Koch and Bull Story

The Scotsman and The New Zealand Dominion, 25 July 1988

As Ed Koch, the mayor of New York, left town last week to begin his trip to Europe, he unveiled the big policy decision the city had been waiting for. “I am picking my fights more carefully,” he announced. “But I am not avoiding them.” The mayor is always in fights.

Before his departure, he went the usual 15 rounds with the local press. One reporter asked who was paying for his trip to Europe. “It’s none of your business,”  he confided. Another asked about the future of a city fire station. “When I decide to tell you, I’ll tell you,” he snapped. Yet another asked about plain clothes police who had been arresting members of the Guardian Angels, the New York gang which fights street crime. “Don’t the police have better things to do?” she asked. “That’s the most idiotic statement I have heard,” said the mayor, who is trying to stay on the right side of the chief of police.

Then he closed in on the reporter. How would she feel if a bunch of Guardian Angels came up to her with their patrol dogs and started challenging her? The reporter looked blank. “Well, can’t you talk?” shot the mayor. “I mean, I don’t think…” began the reporter. “Yeah, you’re right,” he interrupted. “You don’t think.”

Always fighting. But after eleven unremitting years of the Koch and bull story, New York seems finally to be getting fed up with its always ebullient and often obnoxious mayor. Last week, he left a city with all the symptoms of battle fatigue after a particularly bruising spate of controversies.

What is more, he left behind him the Democratic party convention in Atlanta, an occasion which has previously been pleased to welcome him as one of the party’s most colourful advocates but which, this year, offered him no role at all. The political vultures say Koch’s fighting days are numbered.

Half the time he has been fighting himself. Since he first became mayor in 1978, Koch, who is now aged 63, has been promising to clean up his act and rein in his temper. Only last week, he was musing out loud that:”I have the feeling that I would do better if I could cultivate a bed-side manner.”  A likely story.

If he was ever going to manage it, he would have done it last year when he was laid out by a stroke. When he recovered, he was all mild-mannered and modest, promising he would ‘be nicer to people’ and talking about the ‘the more serious demeanour’ he was going to adopt. No chance.

He was soon punching out the state assembly (‘capable of selling their own mothers’) and the city council(‘idiots’), sniping at newspaper editorials(‘dopey’) and liberal lawyers(‘nuts’), and enraging black voters by declaring that “more whites are assaulted in this town by blacks than the other way around”. It got to the point where New Yorkers began to wonder out loud just what the stroke had done to their mayor’s brain.

“Listen,” he demanded. “People have called doctors to ask whether the stroke causes a deterioration in your brain governing your control mechanism. Oh please! That’s ridiculous.”

There was a time when intelligent political analysts found justifications for the mayor’s Crazy Eddie act. This was what New Yorkers wanted, they said. His outbursts got things done, they argued. And although an average of three press conferences a day and six newspaper columns a week might look like a severe addiction to publicity, this was really only a democratic attempt to involve the public in the city’s government.

Now New York seems to be running out of excuses for its mayor. An opinion poll in the New York Times earlier this month found that his popularity had slumped to an all-time low. Even two years ago, 66% of New Yorkers had a favourable opinion of him; now only 30% do. And, with a mayoral election due next year, an intimidating 58% said they believed it was time for someone else to take a shot at running their city.

Koch’s slump in popularity has alarmed his aides, who have been urging him to calm down. According to his campaign adviser, David Garth: “When Ed gets high, he gets confrontational. He becomes the impartial arbiter of life. He does his quote-unquote thing, which I do not think serves him well.”

Koch has been talking himself into an early political grave all year. When the rusting Williamsburg Bridge was suddenly closed in April to prevent a disastrous collapse, Koch shrugged and said it was not his fault if his two senior transport officials were ‘dummies’, an explanation which only infuriated the thousands of frustrated commuters who were caught in a month of traffic jams.

