Death of the town that sold death

Scotland on Sunday diary column, 30 May 1988

They had a little beauty contest in Washington state last year where each contestant had to bring a sample of local produce from her home town. They could bring corn or apples or tourist knick-knacks, whatever they felt symbolised their community. Marcia Cillan, however, brought uranium pellets. Because Marcia comes from Richland – the town that makes bombs for a living.

In Richland, thermonuclear warfare is a way of life. The school football team is called The Bombers. The town emblem is a mushroom cloud. Inside the high school, the floor of the main foyer boasts a mosaic of tiles in the shape of a hydrogen bomb. This is no place to be a pacifist: a high school student who suggested last year that the school could find a non-nuclear crest was bullied to the point of tears by his class mates.

This love affair with the bomb is, however, at root a professional relationship. Richland’s history and, more important, its economy are entirely focussed on the production of weapons-grade plutonium for the Pentagon. Before the bomb, the town had only 240 people; now it has a population of just over 30,000. The bomb business directly employs 14,000 local men and women. For the inhabitants of Richland, therefore, this week’s Moscow summit and the ratification of the treaty to ban short-range missiles are anxious occasions, the symbolic end to the affair. Half of the bomb-makers will lose their jobs within the next five years, and for the rest, the future is unclear.

The relationship has however been deteriorating for years, and the slow death of Richland is a parable for the nuclear age, the story of a community killed off by the contradictions of nuclear weapons.

Just north of Richland, where the wide Columbia River pushes its way through the sagebrush and the windswept grey desert, stands a drab concrete column and a cluster of rusting metal sheds. This is ‘B reactor’, built in 1943, the birthplace of the atomic bomb and also of the local economy. It was plutonium from this reactor which lit up the skies over New Mexico in the first atomic explosion in July 1945, and which a month later destroyed the Japanese city of Nagasaki and 40,000 of its people.

Richland rapidly became a cornerstone of the Manhattan Project, the multi-million dollar American drive to create an atomic arsenal during the nuke-happy decades of the cold war. The Pentagon liked its remoteness and the ready supply of water. Seven more reactors were built along the banks of the Columbia in the shadow of Rattlesnake Mountain, all of them exclusively devoted to concocting thousands of nuclear warheads for Polaris, Pershing, cruise, minuteman and their ilk. Richland thrived. A ninth reactor, built in 1963, divided its time between producing military plutonium and generating electricity.

Everything was looking just fine until the late 1960s, when Richland first learned that genocide is a dying business, particularly the nuclear variety. The trouble is that plutonium has a shelf life that stretches from here to eternity: you can explode the stuff and bring eternity a little closer, or you can stockpile it and endlessly recycle the same plutonium through each succeeding generation of missiles. In either case, there comes a point when you no longer need the row of reactors along the Columbia River.

If Richland had been producing a commodity which anybody really wanted, the town could have carried on expanding. But after 25 years, even the voracious appetite of the US military was sated by the town’s diligent workers. If they had been producing something which rotted and needed replacing, they might have been alright, but the virulent longevity of plutonium gave them little hope. Orders from the Pentagon slumped, and Richland started to shut down its reactors.

The one reactor which might have survived was the ninth – known as “N Reactor” – which was turning out 860 megawatts of power for the electrical grid of the north western United States as well as its quota of warheads, but Richland’s efforts to keep N Reactor alive rebounded on the town. For on closer examination, the reactor and its eight older neighbours all turned out to be riddled with safety hazards.

Some of the hazards were simply a matter of old age, although the speed of the reactors’ decline had not been anticipated by those who built them. They were designed to last for 40 years; none of them has yet made it past 30. But, in an appealing irony, many of the hazards were side effects of the radioactive plutonium. Richland’s deadly industry, it transpired, was poisoning itself.

According to a report by the National Research Council, N Reactor was “beginning to experience life-limiting material aging caused by irradiation and corrosion”. Specifically, they found that after years of radioactive bombardment, the reactor’s 1700-ton graphite core had started to swell, heaving slowly out against the cooling system. The cooling tubes themselves had been parched by radiation and were ready to crack.

