The dull shall inherit the White House

The Scotsman and The New Zealand Dominion, 9 May 1988

It’s been a super-smug year for the Republicans. The economy is
holding up; Gorbachev is playing the game; peace is breaking out
in Nicaragua, Angola and Afghanistan; George Bush has emerged
gracefully from the primaries as the new heir; and in the White
House, the old boy carries on chuckling and checking his
horoscope while his problems get tired of waiting and go away.

If you put that alongside the Democrats’ tale of scandal and
disunity, it is easy to see why Bush is a hot favourite to win
the election in six months’ time. The pundits and the pollsters
are lining up behind him. Not even the Democrat party faithful
seem to believe he is beatable: a recent Washington Post poll
recorded that 50% of registered Democrats accepted that they
would lose the election.

Senior Democrats toy privately with the idea that they will
become a permanent party of opposition. They have lost four of
the last five elections and three of them by landslides. The
Reagan co-alition of economic conservatives and religious
hardliners may, they fear, be here to stay, leaving them to guard
the moral conscience of the country but not to run it. The truth,
however, may be a lot more interesting and quite a bit more fun.

The first point is that American elections are deeply shallow. In
the entire history of US presidential elections, the victor has
never polled more votes than the no-shows. When Reagan won in
1984 with the votes of 31% of the electorate, he was a mile and
half behind the 47% of American voters who simply could not be
bothered to take part.

But more than that, the evidence is that those who do take the
trouble to vote, make their choice on irrational or at best
flimsy grounds. It is a trend which is apparent in all
democracies but which has been heavily encouraged here by the
role of television as gate-keeper to the electoral debate: subtle
ideas and complicated facts are banned. They are boring. They
don’t make pictures.

The basic political strategy for a Presidential contender is
two-fold. First, keep hitting the evening news bulletins with
plenty of pictures of yourself smiling and waving and chewing out
the snappy one-liners. Second, no bloopers. That’s when
television turns around and bites you in the ankle – when you
make the blooper.

Remember Richard Nixon’s running mate, Spiro Agnew, referring to
an overweight reporter from Baltimore, who happened to have
oriental parents, as “the fat Jap” or glibly declaring that “if
you’ve seen one slum, you’ve seen them all”. Sweet music for TV
news producers. Or there was Ronald Reagan in the last campaign
solemnly telling reporters that trees cause air pollution; at his
next stop someone had hung a sign from a large tree pleading:
“Chop me before I kill again.” The pictures ran from coast to
coast.

Agnew and Reagan survived their bloopers. But Gerald Ford never
recovered from the television debate when he put his foot in a
hole by claiming that Yugoslavians do not resent Soviet rule and
then panicked and buried himself up to his neck by saying that
neither did the Romanians. Nor the Poles. As far as the TV news
was concerned, it was the only thing he said during the entire
debate.

The power of the blooper is only the most visible sign of the
basic underlying rule that this largely indifferent and generally
ill-informed electorate is swayed by negatives and, in
particular, by simple ones. McGovern and Mondale lost their
elections because they were too liberal, Nixon lost in 76 because
he was too crooked, Carter lost because he could not get the
American hostages out of Teheran. It is Yah Boo politics,
old-fashioned, nose-snubbing, finger-pointing playground stuff.

So the most important question about the two men who have emerged
as the likely candidates for this year’s election is not who has
the soundest approach to the federal budget deficit nor who best
understands the politics of thermonuclear conflict but simply who
is the most likely to survive the remaining six months without
getting into trouble.

Here, it is Mike Dukakis and not the favoured Bush who looks
best. Dukakis’ greatest potential weakness is that he is dull,
really deadly dull. In another year, running against a Reagan or
a Nixon, that alone would probably be enough to kill him. But
against George Bush, the yawn-a-minute man, it is no problem.

At the moment, Dukakis is also vulnerable to the charge that he
is a nobody. There is George Bush, former ambassador to China,
former head of the CIA, vice President, a famous and
well-established figure, while Dukakis has never held a national
office; he looks like a novice. But that problem will soon
dissolve if Dukakis wins the nomination at the Democrat
convention in July. The little man will then be swept off by a
tide of publicity on a scale which could make Kermit the frog
look like a natural leader.

Dukakis’ special advantage in the Yah Boo stakes is that he is
almost entirely without character. He doesn’t drink or chase
women; he doesn’t lose his temper or cry in public; he pays his
taxes regularly; he has never tried to get rich quick; he is
highly disciplined and very unlikely to suddenly start casting
aspersions on Yugoslavians or local plant life. There may not be
much to get excited about. But, more important, there is nothing
to complain about. That is the secret of his survival so far and
his greatest asset for the next six months.

George Bush is not so safe. He has a history of medium-range
bloopers: boasting into an unseen microphone that he had “kicked
a little ass” in his 1984 television debate with Geraldine
Ferraro; irritating American car workers last year by suggesting
that Russian mechanics could do a better job; cracking
embarrassing jokes in Poland in February about whether Lech
Walesa had any relatives voting in the Iowa caucus.

He has also failed to shake off the insistent allegation that he
is lying about his role in the Iran Contra scandal, a failure
which has already seen him widely portrayed as the Velcro Vice
President, to whom everything sticks, in contrast to his Teflon
boss.

This is evidently beginning to get through to the voters.
According to the polls, he has a higher “negative rating” than
any other candidate from either party apart from Jesse Jackson.
Twenty three per cent of people have already decided that they
will definitely not vote for him.

Dukakis also has a couple of other things running for him. For
example, he is relatively young, only 54. Bush is more than ten
years older; if he is elected, he will be nearly 70 at the end of
his first term. This mattered less for Reagan who ran as an old
man when the rest of the world – ie the Soviet Union – was still
run by old men, but since 1985, the ebullient Mikhail Gorbachev
has changed that. It would be no surprise to see age emerging as
a nice simple made-for-TV issue this autumn.

Finally, there are signs that America may be just tired of
Reaganism and ready for a change. An ABC television poll in
February asked voters to set aside the bewildering field of
candidates and to choose between an unnamed Republican and an
unnamed Democrat; the Democrats, surprisingly, came out ahead by
46% to 43% The explanation seems to be that while the poor have
been alienated from Reagan throughout his eight years in the
White House, they have recently been joined – perhaps since last
October’s Wall Street crash – by the middle class who are
suddenly anxious that they may lose what they have gained in his
tenure if they don’t curb their greed, calm down and sort out the
economy.

Woodrow Wilson wrote at the beginning of this century
that:”America is now sauntering through her resources and through
the mazes of her politics with easy nonchalance; but presently
there will come a time when she will be surprised to find herself
grown old – a country crowded, strained, perplexed, when she will
be obliged to pull herself together, adopt a new regimen of life,
husband her resources, concentrate her strength, steady her
methods, sober her views, restrict her vagaries, trust her best,
not her average members. That will be the time of change.” Watch
Dukakis.