The East Enders who showed New York how to play

Previously unpublished, 1 May 1988

This is the story of two boys from Bethnal Green, Brian and Keith, and their adventures in New York. It’s a good story: rags turn to riches, good guys get the girls and, best of all, the swanky know-all Americans are taught a couple of lessons they shouldn’t forget by our mild-mannered British heroes.

One of the lessons is about sex. Americans often behave as though they invented it; they have more words for it than the Eskimos do for snow; they boast about it, worry about it, sing about it, slobber about it and use it to sell almost everything in their universe. But Brian and Keith McNally put them in their place.

Then there is snobbery. It is one of the Great American Myths that the United States is classless, that while there may be differences in income, there are no barriers for those who have the will and the talent to reach the top. The truth is that the American elite is so insecure as a class that it is virulently snobbish, throwing up barriers on all sides to protect itself against intruders. Particularly in Manhattan, which is where the lads from London made their pitch.

The story begins late in 1976. Brian and Keith had left home in the East End, where their father was a stevedore in the docks, and arrived in New York with no money, no plans, and no intention of even staying. Brian, the older of the two brothers, then aged 27, had dropped out in the sixties and had not yet come back: “I was the last hippy. I was going to work for a few months in New York, then go to LA and down to South America.”

Keith, then aged 25, had been working backstage in London theatres. “But I just wanted to travel,” he says. So he took to waiting on tables as a means of paying his way. In New York, he found a job as a waiter at One Fifth, which was just taking off as The Only Place To Go for the city’s self-consciously fashionable elite. Brian joined him there as a bar-tender. It was the beginning of a new dynasty.

In the next ten years, the two scruffy Londoners simply took over the heart of New York nightlife. Or, to be more precise, they transplanted its heart –  away from the clubs and restaurants which then gripped the city’s glitterati and into their own creations. The end result now, a mere decade later, is that a total of five of the trendiest watering holes in Manhattan are owned and run by the McNally boys.

Each of them owns two rage-of-the-minute restaurants and Keith also owns Nells nightclub – run by Little Nell Campbell of Rocky Horror Show fame – where Prince goes dancing on his nights off, where Eddie Murphy was turned away for refusing to pay the entrance fee, and where you can still see the scratch marks on the door from the night Grace Jones lost her temper and attacked the bouncers.

The empire grew organically out of their first days in Manhatten. At One Fifth, Keith soon became part of the attraction, graduating from waiting on tables to Maitre D’ and then to manager of the restaurant, recruiting along the way another waitress, Lynn Wagenknecht, whom he married. Brian drifted off from his job behind the bar into the New York art world, organising concerts for old blues musicians at Carnegie Hall, shooting off to New Mexico to produce videos. But by the middle of 1980, they were beginning to feel restless and so the two brothers and Lynn Wagenknecht decided to have a little adventure. They would open a restaurant.

It was an exercise in rule-breaking. For a start, they went to an area known as TriBeCa, south of Greenwich Village. “At that time,” said Brian,”nobody went to TriBeCa. Nobody. It was a godforsaken area.” They found an old cafeteria, The Towers, and borrowed $35,000 from friends and contacts to buy the lease.

An American would have moved in and torn out all the 40s interior and lined it with artificial leather and red spot-lights. The McNallys could not afford to go tearing anything out, and anyway, they were not American. They cleaned up the old interior and made a virtue of its age. They could not afford too much new furniture either. “We bought a lot of second hand stuff,” said Brian. “We had a whole load of barbers chairs. Nothing matched anything else.”

They called it The Odeon and in October 1980, with a further $125,000 sunk into the project, they opened the doors. And waited. They soon found out the truth about American snobs – that they are no more secure about their fashions and fads than they are about their class.

The lure of a secure, comfortable refuge in horrible TriBeCa turned out to be a magnet for New York’s socialites. The Odeon’s scruffy edges were a relief from the plush and pompous places uptown, as Brian McNally recalls: “At that time, all the restaurants were getting fancier and fancier. In New York, you could get good food, but you would have to deal with a formal, stiff, sneering French Maitre D’. Or you would get a casual place and the food would be revolting. We tried to get a casual place where you could eat something decent.”

As simple as that. While the glitzy uptown restaurants continued to peddle the same old image, the McNallys repeated their deliberately unpretentious formula. Brian sold his share in The Odeon to Keith and opened Indochine and the Canal Bar. Keith opened the Cafe Luxembourg and Nells Club. The crowds poured in to all of them, depositing increasingly large sums of money in the pockets of the two Londoners.

The McNallys had taken Manhattan snobbery and turned it on its head. The wealthy Americans who had always guarded their exclusive social life like miser’s gold had suddenly woken up to find a gold rush on the other side of town. Their own little pile of glitter up on Fifth Avenue lost its lustre by comparison. They had been outsnobbed.

The result is at its most poignant every night around midnight on a windswept pavement on West 14th Street where a crowd gathers around an anonymous doorway – the entrance to Nell’s Club, Keith McNally’s finest creation.