The council’s chairman, Richard Meserve, was asked if the reactor was still safe. “We are not in a position to make that determination,” he said. “The term `safe’ does not lend itself to easy definition.” This was hardly a vote of confidence.

The town’s efforts to preserve their last reactor suffered a nasty blow in April 1986 when the Russian power plant at Chernobyl blew up. Chernobyl, like N Reactor, had a graphite core and lacked the concrete and steel containment dome which surrounds more modern designs. In January 1987, the political fall-out from Chernobyl finally saw N Reactor shut down like its eight neighbours.

At the time, the Department of Energy said it was only a temporary closure while they carried out $50 million of repairs. Since then, the bill has gone up to $70 million, and Mr Gorbachev and President Reagan have taken steps to prevent any revival in the plutonium market. Two months ago, with the December arms summit in Washington behind them, the department announced that they had no plans to re-open it.

“The treaty and the arms summits have been used as a justification to close down the reactor,” according to Bill Klink of Westinghouse, the company which runs most of Richland’s bomb-making. “When they destroy those missiles, they can just recycle the plutonium. Business has kind of slumped off here in the last few months.”

Apart from being obsolescent, unsafe and out of step with the INF treaty, Richland is also unpopular with some its neighbours who do not share their economic interest in belligerent patriotism. As a result, state senators are doing little to help Richland. “We definitely want to get out of the business,” said Senator Brock Adams. “We think its going to screw up the river and ruin the state.”

Richland is struggling in its death throes. Unlike anywhere else in the United States, the town has been crying out for nuclear waste and has been campaigning hard to become the dumping ground for the high-level waste which no-one else wants. Congress, however, prefers the Nevada desert where there is no river to worry about and where the population of snakes and kangaroo rats has registered no objection.

The town has made a pitch for the contemporary equivalent of the Manhattan Project – Star Wars. But all they have got is a space reactor known as the SP-100, which tests nuclear reactors which are to be used in space. “It’s pretty small potatoes in the whole space programme,” as Bill Klink of Westinghouse puts it.

There was talk of turning the rusting site – particularly B Reactor – into a shrine for tourists to visit. “But you have to jump through a whole bunch of hoops to do that,” says Klink. “There’s too much paperwork and bureaucracy.”

All that is really left for the town is a form of industrial cannibalism. They can earn a living dismantling their own old reactors and other similar ones from around the country and burying their low-level radioactive skeletons deep beneath their land, turning the cradle of the atom bomb into a vast graveyard.

When they come to tear down the old B Reactor, they will find a poster on the wall, dating from 1956, in which an actor wearing goggles urges them to obey safety rules for their own good. The face of this concerned young actor is familiar…It is Ronald Reagan, who is now a long way from Richland.

**********

Up-date on Evan Mecham, the spectacularly unpleasant former Governor of Arizona, who was bounced out of office in April after enraging blacks, Jews, Catholics, homosexuals and anyone else in Arizona who disliked having a sleazeball for a Governor. The great leader finally appeared in court last week to answer charges of fraud and perjury over a $350,000 campaign contribution. He pleaded Not Guilty. Unfortunately, in the same week, his successor, the supposedly squeaky clean Rose Mofford, was accused by the press of sneaking thousands of dollars of public money into her own pocket to pay for gifts, decorations and a joke-writing service to help her out with her speeches. This was particularly ironic since the one thing the dreadful Mecham did for Arizona was to keep it in jokes: Why did Evan Mecham cancel Easter? Because he heard the eggs were going to be coloured…Why does Evan Mecham open his mouth? So he can change feet…What’s the difference between a skunk being run over on the freeway and Evan Meecham being run over on the freeway? There’d be skid marks in front of the skunk…And bumper stickers: I’ll take a urine test if Mecham will take an IQ test…Don’t get mad. Get Evan….You have to laugh.