Police cheat the public to fix their figures: the evidence

The Observer, 13 July 1986

The detective inspector was beside himself with rage. He had just been passed the latest official figures showing the clear-up rates for each of the police stations in Kent. “They’re crooked,” he barked. “They’re ridiculous. Anybody can see they’re crooked.”

Then he turned to the junior detectives in the CID room. “And there’ll be none of that here,” he told them. “There’ll be no dodgy write-offs here. No way.” The new detective constable, Ron Walker, watching the scene seven years ago, was impressed.

But the dodgy write-offs did not stop. As Walker moved from one station to another in the Kent police, in and out of the CID, he kept stumbling across the same dishonest fiddle – scores of unsolved crimes being written off in fraudulent confessions.

The idea of write-offs had been promoted in the mid-1970s as a legitimate way of clearing up crime. The Home Office encouraged police to visit criminals in prison to take statements. The Attorney-General General agreed that such criminals would not be prosecuted for their confessions if it served no useful purpose. But there were no safeguards, no need to check that the statements were true.

For detectives, under pressure for results, and for the criminals, looking for a risk-free way of earning favours from the police, the system was wide open to abuse. In Kent’s police stations, Walker found detectives quite unashamed of their activities.

“On one occasion, I was in the office with another detective constable – a very experienced man who I had always thought was an excellent policeman. He was on the phone to someone in the statistics office at the force HQ. He was making a list of unsolved burglaries, checking that they were still outstanding. I wandered over to his desk and it was covered in blank statement forms. When he came off the phone, he just sat there and started writing out this statement – a completely phony confession writing off all these burglaries.

“There was another occasion when one of the senior detectives came into the office waving this little bundle of write-offs, laughing about it and complaining that he had had so many crimes written off that he could clear up every offence in his patch for the rest of the year. He was saying he would have to feed them into the system slowly over the months so that the figures didn’t go over the top.

“It was a bad joke the way things were being run There was this change of direction coming about: junior officers just wanted promotion; the senior officers just wanted good clear-up rates; helping the public became less and less important.”

Walker’s disaffection spilled over into open conflict when a cynical senior officer torpedoed a major inquiry he had been running. By cultivating an informer and mounting a round-the-clock surveillance, Walker had identified two particularly active local burglars. He was poised to arrest them red-handed when the senior officer intervened. He was worried that if they were arrested and charged, the two burglars would refuse to admit all the offences they had committed, which would make the crime figures look bad. He proposed instead to have a quiet word with them, to tell them that if they left his patch and committed crime elsewhere, he would not give them any trouble. “I exploded,” said Walker, “but I never got to arrest the two burglars.”

About this time, Walker also stumbled on another abuse – ‘phantom crimes’, which were being invented by detectives and then admitted by willing criminals without fear of punishment, so that the crime figures were artificially improved.

“A detective had nicked this gullible young lad who was prepared to play ball with him. I saw him get on to a PC from this lad’s area and tell him to go out and get some vehicle numbers, so that he could get the names and addresses off the computer and put them down as stolen cars. The next thing you know, the lad is confessing to stealing them.”

The abuses split Kent’s detectives. “Some of them were right into this, visiting prisons and turning out write-offs like a machine. There were some who turned a blind eye and just hid. And some of us wanted to fight it, but we didn’t know how.”

Seething with indignation, Walker decided to leave the CID and return to uniform. Then he was breathalysed and charged with driving over the limit. When a senior officer told him not to worry, that his CID job was still open to him, Walker told him he had had enough of the corruption. Back in uniform, Walker made his decision and secretly set out to turn his detective skills on his former colleagues. He became a one-man anti-corruption squad.

He gathered statistics for every sub-division in Kent. They told their own story : in 1978, before the abuses took off, a typical Kent division was solving 24.4 per cent of its burglaries. A year later, the figure had shot up to 69.5 per cent, an astonishing leap.

Clear-up rates differed wildly across the county: while some stations were clearing up less than 10 per cent, others were scoring over 90 per cent. Yet this was happening without any apparent questions or criticisms from leaders of the force. Unknown to Walker, however, alarm bells had also begun to ring in the Home Office. The Inspector of Constabulary began to monitor the use of write-offs; a Home Office research paper noted tactfully that with the sudden expansion of the write-off system “there could be said to be weight behind the criticism that justice is not seen to be done.”

