Why don’t American sports fans attack each other?

The Scotsman and The New Zealand Dominion, 20 June 1988

A Saturday night in Cincinnati and down at the Riverfront Baseball Stadium, the Reds are in trouble. They have been playing a tight game and are holding the New York Mets at 5-5 in the dying minutes when the last man batting for the Mets starts off on a run which will decide the game. The man runs to first base; the ball is thrown there ahead of him; surely he is out; but no, the umpire, Dave Pallone, waves him on. Pandemonium. Disaster. 6-5 to the Mets.

It looks as though it’s all over for the Cincinnati Reds. But now here comes their manager, feisty Pete Rose, striding out on to the field, strutting over to umpire Pallone, poking his finger in Pallone’s face, shoving Pallone back on his heels, barging and bellyaching and yelling in his face. On the radio, the commentators are going wild, calling Pallone all kinds of names. Now, 40,000 spectators are joining in – cheering and jeering and starting to throw beer cans and cigarette lighters at Pallone, who finally turns and runs for the dressing room.

The next day, all America takes part in the post mortem. Nobody is too worried about Pete Rose. It is the involvement of the spectators which causes the collective anxiety attack. The crowds at American sporting events just do not behave badly, and this outbreak of mass disorder in Cincinnati last month was treated like a full-blooded riot. For even though violence is a cliche of American life – the muggings, the assassinations, the blood and guts movies, the Saturday night special in every home – it is almost entirely absent among sports spectators, a curious paradox in the light of the recurrent violence in sport in other superficially less violent parts of the world.

Last week, for example, while European football was once again deteriorating into gang war, I went to Baltimore to watch the Orioles play baseball. There was a huge stadium, a partisan crowd, beer going down in gallons, a tense game and some muggy heat but never the hint of aggression on the terraces. Just children playing tag round the benches and families eating picnics and lots of guys in baseball caps lounging around, jawing on about the best pitcher they ever saw.

For his outburst in Cincinnati, Pete Rose was fined $1,000 and suspended for 30 days, the most severe punishment ever meted out to a baseball manager. He was mighty aggrieved, as he later told the press: “I could have shoved Pallone to the outfield fence and he was in no danger of getting hurt. He gets better contact dancing than what I gave him.” But the baseball authorities were in an unforgiving mood – because the spectators had joined in his antics. They even summoned the radio commentators to New York to slap their wrists for whipping up the crowd’s emotions.

Violence among players and officials is relatively common, on and off the field. The most celebrated exponent of this practice, the absolute prima donna prize heavyweight hitman of American sport is the manager of the New York Yankees baseball team, Billy Martin, who is aged 60 and still flashing his fists.

He has been leaving his knuckle prints on the game for more than 30 years, first as a player and then as a manager. His first public bout  was back in 1953 when he found it necessary to floor an opponent from the St Louis Browns in the middle of a game, for which he was fined $150. He went on to offer a little physical discouragement to a series of other players including a pitcher from the Chicago Cubs who received a broken jaw in 1960. Bumptious Billy was fined $500 for that, although the pitcher tried to sue him for $1 million.

Some of his most famous fights have been off the field: the bar room brawl in Manhattan when a local grocer got his nose broken and his jaw fractured; the time in the airplane when a Texan official had his mouth thumped while he was still strapped into his seat; the altercation with the sports reporter who got a black eye and $7,500 in damages; the encounter with the marshmallow salesman in Minnesota – “He fell and cut his lip,” said Billy at first, before later admitting the truth.

He has perfected his own idosyncratic insult for umpires he disapproves of. He stalks out on to the field, bristling all over and grinding his teeth and does an accelerated knees-up in front of the umpire which is designed to scatter dirt up the officials legs. He is said to have borrowed the idea from a veteran player who used to show his disdain for officials by drop-kicking his cap at them. Last month in California, however, Billy topped an outbreak of dirt-kicking by grabbing two handfuls of dirt and flinging them in the umpire’s face – “like a six-year-old brat in a sandbox” as the New York Times put it. He got a three-day suspension for that.

The point about Billy Martin is that he is a sporting legend and his team is top of the American League. And although he is notorious, he is far from unique. Bursting into the game to berate an official is common not only in baseball but also in basketball and ice hockey. In an ice hockey game last month, the coach of the New Jersey Devils, Jim Schoenfeld, became so exasperated with the referee that he chased him from the rink and all the way down the corridor to his dressing room calling him ‘a fat pig’ and repeatedly inviting him to ‘go have another doughnut’.