When ambulance workers asked for higher pay, Koch denounced them publicly and said they did not deserve the same pay as firemen and policemen; that provoked a one-day strike.  When the fire and police departments started a public squabble, Koch called their chiefs together to kiss and make up at a press conference and ended up screaming red-faced at them in a room full of reporters when they continued to bicker.

No matter what the issue, Koch is there. He ordered that homeless people be swept up and put into mental hospitals; the courts overturned the order. He ordered the street vendors who sell pretzels and hot dogs to get off the sidewalks of Manhattan; office workers who live off the vendors were furious.

Even the new mechanised street sweepers which roll through the city echo with the familiar sound of the ubiquitous mayor. If they meet an illegally parked car on their route, a recording of the Koch voice shouts:”This is Ed Koch, your mayor…PUHLEASE get it outta here.”

But the rant that finally wrecked him was his outburst during the New York primary when he waded blindly into the gentlemanly contest and raised racial hackles across the city by warning Jews that they would be crazy to cast a vote for Jesse Jackson. The Washington Post spelled out the message in language the mayor understands – “New York to Koch: Clam Up!”

But he can’t. Koch’s politics are inseparable from his personality. When he was first elected, he had novelty value. Now he is the party guest who lingers long past leaving time, still holding forth and oblivious to the yawning of his hosts. As he flew off across the Atlantic last week, he left behind him a battle field of bloodied policies.

An apparently simple, uncontroversial issue like trying to stop pit bull terriers from biting the citizens of New York has become an explosive confrontation between a city councillor, Carol Maloney, who wants to control any dog that behaves dangerously, and Mayor Koch, who wants to ban all pit bulls and never mind the other breeds. The two of them have been snapping and snarling at each other for weeks; meanwhile, on 127th Street, a 55-year-old Harlem man became the 190th New Yorker this year to discover what a dog’s dinner feels like.

The genuinely complicated business of hammering out the city’s budget for the next year turned into a political abattoir, as the mayor slugged it out with the City Council. They finally found a compromise at four minutes before midnight on June 30 – the deadline after which the city’s government would have plunged into a fiscal abyss. By that time, city councillors had informed the mayor that he was behaving like a vampire and ‘a one-man arsonist team’.

Along the coast, a score of beaches on Long Island and the city’s southern shoreline have been closed after hundreds of bloodied syringes, needles and other medical waste washed up on the sand. Three weeks after the first beach was closed, the mayor’s men are still chasing their tails: now saying there is no danger and the beaches can open; then closing them all again; now saying they are tracing the guilty hospital; then saying it has all come out through the city’s sewage system and has nothing to do with any hospital. The mayor has made no friends among the businesses which rely on the beach-goers for their trade.

Yet even as Koch’s political obituary is being written, he has thrown down the gauntlet by inviting challengers to declare themselves for the mayoral election in November next year and predicting that he can become the first man ever to be elected to a fourth term as the city’s leader. Some of his opponents give him cause for confidence.

Consider Howard Golden, leader of the Brooklyn Borough council, a product of the old New York City Democratic Party machine which unashamedly traded votes for jobs. Golden hates Koch. In March, the Brooklyn leader was at a hand-shaking ceremony with 100 Wall Street executives to celebrate the opening of a new business venture. But Koch was there too, and when they lined up for photographs at the end of the ceremony, Golden pouted and refused to have his picture taken with the mayor.

A month later, he repeated the performance by refusing to stand next to the mayor at a City Hall news conference and grabbing the microphone and twisting it away from Koch so that he could speak from the opposite side of the lectern. All this has created the impression that Golden lacks gravitas. At the moment, Golden is the leading candidate to run against Koch.

Apart from the lack of serious opposition, there is a cynical view among many New Yorkers that Koch had an ulterior motive for beating spending cuts out of the city council in this year’s budget negotiations. The cuts, they say, were unnecessary and were really designed to store up funds for next year so that the mayor with the mouth will have something good to talk about when the election campaign begins. The fight goes on.