Dying for a place in a secure hospital

The Observer, 29 June 1986

Anthony Corbett had been in mental hospitals since he was seven. He was severely mentally impaired and a mute. Then, last autumn, the young West Indian was accused of killing a female fellow patient. He was taken out of hospital and remanded to Brixton Prison.

As soon as he arrived, the prison doctors were worried about imprisoning someone with such severe mental problems. They feared that his condition would deteriorate and set about trying to find him a suitable hospital bed.

The doctors wrote to the Department of Health and applied for a place in one of the special hospitals, but were told that security there was inappropriate. They wrote again to the Department asking for a review of the decision and also wrote to the Regional Health Authority to ask them for a bed.

Weeks passed. The Department of Health refused to change its decision. The Regional Health Authority never responded at all. Mr Corbett’s condition was beginning to deteriorate rapidly. The doctors went to court and told magistrates that he was unfit to stand trial; the magistrates said they would consider the issue in three weeks time.

On 1 February, 14 weeks after he was first sent to Brixton Prison, Mr Corbett died of a seizure in his cell in the hospital wing. He was 25.

In theory, Mr Corbett should never have seen the inside of a prison cell. Magistrates have a new power to remand mentally ill suspects to hospital. Prison doctors have the power to transfer mentally ill prisoners to hospital.

In practice, Mr Corbett was one of the estimated 1,500 people who are mentally ill and are trapped in prison by the failure of magistrates to use their new power and, more important, by the failure of the Department of Health to provide enough places for them.

Now the Home Office has set up an emergency working group to try to force the Department of Health to meet its obligations. The Prisons Minister, Lord Glenarthur, has told the group, which is made up of officials from the Home Office and the Department of Health, to report to him by the autumn.

The Minister has asked the group to answer four questions: how many mentally ill people are in prison; how the present system is performing; how to keep the mentally ill out of prison in the future; how the mentally ill should be handled when they are released from prison.

The group’s findings are expected to contribute to the continuing controversy over the psychiatric wing of Holloway Prison, Cl, known as the Muppet House, which has been widely condemned for holding mentally ill women in conditions which aggravate their illnesses.