But it was Walker who followed through and gathered hard evidence. Checking through the station officer’s log, he noted two particular offenders whose names had been entered unusually often for having cleared-up crimes. From central records, he obtained a list of all the offences recently cleared by the two men and then began a minute examination.

One of them, Robert H, had written-off 87 offences, including 73 burglaries, when he was visited in Borstal by two Kent detectives. It was an eloquent confession, the sort detectives love to hear, full and frank with just enough detail of each offence to show first-hand knowledge.

He began by explaining himself. “When I was arrested, I admitted a lot of offences to the police. However, I only admitted a few of the offences I had actually committed.” He then apologised that he was unable to name anybody who had helped him commit the offences, nor the people to whom he had sold the stolen goods. Nor could he return any of the goods because he had not kept anything. Then he reeled off the offences.

“About the beginning of October,” he recalled at one point, “I did a place in Letchworth Avenue. I climbed on to the porch and got in through an upstairs window that was open. I had a look around and took some jewellery. The same day as that one, I did one in Robin Hood Lane. I got in through a skylight in the conservatory and forced a window in the back. I had a look round and took some jewellery and some money. A few days later, I did a place in Marston Walk…” And so on.

It was pure baloney. The details of the break-ins were correct, just as they had been recorded when the victims had reported the crimes. But Robert H had not committed them, for Walker discovered that “about the beginning of October,” when a burglar climbed on that porch in Letchworth Avenue, Robert H had been locked up inside Canterbury Prison.

The detectives had slipped up because Robert H’s record sheet was not up to date. Robert H had been in prison from 10 September to 8 October — a discovery that wiped out nine of the offences which he claimed to have committed. But there was more.

Digging deeper into Robert H’s background, Walker established that he had spent two periods under close supervision in a day centre run by the probation service. Walker called the man who runs the centre and took a detailed record of the days and times when it could be proved that Robert H was there. Then he checked back through the confession: seven of his admissions were undoubtedly false, and a further 18 were highly suspect.

But the falseness of the confession was not the most important point. “The question that had to be answered was that if this man had not been at the scenes of these burglaries, how could he know in such detail what had happened there? It must have been fed to him.”

Walker then began investigating the second write-off, in which Ernie C, a veteran with 24 years of criminal activity, admitted committing 54 burglaries in a six-month period. It was another long, detailed confession and its very length gave Walker an idea. He phoned the prison where Ernie C had been visited by two Kent detectives and asked how long they had been in the prison. The times had been logged at the prison gate: they had arrived at 3.20 p.m. and left at half-past-four. Just one hour 10 minutes in the prison.

Walker calculated that it would have taken them at least 10 minutes to get from the main gate to Ernie C and back. Which left one hour. It would take a full hour to write out a statement as long as his, yet the Kent detectives claimed that inside one hour they had persuaded him to confess, got him to recall crimes committed two years previously, elicited the detail and then written it all down.

And, once again, they had slipped up because of a fault in the records. Combing back through the records, Walker found that Ernie C had confessed to a burglary which had also been admitted by someone else. He probed further. He established that a Kent man had reported a burglary in which thieves had stolen money from his electricity meter. Ernie C was now admitting this break-in. Meanwhile, the Kent man had admitted that he stole the money from the meter himself and had invented the story of the break-in to cover himself. But the station records had not been straightened out.

There was one further slip-up. The detectives had been sloppy in checking Ernie C’s record and had allowed him to confess to a burglary which, Walker established, had been committed when he had already been in police custody for an hour.

As an exercise, Walker then took the two write-offs he had proved were fraudulent, and examined the effect they had on the clear-up rate for the police sub-division which recorded them. The sub-division had declared a clear-up rate of 49.3 per cent for the period when the write-offs were produced: 375 burglaries committed and 185 ‘detected.’ Subtracting the 127 burglaries written off fraudulently, the number of detected offences dropped to 58, and the clear-up rate fell to only 15.5 per cent. And Walker knew there was at least one other suspect write-off for the same station in the same period.

