent Reagan’s popularity in 1984 was widely seen as the result of his being too closely identified with the unions, and they could see no candidate who was likely to command the support of their members in 1988. Which is when they became canny.

Instead of following the usual policy of choosing their own candidate in the primaries and spending a fortune to ensure that he was chosen as the nominee, they simply made a videotape of all the primary candidates in both parties and circulated it through every level of every union. Different unionists back different candidates, mostly Democrats.

The result was first, that unions sent a record number of delegates to the Democratic convention, and second that as the primary season moved on, unionists naturally clustered around Michael Dukakis along with everyone else and were well placed to influence his thinking. “We’re so proud of ourselves for not gutting each other,” as one of Lane Kirkland’s aides put it.

This operation also cost next to nothing, leaving the AFL-CIO’s leadership with a healthy fighting fund which they are now putting at Dukakis’ disposal. They have also given the Democrats the priceless gift of a nationwide infrastructure which has been newly overhauled so that even Reagan’s last campaign manager, Ed Rollins, acknowledges that organised labour has a better operation than the Republican Party in almost every state in the union. They are currently trying to recruit half a million volunteers to work on doorsteps and telephones for Dukakis.

Dukakis’ aides are doing their best to build on this. Last week, the Democrats started a new TV advertising blitz. One of the two 60-second spots is entirely devoted to the union vote – a sequence of grainy black and white photos of padlocked factories topped with the complaint that George Bush and his running mate, Senator Dan Quayle, blocked the new law which would have given 60 days notice of closures.

However, even if the Democrats succeed in holding on to the union vote, the arithmetic of the election is such that while this may deny Bush the kind of landslide victory which Reagan scored, it would not deny him victory, and Bush may even be helped in some quarters by the perception that he is no friend of the AFL-CIO.

In the heat of the verbal battle in Portland, Bush seemed to see this. He pocketed his dog-eared union card, looked over the heads of the boiling mob and, once again assuming his familiar tough conservative persona, he told the television audience: “America is on the move again and the American people understand that. Don’t gamble on another liberal Democrat.”