Paradise is wrinkled. It is a place of plenty where the sun always shines and everybody plays all day and there are no problems – and everyone is, well, wrinkly. Paradise is Sun City in the plains of Arizona, a community which is closed to anyone without flaps of turkey flesh around their neck.
Here, 61,000 elderly Americans spend their days swimming and playing tennis, buzzing down to the hypermarket in their golf karts, and, in every way, taking it easy. All Sun Citizens must be at least 50 years old and must be able to afford up to $250,000 for their architect-designed, purpose-built bungalow in the sun. The same playground life-style is repeated through scores of ‘retirement communities’ across the southern sun belt.
But there is a problem in paradise. It was put at its nastiest by a Governor of Colorado, Richard Lamm, who said that the elderly have “a duty to die and get out of the way”. It is put slightly more gently in a new book, titled Setting Limits, in which an academic, Daniel Callahan, argues that the American Government should ration health care to the elderly.
Callahan suggests that beyond a certain age – say 75 – patients should be refused life-extending medical services: they could be given pain-killers or a place in a nursing home or anything else that would make them feel comfortable, but nothing that was intended merely to prolong their life.
It is, at first sight, a fascistic line of thought: the old are unproductive and must, therefore, be eliminated. In a country like America where they tend to romanticise the elderly (quite apart from electing them to their highest office), it is particularly shocking. It is, however, picking up support. The reasons are rather revealing.
If you look at Ronald Reagan’s last budget – the first in American history to go over a trillion dollars – you will find that 30% of that huge federal spending spree is devoted to old people. Roughly 300 billion dollars. No other part of the community comes close to their share.
The question is whether they really need it, for, as visitors to Sun City will observe, many elderly Americans are by no means poor. Washington researcher Phil Longman, who specialises in studying the economics of the elderly, told me: “They are far and away the wealthiest group in American society. It doesn’t show up if you look at their income, because they are retired, but in terms of savings and equity, they really come out ahead.” For example, American pensioners leave some $100 billion a year in their wills.
So, the wealthiest part of the community is receiving the largest slice of the cake. They also get cheap seats in the cinema, cut-price seats in buses and trains and tax loopholes for their savings. If that seems unfair, it gets worse if you look more closely at the way that elderly Americans divide their share of the cake between themselves.
They receive almost all of it in two different forms of payment: social security which pays a regular pension to anyone who has contributed to the scheme during their working life; and medicare which picks up certain hospital and medical bills for those over 65, a service which is valued at half a million dollars for each recipient. But, in both cases, the ones who already have the most money tend also to be the ones who then get the most out of the system.
The pension they receive is graded according to the contributions which they have made, which in turn reflects the salaries they earned during their working life. A well-paid worker will be entitled to a pension of around $14,000 a year. A poor one will receive only half that. Beneath both of them are the underclass of farm workers, domestic servants and illegal immigrants who will have been paid in cash for their work and will have made no contibutions and are, thus, entitled to no social security at all. The same group is also cut out of Medicare.
So while aging white middle class Americans frolic in Sun City, receiving an ample state pension as well as the interest off their private investments, a smaller group of elderly but less fortunate Americans rots on the poverty line in the inner cities. But that disparity pales beside what is now perceived as the greatest inequity of all – a generation gap the size of the Grand Canyon.
The pensions of the old come out of the pockets of the young. At the moment, the price of the golden oldies is just beginning to cause a simmering resentment. For example, the abundant health care which is freely available to many of the old is offered to young Americans only at a punishing price. This resentment is about to be boosted by a freak of demography.
At the moment, there are only 25 million Americans over 65 – a mere 11.3% of the population. By 1990, there will be 31.7 million – 12.7% of the population – and by 2030, when the swaggering ranks of the baby boom generation have all finally reached for their pension books, there will be 64.6 million – 21.1% of the population. And worse than that, behind the all-embracing plague of baby boomers, comes the puny ‘baby bust’ generation, the smallest and feeblest generation this century.
By then, if present benefits are maintained, the ‘grey budget’ will consume 65% of all federal spending. And whereas now there are 3.3 workers to support each pensioner, there will then be only 1.9. The tax burden is likely to be crushing.
Phil Longman said: “The amazing thing is that even if Gorbachev becomes a Democrat and Khomeini becomes a Presbytarian, in other words if we didn’t need to spend a single cent on defence, we are still looking at a social security system that will require pay roll taxes of over 50%. It is bad enough now, but we have not seen anything yet.”
People like Phil Longman and Daniel Callahan have started sounding the alarm bells. Longman has published Born to Pay, the seminal work on the subject. There is even a pressure group in Washington, founded in 1985, called Americans for Generational Equity. But they are fighting a leviathan.
The wrinklies are everywhere – in almost every home, in every town, and most of all, in every ballot box. No Congressman can afford to ignore them. They are also highly organised. There are no less than 29 different lobbying groups pushing pension power in Washington. The mightiest of them is the American Association of Retired People, AARP, which boasts that it recruits 14,000 new members every working day. It is open to anyone over 50 and its ranks now number 28 million – twice the size of the organised labour movement.
The AARP is cunningly commercialised. Membership costs only $5, in exchange for which members receive a regular supply of Modern Maturity magazine, which is now the most effective way for advertisers to reach this wealthy section of the community. The magazine is a money-spinner, making the AARP rich and, therefore, powerful.
“The AARP is the most powerful lobby in Washington,” according to Phil Longman. “It’s not easy to measure power and other lobbies might be promoting more difficult causes. But nobody goes up against the AARP.”
Phil Longman did try. In April, when he was working as a Congressional aide, he took part in a television programme in which he dared to criticise the present system of pensions. His boss was then the object of what appears to have been an orchestrated campaign of complaints, and Longman was sacked.
Bruce Babbitt tried, suggesting that pensions had become a ‘forbidden subject’. Poor Bruce became the biggest loser in the race for the Democratic nomination. Donald Regan, formerly the President’s right-hand man, tried. He once said on television that pensions should be re-examined. He was pilloried by Congressional leaders. Where is he now?
On the face of it, the grey lobby will become even more powerful when the baby boomers come of age and take it over. Longman, who is himself a boomer, disagrees. “The baby boomers’ great strength is their numbers, but it is also their weakness. It makes it very difficult for them to organise effectively but, even if they do, it means that the rewards they get will have to be spread very thinly among them. I see the whole thing just falling apart. We may have a real war between the generations.”
It may not, however, be necessary to go as far as the Colorado Governor and start introducing a mandatory death penalty for the over 60s, or even medical rationing.
“We need to re-write the contract between the generations,” said Longman. “We have to start to target benefits on the basis of need rather than of seniority. Medical rationing is something I threaten people with. It will come to that if we don’t sort it out.”