All of New York is here. There are teenage girls in bum-hugging mini-skirts, teenage guys in leather and Levis, middle-aged couples in fur and jewels, businessmen smoothing their suits, hustlers flexing their muscles, tourists checking their guides, the occasional fabulously famous face, all shivering and shaking in the cold night air and all longing for just one thing – to get through that door. But that simple little thing is so difficult.

The crowd of supplicants is held back from the door by a rope fence. Beyond that, with their broad backs to the door, stand three towering bouncers with their arms crossed and their faces frozen. In front of them, a slim girl paces backwards and forwards with a clipboard. She is called Jessica and she has the most powerful job in New York’s club land: she decides who comes in and who stays out in the cold.

So, who will get in? Club members? There is no membership. The rich? It only costs five dollars. The powerful? Not here. Maybe it is just for people who appeal to Keith McNally, the kind of people he would let into his house. “I wouldn’t let any of them into my house,” he says.

Every few minutes, another car stops in the street and more hopefuls join the crowd. A chauffeur opens a limo door and stands back while two huge fur coats balloon out of the back seat on to the pavement, the smooth tanned skin of their occupants’ faces just barely visible amidst the fluff. They think this is a queue. They are not used to queueing. But this is the famous Nells Club, so they will wait politely.

Just then, a shadowy figure rolls into sight, chewing gum and swinging his shoulders as he walks. He is wearing running shoes, old jeans and a cowboy hat, and he is black. He slides through the crowd, Jessica lifts the rope, the bouncers stand back, and he is in. The fur balloons stir. “Excuse me…. Excuse me…. I say, Miss…” Jessica smiles stiffly. “I don’t think we are going to be able to help you,” she says.

Other voices vie for Jessica’s attention. “I’m on the guest list… I’m a friend of Nell’s… I slept with Nell… I’m just visiting Earth for two hours and I have instructions to get into this club… I’ll pay. Look. I’ll pay.” Another car stops. A teenage boy in tweeds and thick glasses gets out. This is his big night. His parents are in New York for the weekend. He has told them all about himself and his fine life in the big city and about Nells and how he, their teenage son, can get them in.

He struts up to the rope with his parents scuttling in his wake. “Hi. Is Mikey there?” No, there is no Mikey here. “Well, err. Is it OK if we come in?” No, it is not. Suddenly, the evening’s boasts are crumbling. “Well, err. My parents. They’re only here for the weekend. They’ve come all this way.” Jessica gives him the stiff smile. “I don’t think you should hang around,” she says. Next to them, a plump pair in their party best are beginning to crack. “I told you they wouldn’t let us in.” “How the heck was I supposed to know they’d want a piece of my gonad?” “Well, it was your idea.” And so it goes on.

On the other side of the door, things are warm and welcoming. The ground floor is like an English gentleman’s club, cluttered with old armchairs and slightly ragged sofas. There is a long bar, dim lights, aging ceiling fans stirring the air and three guys playing jazz. Downstairs, there is an acre of dancing space and music to make the floor shake. It is a playground for the young and energetic. Which is where the sex comes in.

All kinds of people have made it through the obstacle course outside: here’s a huge fat man with a bald head and a stick, then two men with pony tails, lots of pretty young girls, an intense youth with black rimmed glasses sitting scribbling in a corner, two women wrapped around each other on a sofa deep in conversation, groups of people jabbering at the bar, Dolly Parton, Jack Nicholson, Faye Dunaway, Gary Kasparov and a table full of Russians, secretaries, shop assistants, nobodies who feel like somebody tonight, and Nell.

“Sex and conversation,” she said. “I would like to think this place is about sex and conversation.” She is right, but it is not the sort of sex that Americans usually sell. In a normal American club, everything is deliberately designed to be sexy: the music, the videos, the waitresses, the barmen, the lighting. The end result is like someone shouting a smutty story over a loud-hailer. You just don’t want to hear it. Nells does something much more subtle: the club is just comfortable and easy – the sexy thing is the people, at least, those who get in.

Nell – Australian by birth but a Londoner by adoption – flutters through the club, wearing something very small and tight with leopard spots on it. “I love it,” she says. “It’s much better than being in a play because it’s different every night. I never know how long it will last. It’s like asking how long will an affair last.” All around the place, in dark corners, they are playing out the rituals of urban mating. It is getting hotter. The jabber level is rising. Downstairs, the whole dance floor is seething in the dark. Sex and conversation. “Go on,” says Nell. “Pick someone up.”

The irony of this success story is that, despite their effortless conquest of New York, the two brothers still see their own home town as beyond their reach – because the snobbery there is too strong for even them to handle. “In London,” said Keith, “when I lived there, I could barely get into a restaurant as a diner, never mind start one.” Brian agreed:”In London, you just get the impression there are innumerable barriers. It’s not that someone has to deter you. You don’t even start. You know it’s not for you, especially if you’re from Bethnal Green.”