Review of ‘Blacklist’ by Mark Hollingsworth and Richard Norton-Taylor
For some years now the secret state, the whole contraption of British security, has been so menacing and yet so intangible that the most effective way to write about it has been in a kind of fairy story in which the state replaces the big bad wolf or the leering witch as the Terrible Thing That Will Get You If You Stray From The Path.
The best of these fairy stories have been brilliant – Edge Of Darkness on television or Defence Of The Realm in cinema. As fairy stories, they gave a shape to this fearful, secret creature in Whitehall. Yet, they were limited, precisely because they had abandoned the real world: the menacing state remained an abstract idea and its victims merely works of imagination.
The importance of Blacklist is that it tells the story of the secret state at an almost mundane level: thousands of people who work as car mechanics, engineers, builders, clerks and secretaries are punished for their politics by being locked out of employment, forced to sell their houses or cars to get by, and pressed so out of shape that their marriages and their personalities break down.
The menace derives not from some dimly perceived mirage but from Mr Peter N. Jones of British Telecom, Mr Michael Noar of the Economic League, Ms Susan Windridge of British Leyland, Brigadier Ronald L. Stoneham of the BBC, Mr Patrick Walker of MI5, and ranks of personnel officers, all puffed up with patriotism.
The victims in Blacklist are just as specific. You can not only identify them, but you also identify with them. Take Tony McCarthy, who worked for 16 years in a foundry in Warrington, making cast-iron cookers, a man who was by all accounts an exemplary worker. He was, however, also a shop steward of equal repute who ran rings round the company in negotiations. When he and 200 others were made redundant in 1978, his company, TI New World Ltd, not only resolved to refuse him future employment but also passed his name to the Economic League, whose blacklisting service is used by numerous companies. Tony McCarthy has not had a permanent job since.
McCarthy, like so many of the other victims whose stories are disclosed here, exemplifies the underlying truth of British blacklisting, that while it attempts to justify itself as a defence against spies and industrial saboteurs, it is more often a classic tool to suppress dissent and, in particular, trade unionism.
Blacklist is at its best when it reveals hard facts: the laundering of cash by the Economic League; the names and modus operandi of blacklisters in different companies; the links between private detectives and the police; the role of MI5 and Special Branch; and the endless queue of victims.
Victims like the blind pensioner in Dundee who was blacklisted because he wrote a letter to his local paper supporting the council’s purchase of a portrait of Nelson Mandela.
There are points when the story falters. A lot of the commentary on the victims takes the line that the victim was not a communist and, therefore, did not deserve to be treated in this fashion. It is a line which is doubly flawed. First, because the state no longer pretends to be targeting only communists and explicitly pledges to harass anyone who may be squeezed into the all-embracing smear of ‘subversion.’ Second, because communists are citizens too and the secret state has no legal nor moral mandate to choke off their livelihood.
There is also a dangerous confusion about the history of vetting, whose superficial links with the discovery of various spies in the British establishment have provided a spurious justification for the procedure. Spies sail through positive vetting. Remember Michael Bettaney, the MI5 officer who tried to pass secrets to the KGB?
During the period when he was contemplating his espionage, he was arrested for being drunk and disorderly in the West End. His superiors slapped his wrist and told him to behave. Weeks later, he was nicked at Victoria Station for traveling without a ticket. Fearful that this would lead to his dismissal. Bettaney dug deep into his years of professional training with the intelligence community and devised a cunning plan to fool the MI5 vetters: he decided not to tell them. The plan worked and Bettaney carried on spying.
Hollingsworth and Norton-Taylor explore the legal and political implications of their disclosures, but the emotional ones are just as important. Their chapters on British Telecom and the BBC, in particular, make angry reading. It would be so good if all the massed ranks of all the people who are threatened by blacklisting could take advantage of the information which Blacklist reveals and agree to blacklist and boycott the companies who indulge in this nastiness. Impossible, probably. Except in fairy stories.