Southern politics is up for grabs on Super Tuesday

The Scotsman and The New Zealand Dominion, 7 March 1988

Super Tuesday is a mess. Politics in the South have always been a mess, but this is a particularly fine one. It is also wonderful to watch, and Super Wednesday promises to bring us the rewarding sight of smooth-suited politicians wiping egg off their faces.

Superficially, what has happened is that a bunch of right-wing southern Democrats have got together to throw the political party of the year, but the servants have run off with all the food and drink and now the Republicans have swept through and taken all the guests off down the road to their place, where they have rapidly forgotten their manners and started brawling and throwing bottles at each other.

What is really happening is that the whole raft of old and increasingly unstable political assumptions on which both parties have been floating through the South since the civil war, is finally sinking. The reason for that is that the South has been hit by a tidal wave of economic problems, particularly the slump in oil prices. The result is that everyone on the raft – political chieftains, activists and voters – is scrambling for safety, stepping on each other’s heads, some of them hanging on to the old wreck, some of them seeing it is all over and striking out for new ground.

Who profits from all this? All predictions about US elections should carry health warnings. So, it’s only a theory and it could be wrong etc, but… there are signs that Jesse Jackson is going to break out of his black political base and shock the daylights out of the old white Democrats while, on the Republican side, Pat Robertson is well placed to knock the wind out of George Bush. I have to admit that the polls and the pundits do not support any of this, but so far, they have been wrong at every turn. This is how the theory works.

First, you have to spot the common thread that links some of the key Republican players in the sunbelt states – Ronald Reagan, Pat Robertson, Elizabeth Dole, and the most powerful power-broker in the area, Strom Thurmond, as well as numerous governors and state assemblymen. They are all Republicans who started their political lives with the Democrats. And they are only the high-profile examples of a long drawn out political spasm which has seen southern conservatives steadily abandon their traditional home in the Democratic party.

All across the south, membership of the Democratic party has slumped. In the last year, they have lost 239,669 in Florida, 31,415 in Lousiana. In Mississipi, only 35% of those who voted Democrat in the 1986 state elections are registered with the party for the Presidential election. This is only natural.

Ever since the civil war, both parties have been standing on their heads in the south. The liberal pro-labour Democrats have been virulently reactionary in the region, while the naturally right-wing Republicans have been cultivating poor blacks. The confusion is entirely hereditary, passed down from the 1860s when the Republican Abe Lincoln alienated generations of white southerners from his party by killing their confederacy and freeing their slaves.

Slowly since the 1940s, that has been changing. Politically, northern Democrats have been squeezing out the southern conservatives by pushing the civil rights issue. Socially, race has ceased to be the definitive issue, allowing white southerners to bury their differences with the old enemy in the Republican party. For conservatives, the new social issues are abortion, religion in school, drugs and pornography, all areas where they are attracted to the Republicans. In 1980 and 1984, Ronald Reagan soaked up former Democrats by playing on these issues, although he failed to complete the shift.

This powerful change is all very well, unless you happen to be a leader of the Democratic party, watching in alarm as your power base erodes. It was just such a group of worried Democrats who sat down together after the 1984 election – when Democrats won only 38% of the vote in the south – to try and save the future. They came up with Super Tuesday.

Their analysis, which now looks very superficial, was that they lost in the South because they had the wrong candidate in Walter Mondale. They would have done better, they thought, with a more right-wing candidate like the former astronaut, Senator John Glenn, but he had been obliterated as a candidate in 1984 in the early primaries in liberal northern states. Solution: hold all the southern primaries on one day, as early as possible in the campaign, and select an old-fashioned conservative Democrat.

But look what has actually happened. The dwindling of the race issue and the erosion of the old political divisions in the south means that there is no natural southern candidate. A handful of early northern primaries still throws up liberal candidates like Mike Dukakis and Jesse Jackson. Result: the remaining southern white conservatives in the Democratic party take one look and abandon ship.

The people who are going to vote in Democratic primaries on Super Tuesday are a new constituency, thrown up not by the old race issue but by the new issue of poverty. They are the whole southern underclass, the faceless thousands who inhabit the sweating ghettos of the cities and the tiny wooden shacks and battered mobile homes which litter the backwoods and hills. When the price of a barrel of oil slid from $40 to only $10 in 1986, it was these people who lost their jobs. When the local banks crashed, these people lost their homes. The failure of the fishing industry in the Carolinas, the decline in manufacturing across the region, the growth of a new service economy which pays rock bottom wages – these are the people who live with the results.

Many of them are black; almost as many are Hispanic. But the majority are white. For all of them, race is no longer the prime issue. As Jesse Jackson puts it: “Whenever they foreclose a farm or shut a factory, they pull the plug and the lights go out. And when the lights go out, all of us – black and white and brown – look uncommonly alike.”

The conventional wisdom about Jackson is that he cannot win white voters with the possible exception of a few well-meaning liberals. But Jackson has been picking up white voters all over the north in the early primaries: last week, in Vermont, one of the whitest states in the country, he came in second with 27% of the vote. These were not liberals who were supporting him; they all went for Dukakis. This was an underclass vote.

On Super Tuesday, for the first time in this campaign, Jackson will appeal to an underclass which has the built-in bonus of a substantial number of black voters. More than in any previous year, their votes will swamp the shrunken Democratic camp, and on Wednesday morning, the Conservative Democrats who planned this political orgy may wake up with terribly sore heads. Their only consolation may be that they will have caused equal havoc in the Republican camp, because these Democratic defectors are lining up behind the upstart Pat Robertson.

For the Republican establishment, Robertson is a pain in the neck. He evidently telephoned George Bush last year to tell him that he was planning to run and was told in no uncertain terms that he was not welcome. When he runs well – as he did in Iowa – it is Bush who loses. The reason is that Bush is trying to revive the constituency which carried Reagan to power in the last two elections, but part of that constituency is fixated by the new moral issues – sex, drugs etc – where Bush is frankly too discriminating to play Reagan’s hand.

However, for Pat Robertson, the TV evangelist, it is home turf and he is set to poach the religious voters who supported Reagan in 1980 and 1984. And more important, he is likely to pick up the new block of defecting Democrats who share the moral fixation. They are super-conservatives – born-again Republicans – who have clung to the old Democratic fortress to the last. To them, George Bush smells of the northern establishment, whereas Robertson is a southerner who speaks their language. Robertson knows this and at the last count, he had spent $3.1 million in Super Tuesday states – about as much as Bush and Dole put together.

The pressure is beginning to show. Robertson’s camp reports that merry pranksters from the Bush campaign have been ringing up hotels to cancel their reservations, attacking their phone lines with a hacksaw and vandalising their vehicles. Dole’s people report similar incidents. Bush throws his hands up and disclaims all knowledge. All of them are now pitching into negative advertising, sniping at each other’s records.

This theory does not go as far as saying that either Jackson or Robertson is going to win their party’s nomination. Robertson is not even going to come close. But what he can possibly do is to win enough delegates to lock out George Bush at the Republican Convention in August and hand the prize to Bush’s leading opponent, Bob Dole, who has already forged an unofficial alliance with the evangelist. Jackson’s surge, if it happens, will ultimately help Dukakis who is best placed to take Jackson’s supporters on board. Still, as I said, it is only a theory.

UPDATE: The theory turned out to be only 50% correct. Jesse Jackson won five of the ten southern states on Super Tuesday.