The kidnapper’s revenge

The Scotsman and The New Zealand Dominion, 29 August 1988

The whole state of Mississippi is agog at the goings-on in Jackson, the state capital, which lies in the pine woods and prairie a couple of hundred miles north of New Orleans, a town which has remained an outpost of the old southern way of life, where wealthy families live in genteel comfort while the less fortunate are not encouraged to complain.

Jackson is the home of Mr Robert M Hearin, aged 71, a man who exemplifies this lifestyle – hardworking, earnest, some would say taciturn or even hard, and undoubtedly wealthy, in fact probably the richest man in all of Mississippi and possibly even the richest in the history of the state. Now, Mr Hearin has become the central character in a tale of mystery and intrigue.

On Tuesday, July 26, at about 4.30 in the afternoon, Mr Hearin returned to his pseudo-Georgian mansion in the smartest part of Jackson, parked his air-conditioned limousine in the sprawling shade of the poplar trees which grow from his perfectly manicured lawn and stepped inside to look for his wife, Annie Laurie, aged 72, who had spent the afternoon playing bridge and eating blueberry ice cream cake with a few friends. She was not there. This was most unusual.

Later that evening, his anxiety mounting, he called his son-in-law and together they searched the house and grounds. On the front doorstep, they discovered spots of blood and then they noticed a piece of paper which, they found on examination, listed the names of twelve people and bore a badly spelled message.

It read: “Put these people back in the shape they was in before they got mixed up with School Pictures. Pay them whatever damages they want and tell them all this so they can no what you are doing but don’t tell them why you are doing it. Do this before ten days pass. Don’t call police.” After the list of names, it added: “If any is dead, pay his children.”

School Pictures is one of the dozens of different companies which belong to Mr Hearin’s empire. He has earned most of his fortune – estimated at $200 million – from oil, gas and banking. School Pictures is a little something he picked up along the way; it develops photographs of students taken by cameramen around the country who pay the company for its franchise.

Mr Hearin hesitated and then took the note to the police who joined the search for Annie Laurie. But she was nowhere to be found. The police investigated the note and found that the twelve names belong to people who have been involved with School Pictures and who suffered in some way or another when Mr Hearin streamlined the company to make it more profitable; each of them is embroiled in legal action with Mr Hearin, most of them the targets of his attempts to extract thousands of dollars which he says they owe him.

The police and Mr Hearin agreed that, for fear of jeopardising his missing wife, they would draw a veil of secrecy over the whole incident, but within 24 hours, the story had leaked out to the newspapers. The Mayor of Jackson asked them not to publish. They agreed, but news of the disappearance spread naturally along the grapevine and soon the whole city was talking about it, at which point the newspapers plunged in, too.

Twenty days after Annie Laurie’s disappearance, Mr Hearin received a letter from her, urging him ‘to pay whatever damages they want’ within ten days. The next day, August 16, Mr Hearin dispatched twelve cheques worth a total of nearly one million dollars. Then there was silence – no more notes, no more demands of any type, no clue as to who was responsible and, most of all, no sign of Annie Laurie.

Police chemists announced that the blood spots on the doorstep matched her blood group. More than one hundred FBI agents were drafted in to help the local police. They have interviewed eleven of the twelve listed names, the twelfth being dead.

They interviewed, for example, Mr Alfred Winn, aged 64, a cameraman from Florida who bought a franchise from School Pictures in 1981 and had an unhappy relationship with the company. In 1983, School Pictures started to sue the elderly cameraman for the return of money which it claimed to have advanced him. Mr Winn sued back, complaining that the company had deceived him by exaggerating the chances of making money from its franchise.

Mr Winn lost heavily in the courts. In 1984, he was ordered to pay just over $150,000 to the Mississippi millionaire. He was, however, unable or unwilling to hand over the money with the result that Mr Hearin went back to court recently and set about seizing the cameraman’s property to recover the debt. The police spoke, too, to Mr Victor Hanneld, a cameraman from Oklahoma; Mr Hearin has been suing him for $72,000.

Earlier this month, a distraught Mr Hearin called a press conference to appeal for his wife’s release and made an important confession: “Like any businessman, I have made decisions which may appear to others as unfeeling.” However, he continued: “Those appearances are untrue. Moreover, those business decisions were mine, not my wife’s, and she had nothing to do with them.”

It is this notion of the millionaire’s past catching up with him, as much as sympathy for the missing woman, which has stoked the imagination of the state: the image of the worm turning, of the millionaire’s downtrodden victim fighting for a twisted version of the justice which the rich man’s courts denied him.

