Murrell nephew says murder was ‘state crime’

The Observer, 30 March 1986

Murdered rose grower and anti-nuclear campaigner Hilda Murrell was the victim of a ‘state crime,’ according to her nephew, former Intelligence officer Rob Green.

Commander Green, who held a key intelligence post during the Falklands conflict, has just completed his own investigation into Miss Murrell’s unsolved killing two years ago.

He believes her death was linked to British Intelligence fears that hitherto-undisclosed details about the Belgrano might be about to leak out: further, that the government was worried it might be ‘losing the argument’ over the sinking of the Argentine cruiser.

Commander Green said yesterday: ‘I believe it was a state crime. I sense that Hilda, despite being a law-abiding citizen, became a casualty of an expansion of the activities of the State’s internal security apparatus.’

Miss Murrell, 78, was abducted from her Shrewsbury home in March 1984 and her body found three days later in a copse six miles away. She had died from hypothermia after being stabbed and sexually abused.

Police have always said she disturbed a burglar who kidnapped and killed her. Labour MP Tam Dalyell believes she was killed in a bungled operation by British Intelligence investigating leaks into the Belgrano affair. Others link her death to evidence which she was due to give to the inquiry into the Sizewell nuclear power station.

Commander Green rejects the police view. Although he is a man of moderate views, he sees the hand of ‘covert security organisations’ in her death. He believes they were given ‘freedom of action in the national interest’ in order to gain – and blunt – intelligence.

“Once mobilised, the temptation would have increased to deploy these forces for any task related to retaining political power. The Belgrano affair would have been seen by the government as coming into this category: the stakes were high and the State appeared to be in danger of losing the argument [about the sinking].”

Commander Green believes that British Intelligence, desperate to discover the source of leaks about the Belgrano to Mr Dalyell, investigated him because he had left the Navy and then his aunt in case she was storing secret documents for him.

He points out that she was abducted at the height of the Belgrano panic—two days after the then Defence Secretary Michael Heseltine commissioned Clive Ponting to write the ‘Crown Jewels’, the definitive account of the sinking of the Argentine cruiser. Commander Green points to evidence from two new witnesses:

* An anti-nuclear campaigner and neighbour of Miss Murrell, Laurens Otter, who says she called him hours before she was abducted and told him that a police inspector who gave what is believed to be a false name was about to arrive from London to ask her some questions.

*A Greenham woman who broke into the atomic weapons base at Aldermaston last year and who says she was interrogated by ‘a special man who had to be summoned from London.’ She says he told her: “I interviewed Hilda Murrell myself, and she was just a stupid old bat.”

Commander Green thinks the inspector may have tried to question his aunt about the Belgrano. She would have suspected he was really interested in her Sizewell evidence and would have accused him of coming from Special Branch or MI5. “I think from that moment Hilda was doomed.”

His theory is that the inspector feared Miss Murrell might tip off her nephew, so he drove her off to ask more questions and to get advice from his superiors.

Commander Green believes that she was stabbed and dumped the next day, and that the signs of sexual abuse are a deliberate false trail. He cites a local landowner who is adamant that the body was not in the copse 24 hours after the abduction; and witnesses who subsequently saw a man in a dark car walking to the copse and, later that night, lights moving in the area.