There is a scurrilous but trendy magazine in New York called Spy which runs a regular feature under the title Separated At Birth. They dig out obscure pictures of the rich and famous and match up pairs of apparently unrelated people who turn out to share the same features: former Defence Secretary Caspar Weinberger and the French poet Jean Cocteau; the late head of the CIA William Casey and President Roosevelt’s wife, Eleanor; the loud comedienne Joan Rivers and an African baboon; and so on.
Today, as 4,161 delegates, 15,000 journalists and an estimated 20,000 rubber-neckers descend on Atlanta, Georgia for the convention of the Democratic Party, this column (being, as it is, increasingly scurrilous and unstoppably trendy) can disclose the identities of two American politicians who, the evidence strongly suggests, were themselves separated at birth.
The first is Lloyd Bentsen, the suddenly world-famous Senator from Texas who is due to be annointed as Mike Dukakis’ running mate in Atlanta this week. Consider the following facts about Mr Bentsen: he is in his mid-sixties; a tall well-groomed figure of patrician style; a former World War II pilot; a keen country club tennis player; a grandfather who has suffered the death of a young grandchild.
Remind you of anyone? More clues: he is a millionaire who has made a fortune in the oil business; his political base is the state of Texas; he supported civil rights for black people but tried to block key reforms; his wife is widely regarded as one of the most effective partners in US politics; he started his career with a brief period in the House of Representatives and left politics before returning to win much higher office.
Now here are the give-away clues: he promoted the whole ‘Reaganomics’ package of tax cuts for big business; he is an outspoken supporter of CIA-backed guerrillas in Nicaragua and Angola; he is in favour of compulsory prayers in state schools and of bigger defence budgets; he is opposed to gun control and abortion; he is an arch conservative and has an outstanding record of staunch support for President Reagan. Every one of these statements about Bentsen applies equally to another American politician. Yes, Lloyd Bentsen was separated at birth from Vice President George Bush, the man he is now set to run against.
Mike Dukakis’ decision to choose the Texas Senator as his running mate was a surprise, in the simple sense that very few people had predicted it, but it was also a shock to anyone who had allowed themselves to be lulled into believing that Dukakis actually stood for anything.
Bentsen is, to all intents and purposes, a member of the opposition party. The Congressional Quarterly, which is the house magazine of Washington politics, analysed his voting record and found he was more supportive of President Reagan than any other Democratic senator. He happens to be registered as a Democrat because he grew up in Texas at a time when the Democratic Party was the only party in the state: the Republicans had been dead on their back in Texas for years and the state Democrats embraced the whole political spectrum, particularly its most conservative and occasionally racist element.
Bentsen (or Bush, as you may prefer to call him) has next to nothing in common politically with Mike Dukakis. Bentsen is pro Star Wars; Dukakis is anti. Bentsen is pro capital punishment; Dukakis is anti. Bentsen is pro MX missiles; Dukakis is anti. Bentsen is pro Contras; Dukakis is anti (in fact, it was the one specific policy commitment Dukakis made when he declared his intention to run for the White House 15 months ago).
Dukakis has several hundred trade union activists among the delegates who are slated to support him at the convention and is expected to receive a formal endorsement from the union movement. But Bentsen is a spokesman for big business and includes the American Bankers Association, General Contractors of America and numerous large corporations among those who have funded his previous election efforts. So why has Dukakis chosen him? And where does his choice leave Jesse Jackson at this week’s convention?
There are broadly two reasons why Dukakis seems to have picked Bentsen. One is uncharacteristically romantic: Dukakis has a deep and nostalgic affection for the memory of John Kennedy, whose example as a Massachussetts senator and then as President shaped his own political ambitions. Dukakis keeps publicly comparing himself and his campaign to Kennedy in 1960, when Kennedy, of course, chose a conservative Texas senator, Lyndon Johnson, as his running mate, and went on to win Texas and the election.
But according to the current Washington folklore, Kennedy chose Johnson by mistake. Johnson had been running against Kennedy for the presidential nomination and had attacked the young senator as a namby-pamby northern liberal. Kennedy’s aides, apparently encouraged by Johnson, believed that the acerbic Texan would rather trot down Pennsylvania Avenue in a tutu than serve under the despised Kennedy and so, purely out of courtesy and in order to mollify Johnson’s foul temper, Kennedy offered him the Number Two spot, knowing he would turn it down. And Johnson went and accepted it.
