The day begins at eight. Down the long corridors, women with keys bang on blank wooden doors. Through eye-level slits, they inspect the waking women inside: some stay curled tight in their corners; others start to moan or howl. A rhythmic thumping begins – the sound of a woman punching her forehead against the wall. Welcome to the Muppet House.
It is nothing much to look at from the outside, just the ground floor of a neat red-brick block in a corner of Holloway Prison in North London, home for 42 women in 26 cells and four four-bed dormitories, officially titled C1, the psychiatric wing. It gets its unofficial title from the other prisoners, who refer to its inhabitants as Muppets.
The noise is the first clue to what is happening inside: from the first moans of the morning, it can sometimes go on all day in a miserable cacophony of foul abuse and pitiful wails and screams, occasionally broken by the crashing of someone destroying all the cardboard furniture in her cell.
The cells are heavy with mental torture, expressed in abundant graffiti: “Lord, I’m sorry. Lord, change me… She must have been silly/ To give too many drugs to the baby/ If she hadn’t done that/She’d still have a flat/Well, just fancy that… Dear God, if you are there, I hope you have Sandra there… I have asked God for forgiveness for what I have done… I hate this place.”
Some of the women who are locked up here are just simple minded. Meg is small with grey hair and gaps in her teeth. “I want to go back home,” she says. “We’ve got a big garden at home. And we’ve got a picture of a windmill.” She is charged with murder and could stay on C1 for a very long time.
Others are much more disturbed. Janet says the bed is going hot and cold and things are dropping from the ceiling. Cathy who has lived on the streets since her mother abandoned her, has just disowned her new-born baby. Sally spends the day head-banging, not happy till she has marked herself. Greta, glowering at the eye-slit in her door, threatens to attack anyone who is rude to staff.
Some are charged with the most minor offences – breaking a window, or leaving a restaurant without paying the bill. Others have killed their own children, or indulged in arson sprees.
All are to a greater or lesser degree racked by mental illness. Many of their cells are completely bare, just a bed bolted to the floor which is covered in old linoleum. For safety reasons, there are no radios or record players. Meals are pushed in through a slot in the door. The women can be locked up like this all day, day after day.
Trapped behind their doors, they turn in on themselves. Self-mutilation has become a part of life on the wing – ‘cutting up’, they call it. They break the lights or smash chips off the sink and saw away at themselves with the splinters. Some try to kill themselves. Last December, Ann Franklyn succeeded, hanging herself from her cardigan sleeve.
The Muppet House seems like a ghastly echo of the old Victorian asylum, a Bedlam for the 1980s. But it is different in one particularly important and frightening respect. Where the miseries of the old asylums were born out of ignorance and cruelty, C1 is the product of a system run by enlightened and sympathetic people who have the best will in the world to help the women locked inside it.
The people who run the regime condemn it. They share the view of the women that the place is a human dustbin, a pit at the bottom of a social waste pipe down which the women have slid, passing the hospitals and the courts and the whole complex of caring agencies along the way.
They agree that the regime on C1 is liable to make sick women sicker, but when they try to change it, they run into a swamp of structural defects in the building as well as chronic staff shortages. These, in turn, reflect deep-seated problems of industrial relations and finance which go far beyond Holloway Prison.
They agree, too, that most of the women on the wing should not be there at all, yet the women continue to be shovelled towards them by magistrates, politicians and hospital administrators who insist that they have no option and who are outside the prison’s control.
When the new Holloway Prison was first planned, it represented some of the most humane thinking on prison care in this country – the idea, born in the 1960s, that crime, particularly in women, should be seen, not as an evil which had to be punished, but as an illness which could be treated.
The new Holloway was originally planned as one big hospital rather than a prison – a caring environment where broken women could heal themselves. But during its construction in the 1970s, this medical model was destroyed by new research which cast doubt on its effectiveness and by a sudden surge in the number of women being jailed.
Now, almost all that remains of that heady Sixties dream is the Muppet House, which opened in 1977. The last vestiges of a medical regime still survive on the wing: it is staffed jointly by nurses and ordinary prison officers; a senior medical officer shares overall responsibiity with an assistant governor; two local psychiatrists visit daily. Yet no one here pretends that they are curing the women. Indeed, some admit that they are actually making them worse.
The matron in charge of the wing’s nurses, Esther Samson, who has worked here since 1978, says: “Being locked up behind a door exacerbates the situation. They have plenty of time to think, to cut up, or to try and commit suicide. I would like them to be in hospital or else for provision to be made so that they could be looked after here.”
As it is, staff can do little more medically than to provide sedatives and psychotropic drugs. For years, Holloway has topped the league table of prison drug consumption. Women who leave the wing say they suffer for months from the side effects of their daily ‘tots’.
The basic problem is that Holloway is now a prison, not a hospital. Esther Samson says: “Mental hospitals are licensed to treat, and we are not. They can give them injections and treatments at will, but we can’t give them treatment here, not unless they accept it, and most of them won’t. We have no power to treat.”
