The spies who are allowed to tell their tales

The Scotsman, 1 January 1988

It was the kind of event which the British Government encounters only in its nightmares  – not one or two but fifteen former intelligence officers, possessing collectively many of the nation’s most sensitive secrets, gathered together with one express intent, to talk to the press about their work. And, even worse, getting away with it.

They talked about coups they had engineered, murders they had ordered, about rigged elections and arms deals and burglaries and propaganda. Then they attacked the Government of the day and their former masters in the intelligence community and demanded changes in policy. The next day, the newspapers quoted them word for word.

The difference between these retired spies and Peter Wright or Anthony Cavendish is simply their nationality. This press conference was held just before Christmas in Washington DC, where it caused not even a ripple on the political pond, because it is accepted here as an uncontroversial fact of life  that former intelligence officers are allowed to speak and to write about their work.

It is, at one level, a matter of law. The First Amendment to the Constitution demands that “Congress shall make no law abridging the freedom of speech or of the press” and it leaves no loophole through which a fearful Government could push its spies out of the public eye. But, more important, it is now accepted at the highest level in the CIA that, while it may sometimes be painful, in the long term this openness actually helps the intelligence community.

The former spies at the press conference all had a track record of writing and talking about their careers: John Stockwell, who ran a secret CIA war in Angola in 1975, is now writing his eighth book and is about to deliver his 500th lecture; former agent Mary Fleischer is writing a film about her adventures and about her marriage to a senior CIA man; Ralph McGehee who spent 25 years with the CIA in Asia and Vietnam is writing his second book and compiling a computerised data base of information about US intelligence; Colonel Phil Roettinger, who deposed the President of Guatemala in 1954, has given numerous interviews and has been working in South America trying to expose death squads operating with the support of his former colleagues.

They acknowledge that some things must remain secret and all of them are bound by the Secrecy Agreement which every US intelligence officer signs. The effect of the agreement is that they have to submit their manuscripts to the CIA before publication; the CIA can delete passages to which it objects, but it does so in the knowledge that its decisions may be challenged in court where it will meet the full force of the First Amendment.

The production of US intelligence memoirs is now such a mature industry that a serving CIA officer has opened a book shop in Washington, the National Intelligence Book Centre, to sell them. The shop’s catalogue runs to 114 pages. The former officers are mystified by the British objection to this kind of openness and aghast at last week’s court action against The Scotsman and other newspapers, which has been reported in the American press.

Ralph McGehee, who last year published his autobiography, Deadly Deceits – My 25 Years in the CIA, said: “I think it is horrendous. It is a violation of human rights not just in Scotland but also in the rest of Britain. It is the Government using secrecy to cover up embarrassment and illegal operations. I really find it very difficult to think of any justification for it.”

Memoirs are only one part of the high public profile of American intelligence, which produces sights which are bizarre to the British eye.

Americans who want to speak to the head of the CIA, William Webster, can call him on his direct line – Washington 482 6363, which actually rings in his office. The number is no secret; it is published and freely available in sundry Government guides. If they obtain no satisfaction from him, they could try one of his predecessors, William Colby, whose number and home address are listed in the Washington phone book. Or if they had 17 dollars to spare, they could go along to the nightschool class in Covert Operations which is taught by David Atlee Phillips, a CIA veteran with 25 years service.

Whereas the identities of British intelligence personnel are closely guarded secrets, the movements of their American counterparts are reported in the press because the CIA issues press releases about the hiring and firing of senior officers. Not even the CIA’s intelligence material is necessarily considered secret. The agency’s marketing division sells biographies of political leaders, intelligence reports on every country in the world, economic statistics on communist countries, wall maps on every subject from British railway lines to the Chinese clothing industry, and booklets about itself and its approach to espionage.

All this has a political edge. Giving their press conference, the 15 former officers were deliberately setting out to influence policy. Their central point was that the CIA was performing badly in its prime task of gathering intelligence because it was diverting resources into covert operations like the secret funding of the Contras. They have formed themselves into a pressure group, The Association for Responsible Dissent, to campaing for an end to all such covert operations.

They are not alone in trying to stimulate debate about the direction of US intelligence. The Washington Post recently carried a long analysis of the CIA’s relationship with the White House. The article attacked politicians for twisting CIA reports to suit their own purpose, disclosed the detail of furious internal rows in the agency, and revealed serious weaknesses in CIA coverage of vital targets including the Russian Politburo. A note at the bottom of the page explained that the author, Robert Gates, was not another investigative reporter from the Washington Post but is the current deputy director of the CIA.