Heroin: the government screws it up

The Observer, 13 March 1986

In its fight against drug abuse, the government is hammering home one central point – heroin damages the user’s mind and body. Yet many of the young people at whom the campaign is aimed are rejecting its message, and their indifference is mirrored in the continuing boom in drug abuse. How can such a clear warning fail?

Many doctors and scientists who have studied drug abuse suggest that one reason may be that the heroin users believe that the message is wrong. Medical evidence, collected over the past 60 years, suggests that heroin, though undoubtedly addictive, does not in fact cause long-term harm: the depressing side effects listed in the government’s message are mostly the product of the black market with its unhygienic conditions, adulterated heroin and criminal sub-culture.

Some experts now argue that the message is only part of a larger error which has misdirected the strategy now used to combat hard drug abuse.

We met George in a south London pub. He was just back from two weeks in the sun and looked tanned and fit in his fine French clothes. He drives a red Porsche, which frightens his right-hand man, Keith. “Driving a brand new Porsche in this manor is like having a sign on your forehead saying Active Criminal,” he complains.

George’s whole family are active criminals. His father was a top armed robber during the Fifties and Sixties. But George is in heroin, moving about three kilos a week – buying at £16,000 a kilo from a Turkish contact, selling at £23,000, earning about £20,000 a week.

The police know all about George. Eighteen months ago, they infiltrated an undercover officer into his operation. But they have not yet got round to arresting him. “He’s not a big target right now,” according to one police source. “There are people above him queuing up to be arrested. There’s so much intelligence coming through that the operational side just can’t keep up.”

George is one of hundreds. Nobody knows exactly how many heroin dealers there are or how much heroin they are bringing into Britain, but all those involved know that it is getting worse.

Although the Prime Minister has herself spearheaded an attack on the supply of heroin aimed at every link in the chain from the poppy field in Pakistan to the street-corner deal in Merseyside, the use of heroin is still on the increase.

On the streets the price of heroin is gradually falling – it is now about £60 a gramme and the purity is staying remarkably high – more than 40 per cent compared to the 5 per cent in New York. These two facts spell out a simple message: the market is saturated.

The failure of the attack on heroin is so complete that it has called into question the whole strategy being used in Britain to stem the epidemic. A growing number of experts make these crucial points about the nature of the drug and the destruction it wreaks:

* Heroin, they say, is not in itself harmful if taken in pure form under controlled conditions.

* Most of the deaths and appalling suffering caused by the drug stem from its adulteration by dealers, from overdoses, or infected needles.

* As the black market in heroin grows, so do the risks. The less control over the use of the drug, the greater the danger to those who try it.

Given these circumstances, critics of the present policy argue that we should revert to the approach of the 1960s when Britain was the foremost exponent of the ‘maintenance’ strategy – the idea that addicts should be allowed to maintain a supply of heroin prescribed by their doctors for as long as they need it in order to take them off the streets and wean them back to ordinary life.

The prospect appalls most doctors. They argue that the 1960s policy was abandoned because it left the policing to doctors and began to spiral out of control. But the debate has begun, and a significant body of opinion is now pressing for the whole issue to be re-examined.

Neil is a journalist on a popular magazine. He dresses well, looks good and earns a fair living, although he takes daily doses of methadone and has been an addict for more than six years. “The popular image of an addict,” he says, “is someone scrabbling around in the gutter who is willing to rape, murder and maim in order to get their fix, or hang around school gates punting it to schoolchildren. There is so much ignorance about it.”

In his six years of addiction, life has not always been so stable. For a long time, he was spending £500 a week on the black market, using his own and his parents’ money, becoming ill from injecting in unhygienic conditions. “I transferred a throat infection into my vein and ended up in hospital for several weeks,’ he says.

The difference now is that he has found a private doctor who, for a £30 consultancy fee, will prescribe him weekly doses of methadone, so that he need no longer deal with the black market.

Most addicts cannot afford a private doctor and if they approach a GP they are often given short shrift. But those who succeed are now working as lawyers, journalists, City executives or farmers without problem and without any outward sign of their addiction.

Traditionally, there have been two strategies for dealing with drug-abuse: ‘prohibition’ which attacks the supply line with police activity; and ‘maintenance’ which tackles demand by providing a legal, controlled supply of the drug. Until 1965, Britain followed the maintenance strategy.

Then, an official inquiry advised that addicts should be treated only by licensed doctors in special clinics, known as DDUs (Drug Dependency Units), which opened in 1968. They progressively eroded the maintenance policy changing from heroin to methadone, from injectable to oral drugs, then cutting back on the period for which they would prescribe to any user.

Today there are 40 DDUs. They prescribe oral methadone in decreasing amounts for a short period, rarely for longer than four months, often much less. They are attended by less than 10 per cent of the country’s addicts. The maintenance strategy is now practised only by a handful of doctors, most of them in private practice. Critics of the present policy want a two-pronged approach which would continue the prohibition drive to deter new users but re-introduce maintenance to take existing addicts out of the black market. The disaster, in their eyes, is to pursue prohibition alone.