Dukakis’ other reason for choosing Bentsen is more important and much more in line with the man’s character. The key to Dukakis is his dogged persistance: his hobby is cross-country running; he is a second generation immigrant, determined to succeed in his adopted homeland; he is unusually disciplined and determined. He has picked Bentsen because – regardless of philosophy or feeling – he believes Bentsen will help him to win and that is what matters to him.
The belief is based on several Bentsen assets. First, the Texan is a wizard at fund-raising. Before Dukakis’ call, Bentsen had been preparing to run for re-election to the senate in November and had already raised $5.05 million – more than any other candidate in the whole Congress. Dukakis must know that his own victory in the primaries was largely due to the fact that he had raised twice as much as his nearest opponent and that he needs a lot more to beat Bush.
Second, winning an election is not so much about winning arguments as deciding which issues are going to be argued about in the first place. Bush has been doing well in the polls for the last three weeks because he has shifted the debate on to Dukakis’ record and, specifically, to the claim that Dukakis is a liberal – a dirty word to many Americans. Nobody ever accused Lloyd Bentsen of being a liberal, so now Dukakis can shove the argument back towards Bush’s record in the White House, his tangled connections with Oliver North and his sycophantic attitude to the President.
And that raises the most important issue – the Reagan legacy. The man who wins the election in November will be the one who captures the swing voters. The problem for the Dukakis camp is that the wretched swing voters all voted for Reagan in 1984 and, the polls suggest, they still support him.
So, last week, Dukakis had a choice: he could stick to his principles and try to persuade the swing voters to come round to his way of thinking or he could choose Ronald Reagan as his running mate. Reagan was otherwise engaged; George Bush would have done nearly as well but he was busy too; so they put out the welcome mat for George Bush’s long lost twin brother. Never mind the principles, the death penalty, the Contras, the Reaganomics and the rest. It’s winning that counts. But will it work?
A key job for Bentsen is to deliver Texas for Dukakis as Lyndon Johnson did for Kennedy, but that is a much more difficult trick now than it was in 1960. In 1960, Johnson and Kennedy just scraped home in Texas by a tiny margin of only 46,233 votes. But twenty eight years later, their Republican opposition in the state is immeasurably more powerful and better organised and, crucially, it is fielding a candidate whose whole political career has been built in Texas.
Bentsen’s other main task is fund-raising, an area which could now blow up in Dukakis’ face. In the past, Bentsen has raised much of his money through the controversial use of Political Action Committees, which are set up by various special interests and industries to promote politicians who support their causes. Apart from opening up loopholes in election laws, the committees are often criticised for simply buying political influence. One of their sternest critics in the last year has been Mike Dukakis. Will Bentsen now turn his back on all his old PAC connections? Or will Dukakis dump this principle as well?
Bentsen has a more specific problem with fund-raising over an incident two years ago when he tried to set up a ‘breakfast club’ charging lobbyists and PAC organisers $10,000 each for the privilege of sharing his breakfast and his thoughts. He had already raised $90,000 when a howl of protest forced him to close the club. He returned the money. More than half the donors insisted on giving it back to him (“No, Lloyd, really, the kedgeree was so good.”) In the next few months, those breakfasts are going to become famous and, possibly, dangerous.
But these difficulties all take second place to the immediate problem of Jesse Jackson and how he handles the convention this week. The calculation by the Dukakis camp is a smug one – Jackson and his supporters may be angry, but they have nowhere else to go. They have to support Dukakis.
From a constitutional point of view, that is not true. There is nothing to stop Jackson running for President as an independent candidate and, if he did, he could take many of the seven million people who voted for him in the primaries and some of the ten million who voted for the formerly liberal Dukakis and, although he would not win the White House, he could torpedo the Democratic Party’s warship way below the water line, and teach Dukakis an unforgettable lesson.
From a political point of view, however, Jackson looks trapped. He will not want to be blamed for giving the Republicans another four years in the White House. Even though the truth might be that he has a significant following among black and white progressives and a legitimate political right to try and salvage the self-respect of the progressive wing of the party, he is already being caricatured as a sulky egomaniac, and any attempt to fight the party leadership would be vulnerable to a devastating personal attack.
It appears that the smug calculation of the Dukakis camp may be justified: Jackson may shake the chains but he won’t break them. Dukakis and Bentsen may also raise a lot of money and even win Texas. The two of them may be perfect fig leaves for each other’s most embarrassing parts and walk hand in hand all the way to the White House.
But Dukakis should be careful. If George Bush plays this electoral game with the same cynicism as the Democrats, he could yet shock the lot of them with his choice of running mate. How about Mario Cuomo, for example, the darling of the Democrats? Or maybe Cuomo has a long lost brother somewhere.