Michael Dukakis – portrait of a perfect American

The Scotsman and The New Zealand Dominion, 1 April 1988

There are two revealing anecdotes about Michael Dukakis currently working their way along the Washington grapevine. One goes back to the early 1950s when the young Dukakis was a law student at Swarthmore College outside Philadelphia. He found out that the campus barber was refusing to serve any of the few black students at the college, so he took a chair, placed it in the main square of the campus and set himself up as an alternative barber, attracting long queues of students who were prepared to risk their scalps to support his boycott.

This is Dukakis the liberal, the classic northern Democrat, who stands up for the poor and oppressed. This is the Dukakis who wants to take on the mantle of the Kennedys and who, as a schoolboy, wrote admiring letters to the young Senator Jack Kennedy telling him: “I feel it is about time I dropped you a note on a couple of issues now pending in the Senate.”

The other anecdote is about Dukakis’ first term as Governor of Massachusetts in 1974 when he tried to force unpopular measures through the state assembly, many of them contradicting his campaign promises. Dukakis so enraged the local legislators that he became a hate figure for them. They set out to obstruct and irritate him at every turn and were even driven to exploit his obsessive dislike of tobacco smoke. Every time they met the governor, they filled his room with smoke. “We’d all light up cigars,” according to the then assembly leader, William Bulger. “Even guys who never smoked would light up.”

This is the ugly side of Dukakis – unpopular, arrogant and unbending, rigidly enforcing his will on those around him. It is the side which dominated that first term as governor and saw him heaved out of the governor’s mansion in 1978 by an angry electorate which left him in the cold for four years before giving him a second chance.

Now, as the front runner for the Democratic Presidential nomination, Dukakis, who is aged 54, faces the greatest test of his personality. In political shorthand, he has to show that he is a winner by building the stature and popularity of a Kennedy while shedding the petty arrogance of his past.

He has a great asset in his family background which is a classic of the American dream. His father, Panos, arrived in the United States in 1912 as a penniless Greek immigrant speaking hardly a word of English. He worked in the textile mills of New Hampshire, saving every spare cent, studying every evening at night school until only six years later he won a place at Boston University. A further six years later, he became the first Greek ever to graduate from Harvard Medical School and went on to become a successful family doctor in the comfortable suburbs of Boston. Dukakis’ mother, Euterpe, followed a strikingly similar path, arriving from Greece in 1913 with her family and later becoming the first Greek girl to graduate from her college in Maine.

Dukakis now tells his parents’ story at every opportunity to stress his respect for American immigrant values – enterprise, hard work, independence. But his friends say that the real importance of his background lies in his character: his parents who had struggled to succeed were determined that their children would grow up to be as honest and hard-working as they were. The Dukakis household was a strict and moral one.

For Michael’s older brother, Stelian, the recipe was too much. During his first year at college, in 1954, he suffered a nervous breakdown, attempted suicide and was confined to a mental hospital. Although he was soon released, he never recovered his independence or his drive. In 1973, he was knocked off his bicycle by a car and died from his injuries. Stelian’s collapse had a traumatic effect on the Dukakis family. Michael’s girlfriend at the time, Sandy Bakalar, remembers him bursting into floods of tears as he told her about it, although he now says he barely remembers it.

Michael, however, appears to have flourished on the strict regime. As a child, he was top of his class, always clean and neat, never in trouble, rather shy with girls, but basically perfect. His high school year book referred to him as Big Chief Brain in the Face. As an adult, he is the same – disciplined, self-contained, occasionally cold, but always supremely efficient.

He sleeps each night from midnight until 5.30. He regularly runs cross country. He does not drink – he refused to even pose with a glass of beer for a photograph with union leaders. He has no time for films – not even the new Cher film, Moonstruck, in which his first cousin, Olympia Dukakis, has a major role. He does not waste his energy on novels – he once went on holiday with a book called Swedish Land-Use Planning. His only relaxation is growing vegetables but, predictably, his garden is famous for being perfectly free of weeds and beautifully laid out in symmetrical straight lines.

This kind of discipline is the best fuel for a Presidential campaign. His school friend and political colleague, Beryl Cohen, says: “He will kill them with hard work. You have to remember, cross country is his sport. He has learned to run and run and run until it’s over. Michael will not break stride. He will hit every mark.”

That is how it has been in his career so far. All through school and college, he was politically active. After he had graduated from Harvard Law School in 1960, he went into Democratic politics in Boston. Two years later, he was elected to the state assembly, to which he was re-elected regularly throughout the 60s. In 1970, he lost an election for the post of Lieutenant Governor of Massachusetts, but that did not stop him. In 1974, he ran for Governor and won. After his rejection by the voters in 1978, he came back to win in 1982 and again in 1986, this time by a landslide.

In his campaign for the presidency, he has been typically controlled and competent. There was one skeleton in his family cupboard: his wife Kitty had been addicted to diet pills for years and had secretly gone to a drug clinic to be cured. Instead of waiting anxiously for the press to drag it out, Dukakis and his wife held a press conference at which they made a clean breast of their secret and neutralised any potential damage.

When Gary Hart fell by the way, Dukakis picked up most of his staff and his supporters. When Joe Biden withdrew from the race after being caught stealing Neil Kinnock’s speeches, Dukakis picked up his staff and supporters as well. There was a nasty moment when it was discovered that Dukakis’ campaign manager had been responsible for the video of Biden and Kinnock which had brought the issue to a head, particularly nasty since Dukakis had been accusing other candidates of producing it. Dukakis sacked the campaign manager and proceeded on course.

His campaign has been underpinned by a dazzlingly efficient network of fund-raising, which enabled him to penetrate the potentially hostile south on Super Tuesday. Now, he can look forward to an endorsement from Mario Cuomo, the governor of New York, who has superstar status among Democrats. But he is still vulnerable.

He presents himself as the technocrat, the great manager, and cites the economic recovery of Massachusetts under his leadership as an example of what he can do for the country. Many economists, however, say that Massachusetts’ performance has nothing to do with its governor and is largely based on President Reagan’s huge defence spending which has spilled into the state’s high-tech industries. As a front-runner, his claims will come under new and intense scrutiny. His record of raising taxes in the states may become a political albatross and, in that context, he may be embarrassed to be reminded that all those years ago, when he boycotted the college barber, he charged his fellow-students 65 cents a head to join his protest.