Dr Arnold Trebach, Director of the Washington Institute of Drugs, Crime and Justice, who has spent 14 years researching drug addiction in the US and UK, told The Observer: “The Americans have been treating this like a war for years and they’ve been failing. I hope people in England will not think that this madness about the war on drugs has universal support here: a lot of moderate, sensible Americans who don’t particularly care about addicts, are beginning to see that we’ve been getting it badly wrong.”

The most controversial single aspect of the prohibition policy, ironically, is the statement which is most widely taken for granted and which is now the headline of the British government’s advertising campaign: “Heroin screws you up.”

Dr Trebach said: “I am a scholar and I spend all of my time reading evidence about this, and there is overwhelming evidence that these narcotics – heroin, methadone, codeine, morphine and so on – are, as a group, organically not harmful.”

The biggest study of opiate use was conducted on 861 patients at Philadelphia General Hospital in the 1920s. It concluded: “Morphine addiction is not characterised by physical deterioration or impairment of physical fitness aside from the addiction per se. There is no evidence of change in the circulatory, hepatic, renal or endocrine functions. When it is considered that these subjects had been addicted for at least five years, some of them for as long as 20 years, these negative observations are highly significant.”

Other studies have tried to find evidence of damage to the user’s brain or mental functions, but have found none. “That individuals may take morphine or some other opiate for 20 years or more without showing intellectual or moral deterioration is a common experience of every physician who has studied the subject,” according to one study conducted by Dr Lawrence Kolb, former assistant surgeon-general in the US Public Health Service

Most doctors do not believe this claim. They say that heroin has many harmful physical effects and, above all, that it is addictive in a way unequalled by any other drug.

Its physical effects were summarised last week by Dr Joe Collier, consultant pharmacologist at St George’s Hospital, south London, and deputy editor of the Drugs and Therapeutics Bulletin: “It causes nausea, vomiting, and depression of appetite. Addicts often suffer abdominal pain, cramps and severe constipation, and can experience low blood pressure. It also depresses breathing, which is the way most addicts die from it.”

Others point out that these adverse physical effects only occur in the early stages of heroin use or because of overdoses.

There is one point on which both sides agree: heroin is highly addictive and, taken in large quantities, it is possible to overdose. The emerging view, however, is that the risks which are associated with it are the result of the black market and not of the drug itself.

Dr Ann Dally, president of the Association of Independent Doctors in Addiction, and a Harley Street practitioner, said: “The moment they start injecting it, it becomes more dangerous, and they usually start to inject because they are having to spend all their money on the black market and injecting is the most efficient way of taking it. They can’t afford to smoke it or snort it.

“Injecting is risky at the best of times, but in the black market they share needles or use dirty needles and contract all kinds of infections – hepatitis, AIDS and blood poisoning, which can cause abscesses all over their bodies and also heart damage.

“They buy heroin which is adulterated with all manner of things – brick-dust, Vim, flour, chalk or other drugs like barbiturates. That can poison the body or cause abscesses or thrombosis or severely damage organs.”

In addition to medical problems, the black market is also blamed for the social destruction which addicts suffer. Dr Dally said: “They have to spend all of their time trying to buy drugs and so they lose their jobs. They spend all their money on drugs so they don’t eat and they get scruffy and start to look dreadful.

“Most of them steal to get the money and then they get arrested and have a criminal record. Some of them sell it to fund their own habit, which is one of the very important reasons why it has been spreading so fast, because they need to find new users to keep going.”

On this view, the priority is to get the addict away from the black market rather than away from the drug. It was this idea which was at the core of the old maintenance strategy which has now been abandoned.

Among those who are now calling for its return is Dr Dale Beckett, who founded the first Drug Dependency Unit, in Norwood. The objections to the old policy of maintenance prescribing are:

* Addicts frequently sold some of the drugs they were prescribed, thereby spreading the habit.

* It did not lead to addicts leading a more stable life. They frequently experimented with other drugs as well, so it did not protect them from the dangers of injecting heroin mixed with Vim, brick dust, baking powder and so on.

* It confirmed in their minds that they could not do without drugs so it denied them any hope of ever coming off. It gave them a medical opinion that they could not manage without.

Dr Charlotte Feinmann, who is a locum consultant at the DDU at University College Hospital and has set up a new day care centre there, opposes the maintenance programme because “when you are prescribing, the only conversation you have with the drug user is over the size of the prescription. You cannot get them to change any aspect of their life. They cannot bear to take the final step and come off altogether because they cannot face the thought of the future without drugs.”

The government would argue that prohibition is not the only weapon they use. In addition to the 40 DDUs, they provide some 150 hospital beds, grants for charities which have a further 450 beds, and £17 million for local initiatives, particularly advice and counselling services. They are also promoting an advertising campaign, aimed at young people.

But research psychologist Mike Gossop says: “One of the great tragedies of the British response is that there has been no systematic research. We still don’t know the answers to basic questions. We are still in the Dark Ages from the research point of view.”

NOTE: This feature was the object of an internal tug-of-war in the Observer newsroom. Some journalists refused to accept the emerging facts about heroin and were determined to cling to the official government line. The result was that, like blackmarket heroin, the feature had some toxic ingredients added to it, including the quotes from Joe Collier and Charlotte Feinmann and the penultimate paragraph on government actions.