Working within that fundamental limit, the wing’s main objective, instead of treatment, is safe containment. But with women who are desperately ill and liable to damage themselves, that objective has daunting implications.
Almost every object becomes potentially lethal: the top of an old-fashioned radiator is for cracking your skull; the bed is to be dismantled for ammunition; the open window is a hook to improvise a gallows; clothes, blankets and floor coverings are to be torn up to strangle yourself; records, radios and light bulbs are for smashing to cut yourself with the pieces; cigarettes are for lighting fires; toilets are for blocking to flood the cell; the walls are for head-banging.
Safe containment thus becomes the torment of hours alone in a bare cell with every potential distraction removed – an experience which inevitably makes sick women sicker. In an attempt to make it safer still, builders are now constructing a padded cell on the wing – the ultimate paradox of humane treatment as solitary punishment.
Because it is part of a prison, C1 is staffed by prison officers who have no medical training and by nurses, most of whom have no psychiatric training and some of whom come in for short spells from an employment agency in Holloway Road.
In a prison, containment also involves discipline. In C1, this means that women are punished for the symptoms of their mental illness. Official figures show that they are punished more often than other prisoners, particularly for damaging prison property and disobeying orders.
HM Inspector of Prisons, Sir James Hennessy, was shocked when he discovered what was happening in Holloway. He wrote a stinging report in 1983 complaining that women were being disciplined at hearings which they were mentally incapable of following, even though doctors had passed them as fit for punishment.
He demanded that the practice should end, but it has not. The assistant governor responsible for the wing, Bill Quirie, says: “This is a prison. We are bound by prison rules and we have no authority to deviate from them whatsoever. If an officer is assaulted by a prisoner, she has a right to expect the prisoner to be disciplined.”
The building is all wrong: low ceilings and narrow corridors breed claustrophobia; cells with built-in toilets create blind spots where women can hide and cut up; long corridors with sightlines blocked by doors and corners mean that large numbers of officers are needed to supervise small numbers of prisoners.
The whole prison suffers from these architectural problems, but it has only just been completed after 15 years of building work. Replacing it is an impossible dream. “It’s a bloody disaster area, but we have to live with it,” says one senior official.
There are special problems with staffing. In any prison, if there is a shortage of staff, the immediate result is that prisoners stay locked in their cells. In Holloway, with its staff-intensive design, the shortage of officers is chronic and deeply rooted, and it is responsible for many of the harrowing hours suffered behind the doors of C1.
On paper, women in C1 spend most of the day out of their cells in education classes, a Skills Training Unit for occupational therapy, a gym, a sports hall and a swimming pool. The reality is quite different because there are not enough officers to escort them to the facilities or to supervise them.
On a good day, some of the women will spend as long as five hours out of their cells, but most of them spend most days behind a door. An average of half the education classes never take place. The Skills Training Unit sessions are very vulnerable: in the latest week for which figures are available, three of the eight sessions never happened at all; and none of the five which did take place was fully attended.
All the way through the hierarchy, from the prison officer on the ground, through the nurses and the governor grades, up to senior officials at headquarters, there is widespread agreement that most of these women should not be in prison. Yet they are.
Some of them are there because of the refusal of magistrates to grant them bail. On average, some 32 of the 42 women on the wing are on remand awaiting trial. Some of them are, indeed, too disturbed or dangerous to be bailed, but official figures suggest that more than half of these 32 should be a liberty.
The key figure is that 65 per cent of the women held on remand will eventually be given non-custodial sentences when they come to trial. In other words, as an average, 21 of the women on the wing at any one time ought to be out on bail. But magistrates prefer to play safe by denying it to them, and prison officials are powerless to stop them.
There is a further difficulty with those women who are manifestly mentally ill. The 1983 Mental Health Act gave magistrates a new power to remand such cases to hospital instead of to prison so that doctors could care for them and make an early decision about whether they were fit to stand trial. The new power is hardly being used.
Esther Samson says: “It has not made any difference at all. I meet magistrates who come to visit the prison, and some of them are not conversant with the new Act. They don’t even know they have this new power. Then there’s a problem that most of the hospitals claim they don’t have beds.”
The National Health Service has resolutely refused to provide suitable places. Ordinary local mental hospitals tend to throw up their hands in horror and plead that they do not have the security to cope, even though prison psychiatrists believe that some of the women are well suited to open conditions.
The secure hospitals, ironically, argue that their high security would be wasted on the women. They are also chronically overcrowded.
In the middle are the Regional Secure Units – a focus for abiding political friction. More than 10 years ago, it was estimated that the units needed to provide up to 2,000 beds. To date, they have provided only 298 in the whole of England and Wales.
Apart from reinforcing the magistrates’ failure to send remand prisoners to hospital, this intransigence in the NHS also traps convicted women in C1. But there is another, even more insidious problem.
A neat Orwellian loophole has been constructed which means that although a woman may be ill in the eyes of everyone who deals with her, she can still be deemed to be not ill in the eyes of the law, and so there is no need to provide a hospital place for her.
