Control Risks: the privatised wing of British security

The London Daily News, 16 June 1987

It was in a prison cell in Bogota in 1977 that the limelight first caught up with Control Risks. Until then the company had succeeded in setting itself up as a new power in the security world with the maximum of discretion.

But a job in the Colombian capital went badly wrong. An American businessman had been kidnapped; two men from Control Risks flew to Bogota to advise his employers on how to handle the problem; after eight months a ransom was paid and the businessman was released. The celebrations were then rudely interrupted by a local judge who ordered that the two men from Control Risks be arrested and thrown into prison.

It was a double blow for the company: apart from exposing its existence to the world’s press, the Bogota judge had raised the issue that has dogged the company ever since – whether you can negotiate the release of hostages and supervise the payment of ransom without ultimately encouraging the criminals involved to repeat the exercise.

The Bogota judge was persuaded to back down, but the issue is still there. In the last two years, the company has drawn a stinging attack from the Irish government over its role after the kidnap of Jennifer Guinness, and a call in the House of Commons for its prosecution over the case of kidnap victim Don Tidey – a call which was rebuffed by the Attorney General, Sir Michael Havers, who said there was no evidence that the company had broken any law.

Don Tidey’s employers agreed to pay the IRA £2 million to stop any more of their executives being kidnapped; Control Risks advised against making the payment but was nevertheless criticised for failing to warn the Irish authorities.

Now the suggestion that the Commissioner of the Metropolitan Police, Sir Kenneth Newman, may join Control Risks when he retires in July has rekindled the controversy. Although Scotland Yard says the suggestion is ‘speculative’, Labour MP Dale Campbell-Savours has tabled questions in Parliament about whether it is in the public interest for Control Risks to hire such people.

Sir Kenneth Newman is neither the first nor the foremost member of the security establishment to retire and pick up a contract with Control Risks. Its staff list over the years reads like a Who’s Who of the ‘Secret State’.

From the Metropolitan Police it already has one of Sir Kenneth’s predecessors, Sir Robert Mark; and the former head of the Anti-Terrorist Branch, Roy Habershon, both of whom hold shares in Control Risks’ parent company, Diversified Management Services.

There are powerful mandarins like Sir Clive Rose, formerly of the Cabinet Office and NATO; and senior diplomats including Lord Soames, the last Governor of Rhodesia and a former leader of the House of Lords. It has also recruited some of the most influential figures from the military and intelligence fields.

Its board of directors currently boasts General Sir Frank King, who ran the British military operation in Northern Ireland 1973-1975; Field Marshall Sir John Stanier, who was Commander in Chief of UK Land Forces 1981-1982; and Dr Richard Clutterbuck, former head of the Royal College of Defence Studies.

Its Washington office is run by Colonel Peter Goss, who used to be head of military intelligence in Northern Ireland before working as security adviser to the Cabinet. His predecessor in Northern Ireland, Roger Meares, works in the London office.

There are half a dozen SAS officers, like Major David Walker. He was managing director of Control Risks for three years before leaving in 1977 to set up KMS, the security company involved in Washington’s Irangate affair.

The paradox is that while the company boasts this extraordinary line-up of prestigious names, it is run by a man who still clings to anonymity. He is Major Arish Turle, holder of the Military Cross, formerly of the Greenjackets and a squadron leader in the SAS. He has been with the company since 1976 and was one of the two Control Risks men who was gaoled in Bogota.

The company he joined was the creation of a group of insurance brokers in the City who joined forces in 1973 to deal with the wave of Palestinian and Irish terrorism which was them sweeping Europe. Clients were asking to be insured against the new risks, particularly of kidnap, and the brokers were worried that they were out of their depth.

The company’s original aim was to hire a small team of security experts who would act as specialist loss adjusters, arriving after a kidnap to ensure that claims for insurance pay-outs were genuine. But it soon realised that it could be most effective if it had people on hand as the kidnap unfolded. That put the company on an ethical tightrope, balancing between the interests of its client and the law.

Those close to the company say it has pulled off the balancing trick. “It is easy to complain that it encourages kidnappers,” says one security expert. “In fact, there is no evidence that it does. The real issue is whether you advise someone to pay or whether you allow people to be killed. The decision is never whether or not to pay, but how much and when.”

Turle has seen the company expand from handling a mere £100,000 of business in 1977 to its position today when it receives an annual retainer, estimated to be more than £2 million, from LIoyd’s insurance simply for being on hand, and then charges £1,000 per man per day for handling a kidnap.

It is Turle who has hired the big names – a policy which has annoyed some of his colleagues. “He is extremely able and highly intelligent,” according to one, “but he has this unfortunate weakness for people with big reputations. It is a ridiculously inefficient way to run a company. He hires these people who have already climbed all their mountains and got pot bellies on them and pays some a great deal of money, while the people who are doing the real work get nothing like the same reward.”

Despite the attacks, the company still has the blessing of the British security establishment, for whom it represents the privatisation of a service which they can barely afford to provide themselves.