The next day, the ice hockey authorities punished Schoenfeld by suspending him for just one game. Schoenfeld, however, objected to this mild rebuke and got a court order over-ruling the suspension. That caused more trouble that night, when Schoenfeld appeared at the rink side for the Devils’ next game and the referee and his linesmen staged a wildcat strike in protest. They had to draft in amateur substitute officials to take their place. The game then proceeded with the usual fistfights and exchanges of abuse between the players.

Sports commentators shrugged their shoulders at the incident. Robin Finn of the New York Times, for example, said that Schoenfeld “has emotional and symbolic importance for the Devils. His relatively young and untested players have relied upon his fiery encouragement to make them more aggressive.”

The conclusion that begins to emerge is that American sport tolerates an unusually high level of aggression and even violence from its participants and that this may change the emotional chemistry of sporting events so that the spectators are less likely to become aggressive and violent themselves. But this is a little too glib – as well as being uncomfortably close to a pat on the back for barmy Billy Martin.

American sport does certainly tolerate high levels of violence. Just look at the body contact in American football compared to European football. Just look, if you can bear to, at American wrestling. It is like a children’s pantomime sprayed with blood. The wrestlers all play stereo-typed characters in the ring. You can watch Kimala the Ugandan Headhunter or Brutus Beafcake or The Animal (who used to be a school teacher in Detroit) or The Junk Yard Dog or Gorgeous Jimmy Garvin. Most contests start as a simple clash between good and evil, and end up in confusion, but who cares as long as there is plenty of blood. Real blood, that is. None of your cissy ketchup stuff.

To ensure a free flow of the red stuff, wrestlers often climb into the ring with a razor blade secreted in their costume. The idea is to smuggle it out in the middle of a good clinch and nick your opponent’s scalp – or even your own. There was a fight in Philadelphia two years ago when a wrestler called Wahoo McDaniel set out to nick a little technicolour lump out of his forehead and accidentally embedded the razor blade in his head.

By the time the fight was finished, Wahoo’s face was a sticky scarlet mess and the Pennsylvania Athletic Commission decided that enough was enough. They banned the use of blades. Wrestling promoters rose in anger and lobbied the Pennsylvania state legislature and persuaded them that in the interest of spectacle they should kill off the Athletic Commission. So blades are back, along with belts, chairs, guitars, bottles and anything else the wrestlers can lay their hands on and bring into the ring.

In most states, the sport has only the thinnest veneer of supervision. The Washington Monthly magazine recently recalled that: “A 1985 show at the Nassau Coliseum featured a steel-cage match between Captain Lou Alabano, then 52 and grotesquely obese, and Classy Fred Blassie, then 69 and with an artificial hip that forced him to walk with the aid of a cane. Thanks to the attending physician, we have it on good authority that Albano’s and Blassie’s diastolic readings passed muster.”

If it were true that the spectacle of violent sportsmen tends to pacify spectators, then American wrestling would have trouble-free crowds. In fact, wrestling has staged some of the few American sporting riots, most memorably the battle at Madison Square Garden when 500 fans swarmed over the ring, injuring two policemen and splintering 200 chairs.

The explanation for America’s relative immunity to violent spectators seems to lie outside sport in the back streets of its cities and in particular in the nature of its street gangs, which are quite different to those which have just been wreaking havoc in European football.

American street gangs are ethnic. They are the products of cities which have been created entirely by waves of immigration and which now have the shape of ethnic patchworks – the Italians, the Poles, the Greeks, the Jews, the blacks, the Vietnamese each in their own neighbourhood and each, therefore, with a distinct turf to protect and exploit.

European street gangs, by comparison, have always been an artificial affair with no distinct turf and no clear dividing line between them. But you have to have a gang. What else is Saturday for? A football team is the ideal pretext, a vehicle for the business of battle, a travelling totem to be defended at home against invaders and then pushed deep into enemy territory when the chance comes. Sport has become the unfortunate justification for gangs who would otherwise have no reason to strap on their bother boots.

American street gangs do not need to involve themselves in sport and in fighting for their team. They are too busy fighting for their turf and, often enough, for their lives in the drug wars. The result is that America has some mean streets but sports stadiums where players and officials have a virtual monopoly on violence.