The 1983 Act excludes from its provisions a wide range of personality disorders and behavioural problems as well as any form of psycopathy which is held to be untreatable. So, the system now runs on a dual definition of mental illness. Some people are “ill within the meaning of the Act” while others are merely “ill” – and the latter are trapped in prison, barred by the letter of the law from hospital.
Just over a year ago, senior officials at the Prison Department decided that the containment of most of C1’s population in prison cells was so indefensible that the wing should be closed down.
They set up a committee to decide what to do with the women from the wing and to review Holloway’s role generally. But the officials were soon completely trapped by the magistrates, the NHS and the law. By the time the committee had finished its work, the decision to close C1 had been reversed.
Now the task of trying to end this misery has fallen to Colin Allen, the Governor of Holloway since February 1985. He is intelligent, humane and imaginative, one of the generation of younger governors who have brought new energy and subtlety to the attack on the prison system’s problems.
When he took over, he inherited a political crisis. The disclosure in The Observer in September 1984 of conditions on the wing and an outbreak of self-mutilation in which one woman had gouged out an eye, set off an extraordinary public reaction. The Home Office received a barrage of letters from the public and questions from MPs. For a year, Mr Allen has been struggling to break the log-jam around C1, but he still has very little room for manoeuvre.
Unable to stop the flow of mentally ill women into Holloway or to turn the prison into a hospital, his objective has been to make ‘safe containment’ more safe and more humane. He has been pushing at the Treasury for funds, at the Prison Officers Association for new manning agreements, and at the Prison Department bureaucracy for results. Some wheels are beginning to turn.
£250,000 is being spent on removing the dangerous fittings and the blind spots from 10 of the cells on the wing and on the construction of a padded cell. A ‘prefab’ is to be erected near the wing so that women can leave their cells without needing to be escorted across the prison.
A new medical officer is taking charge of the wing; staff are being sent on week-long training courses. But more fundamental problems remain and Mr Allen has working groups trying to find solutions. The question is whether he can possibly win through. He is effectively trying to buck the system which has created C1, and he knows that there is no guarantee of success.
The women in the cells:
MARY
Mary was sentenced last year to 18 months for burglary, criminal damage and assault. She is still in her twenties, but her life has been in a downward spiral since she was subjected to a series of sexual assaults by her grandfather when she was very young. She goes through periods of crazed violence. Soon after she arrived on C1, staff tried to get her a hospital place. They argued that she needed treatment to overcome her problems, but they were told that she was “not within the meaning of the Act”, ie not within the legal terms of the Mental Health Act. She started lighting fires in her cell and, eventually, after her condition had deteriorated, she made a determined attempt to kill herself by lighting a fire and burying her face in it.
RHONA
Rhona has been in and out of hospitals and prisons all her life, diagnosed at various stages as psychotic, schizophrenic, alcoholic and simply inadequate. Now in her forties, she is considered too old to be treatable and so no hospital will take her. She is now serving 11 months for breaking glass worth £40. The pattern now seems to be set: she will continue to commit petty offences; she will be denied hospital treatment; she will spend most of the rest of her life in prison.
LINDA
Linda has just left the wing after 18 months of chaos. She is an unusually large and powerful woman, who has been damaged since birth. Since she was 15, she has been shuttling in and out of psychiatric hospitals.
In 1984, she was jailed for burglary and sent to C1. Psychiatrists and staff agreed that she should be transferred to a hospital, but her reputation for violence preceded her, and none of the special hospitals would agree to take her. Held in the restricted regime of CI, Linda soon began to cause havoc. She assaulted staff, leaping on them from behind and pummelling them with her fists.
She barricaded herself in her cell and destroyed anything she could lay her hands on. Unable to treat her properly, the staff tried to punish her. She simply outstripped them, committing up to five serious offences a day. Within months she had lost all her remission and all of her ‘privileges’ and there was nothing left to punish her with. Finally, after 18 months of turmoil, with staff at the end of their tethers, prison psychiatrists persuaded one of the special hospitals to take her.
LUCY
Lucy left the wing last year. She was a bright, intelligent, outgoing girl from a stable home who had worked as a nanny in North London. She took her work very seriously and began worrying about whether she would get a good reference from her employers. Her anxiety reached such a pitch that in March 1984, she took an overdose of pills. Then began a relentless slide. The overdose cost her her job. Back home with her parents, she became so depressed that after a couple of months she overdosed again.
She became a patient at a psychiatric day centre and moved into a flat with another girl, but just as she seemed to be settling down, she had a furious row with her flatmate and was ejected. A passing taxi picked her up, but the driver stole some of her belongings and may have sexually assaulted her. She developed an obsessive hatred for taxi drivers and started travelling without paying her fare.
She spent 17 weeks in C1, most of them alone in her cell, chanting ‘Nobody loves me’ for hours on end. She was never the same again, and after her release in February 1985 she staggered through nine months of deep depressions, making several suicide attempts. Finally, in November, she jumped from the roof of a multi-storey car park and killed herself. She was 21.
For legal reasons, most of the prisoners’ names have been changed.