For those who live in Mississippi’s shanty towns and sweating ghettos, it is a thrilling possibility; for the state’s peculiarly pampered elite, in the splendid isolation of their wealth, it is as if the wretched underclass had come creeping across the front lawn to peer in their windows and steal the silver.

The incident has been a keyhole on the happy-go-lucky world of the American millionaire which is, it appears, neither happy nor lucky. Mr Hearin makes money for a living and lives to make money. Even in his 70s, it is said, he often rises as early as four in the morning to go to his office to make a little more before the sun comes up, streamlining and rationalising his empire, improving the figures in the bottom line even while he regrettably leaves a few casualties like Mr Winn and Mr Hanneld behind him in the deficit column.

His life is like one of those cautionary tales that Victorian nannies once deployed to cow their children, a warning in its own right against unbridled greed and the perils of work without play. There has been a spate of similar stories recently leaking out of the private world of America’s millionaires.

There was the unmistakable sound of the mighty falling in Manhattan last week where a federal jury finally skewered the enormously wealthy Hunt brothers of Texas – Nelson, Lamar and Herbert – who set out in 1979 to buy up all the silver in the world so that they could starve the market, send the price rocketing and then cash in. The jury found that the brothers had engaged in an illegal conspiracy and that they had consistently lied to conceal it; they ordered them to pay damages of $130 million to a Peruvian company which lost a fortune because of the Hunts’ activities.

The Hunts may well go down in history as the greediest people in the world. Nelson was already ranked as the richest man in America long before he set out on the silver scam. His two brothers, even after the silver disaster, are worth something like $500 million each. The most humble Victorian baby sitter could have told them that their money would do them no good. All the other victims who lost money because of the silver plot are now lining up to collect their damages. The Hunts’ family companies have already been forced into bankrupcy, and their individual holdings are now also at risk.

Similarly, in Atlantic City last week, there was the spectacle of two millionaires squabbling publicly over who gets to build the city’s next casino, a deal which is worth many millions to the winner. On one side is Bob Guccione, the wrinkled lothario behind the Penthouse empire, possibly America’s most prestigious pimp. Facing him is Donald Trump, the egomaniac builder of Manhattan skyscrapers, a man whose personal habits make the cast of Dynasty look like models of good taste and discretion. Following their battle is like watching two thugs having a punch-up in a bar: for spectators, at a safe distance, it really does not matter which one of them wins as long as at least one of them gets seriously hurt.

Yet it would be foolish or, at least, premature to imagine that the millionaires are about to heed the moral of these tales and abandon their greedy ways for, of course, many of them continue to survive and prosper. It is a striking co-incidence that after all those months of fighting and feuding in the primaries, the two political parties here have chosen four candidates who are all men, all white and all millionaires – Dan Quayle inherited a newspaper fortune of $200 million, both Bush and Bentsen made fortunes out of oil, and Dukakis inherited several million dollars in trust funds from his father.

Back in Jackson, Mississippi, Robert Hearin has decided to sell School Pictures. A company which supplies school equipment has offered him $25 million for it. More millions for the millionaire. It hardly seems adequate compensation.

NOTE: Following publication of this column, the US Consul General in Edinburgh wrote to the Scotsman to complain about the “unremitting negativism” of Nick Davies’ reports.

UPDATE: Associated Press obituary of Robert Hearin, who died in November 1990, aged 73:

Robert Hearin, a millionaire businessman whose wife was kidnapped from their home two years ago and was never found, died of a heart attack at Mississippi Baptist Medical Center on Wednesday after collapsing at his office. He was 73 years old.

Mr. Hearin was a major stockholder in Trustmark National Bank and chief executive and co-owner of Mississippi Valley Gas. His worth was estimated at more than $200 million.

On July 26, 1988, his wife, Annie Laurie Hearin, 72, was abducted from her home after a bridge party. A ransom note asked that $1 million be sent to 12 people who, the note said, had been wronged by Mr. Hearin in a business deal. The money was mailed.

Nineteen months later, in February 1990, a lawyer, Newton Alfred Winn, was sentenced to 19 years in prison for conspiring to kidnap Mrs. Hearin. He was one of the 12 for whom compensation was demanded in the note.

Mr. Hearin had been prominent for years in banking, oil and gas development, insurance and other businesses. He was formerly a part-owner of the New York Jets football team.

Survivors include a son, Robert Jr. of New Orleans, and a daughter, Laurie McRee of Jackson.