The Bland leading the Blind

The Scotsman and The New Zealand Dominion, 8 February 1988

Times are hard for Willa Kenoyer. She is running for President in the United States: she has no national organisation, a campaign budget of only $20,000 compared to George Bush’s $19 million, one beaten-up old Chevy to transport her to the hustings, and maybe, just maybe, if she is lucky, a chance of winning a grand total of 50,000 votes out of an electorate of 170 million.

Her political future is one of the few certainties in this year’s American elections. Today’s caucus in Iowa is only a foretaste of the confusion to come: front-runners may fall; dark horses may come racing up on the outside; runners and riders may be disqualified for cheating. But there is one safe bet: whoever it is who finally makes it to the White House, it won’t be Willa. And this is very strange.

For Willa Kenoyer is not one of those ravers in a raincoat who haunt the fringes of elections. She is the official candidate of the Socialist Party of the USA, the American representative of one of the most powerful political movements in Western democracies – not the bright red revolutionary brand of socialism with which respectable mothers frighten their children, but the mild-mannered, mainstream, reformist socialism which is part of the common currency of political debate all over the developed world.

“We get a very warm reception when we manage to talk to people,” she told me. “I am a white middle-class, middle-aged lady and they can’t believe that I am a real socialist. But we have no chance of winning. If we are very lucky, we could be looking at 50,000 votes.” Her party’s total isolation here is a clue to some of the central mysteries of American politics and a hint, too, of some this country’s more worrying ways.

The deep background to her problem is that Americans have never liked the sound of socialism – now less than ever. When the American Council on Education conducted its annual survey of students last month, they found that 71% of them rated ‘being financially very well off’ as a top priority in life – double the figure in 1970 – and only 40% of them thought it was important to develop a philosophy of life – half the figure from 20 years ago. But beyond this deep cultural aversion to anything other than mere materialism, there are other problems buried in the process of US elections.

Consider this little gem of a revelation: Richard Gephardt, one of the Democratic dwarves who has been slaving hardest in Iowa, discovered early in the campaign that his skin is so fair and his eyebrows are so blond that under the bright lights of a television studio, his facial features more or less disappear. He has, therefore, taken to using women’s make-up to paint his features in place. Perfect. As a symbol of the American electoral process, it could not be more perfect – the faceless man who creates an artificial image of himself to suit the media.

The candidates have all been struggling to develop Lowest Common Denominator philosophies with personalities to match, obliterating any sign of individuality. Bob Dole happens to be a lot less charming than a puff adder, so he pretends to be Mr Nice Guy. George Bush is rather soft, so he has started pretending to be Marlon Brando in On The Waterfront. The preacher Pat Robertson has stopped talking about God. Former NATO supreme commander Al Haig has hidden his helmet. Only Paul Simon has busted loose in a wild and crazy gesture which has earned him national notoriety – he wears a bow tie.

The dominant theme in the election so far has been the lack of a dominant theme. All the candidates agree that budgets should be balanced and arms should be controlled and they’ll make America great again. Pat Robertson’s plans for his cabinet are a classic of contemporary American politics:”I promise in the Cabinet I’m going to have an Asiatic, a black – at least one or two – a Hispanic, a woman, every segment of the population.” Just in case that was going too far, Robertson went on in the same speech to cover himself by criticising other candidates for “worrying about whether they’ve satisfied all the special interests out there”.

The problem has a lot to do with the selection process itself. Nobody ever sat down and designed this sprawling labyrinth of primaries and caucuses; it has all just grown like topsy with candidates declaring ever earlier in search of greater name recognition, and state parties competing for prominence by holding their selection procedures earlier and earlier in the political calendar. This time the campaign is longer than ever – with unfortunate results.

First, active and able politicians are deterred from joining the campaign because it will mean deserting their post for the best part of a year, and so the inactive and less able fill the vacuum. Second, for those who join the race, the whole affair becomes an endurance test and the only politics which matter are the politics of survival – try not to irritate anyone, say nothing controversial, keep your head down. Hence the bland and faceless candidates.

American television makes it worse. In the absence of national newspapers, the candidates’ only way to reach the American population is to catch the eye of the evening news bulletins. That means nice pictures, snappy one-liners, and for heaven’s sake keep it simple. So the bland candidates deal in superficial ideas. A case of the bland leading the blind. Which brings us back to Willa Kenoyer.

Her platform is, to an outsider’s eyes, uncontroversial: a national health system, improvements in minimum wage levels, selective nationalisation, protection of the environment, unilateral initiatives towards nuclear disarmament. It is the package of ideas which has been moving in and out of power in Europe and Australasia for most of this century but it is all off-limits to the American electorate.

The ideas may be plain wrong. The package may be utterly repugnant to American voters. We will never know because no US Presidential candidate can afford to run the risk of offering such specific ideas or of stepping so far out of line from his competitors. American elections simply will not accommodate that kind of behaviour.

And if the big party candidates do not try out new ideas, Willa Kenoyer is not going to get the chance to do so herself. To spread their message, the thirteen candidates from the two big parties have so far raised a total of $86.9 million – an average of $6.7 million each. “I will be lucky to raise $20,000,” said Willa.  “Ethically, I can’t go to the major corporations like other candidates do.” There is also a whiff of conspiracy here.

In the 1932 election, the socialist candidate, Norman Thomas, broke all records by winning nearly 900,000 votes. Since then, most states have changed the rules to make it difficult for an outsider not just to be elected but even to be registered as a candidate. In the shadow of Norman Thomas’ success, they declared that no candidate’s name can appear on a ballot paper unless it is supported by a petition signed by a sizeable number of local voters – 170,000 in Florida, for example. Gathering those signatures is a laborious and expensive business, well beyond the reach of most outsiders. Even the main parties find it difficult – two Republican candidates are in trouble in Texas for submitting petitions with forged signatures on them.

Other would-be candidates who are not supported by wealthy organisations are effectively disbarred from the election simply because they cannot afford to get their names on to the ballot papers. The socialists and other third parties believe that the rule has been introduced deliberately by the big parties to keep the political stage to themselves. It may or may not have been a conspiracy, but the effect is clear: political stagnation and hard times for Willa Kenoyer.