“It meant the detectives could afford to spend plenty of time taking it easy. In just a couple of days work they could get enough crimes written off to keep the crime figures looking right for the next six months.” Walker continued to look for evidence of abuse and had no trouble finding it. Late last summer, one of the area’s most active juvenile criminals – “a one,man crime wave” – was arrested for burglary. To Walker’s amazement, he was given bail without any objection from the arresting officer.

It then transpired that, after his arrest, the criminal had agreed to plead guilty and ask for some 30 other offences to be taken into consideration. A few weeks later, he was arrested again, having continued his one-man crime wave while on bail.

“They knew that if they didn’t oppose bail, he would go out and commit more offences, but they didn’t mind as long as he agreed to ask for a lot of offences to be taken into consideration. It didn’t matter that the people of Kent were burgled, as long as the books looked good.” About one-third of the offences to which he admitted could not have been committed by him.

Walker found evidence, too, of phantom crimes. Looking through a sheet of offences prepared for a suspect to ‘take into consideration’ he noticed half a dozen odd ones. All were for the theft of £5 rear fog lamps; none of them had a crime report number, which is normally given to each crime as soon as it is reported by its victim.

Either there had been an unusual series of administrative errors or these were phantoms. The names and addresses of the supposed victims were recorded on the sheet. Those contacted by The Observer last week confirmed Walker’s suspicions that they had never lost a rear fog lamp, let alone reported one stolen.

Having got his evidence, Walker’s problem was to decide what to do with it. “I was worried about it from the survival point of view. I didn’t see how I could use the evidence without putting paid to my career and jeopardising my family and their welfare.” After months of agonising, he decided to approach Scotland Yard on a confidential basis to ask them to investigate without disclosing his role. Things went badly from the start.

On 6 January this year, he phoned the Yard’s anti-corruption squad, CIB 2, and outlined his story. They told him that, to comply with the procedures. he would have to lodge the complaint with his own force. Nervous that this would disclose his role, he approached a Kent superintendent he trusted, who advised him that he would have to go through the formal channels whatever the risk.

It was two weeks before the inquiry was launched and he was interviewed by a superintendent from the Yard’s Serious Crimes Squad. Within four days, Walker’s wife was being cut dead by other police wives and Walker, who was by then on sick leave, was told that the force was buzzing with gossip about what he had done.

A week later – with his cover already blown – the whole inquiry was compromised by a leak, apparently from the Yard, to the Daily Mail, who ran a small story outlining the inquiry and effectively putting every detective in Kent on notice to cover his tracks. There was worse to come.

Walker had repeatedly stressed that the evidence he had presented amounted only to a few random examples of widespread and routine abuse. But the Director of Public Prosecutions asked the Yard superintendent to concentrate only on the incidents for which Walker had produced evidence: his allegations about systematic abuse in Kent and in other forces were put on one side.

The superintendent from the Yard then diligently set about investigating the two phony write-offs that Walker had described. He criss-crossed the country, a sergeant helping him with the paperwork, interviewing everyone involved. Two weeks ago, he submitted a 450-page report to the Director of Public Prosecutions and the Police Complaints Authority. The report confirms that the write-offs are phony.

His inquiry was severely hampered because key documents have gone missing. The original hand-written versions of the two write-offs have mysteriously vanished, making it impossible to assess whether they were really signed by the criminals involved and whether they even knew of their contents. Records of offences taken into consideration have been destroyed within the past month.

Kent detectives have tried to discredit Walker, claiming that he has a vendetta against one of them because he failed to prosecute two men who assaulted Walker in a night-club. They have suggested that if there are errors in the confessions, it reflects pressure of work or genuine mistakes.

The Director of Public Prosecutions may now decide that there is insufficient evidence to prosecute the officers. It may then be said that there is no other evidence to justify further inquiries into the allegations. The Police Complaints Authority is known to be deeply concerned about the case and keen to broaden its scope, but it does not have the resources to do so. Walker fears he has jeopardised his career and his family without achieving justice, which is why he has now taken the ultimate risk of speaking out in public.