New evidence of plots to oust liberal prison governor

The Observer, 2 March 1986

The row over the removal of the governor of Styal Prison took a new turn last week, with allegations of political intrigue at the Prison Department and of an extraordinary plot by women prison officers.

The Observer disclosed last week that James Anderson, an outspoken liberal, had been moved at short notice from his post at Styal women’s prison in Cheshire after a sustained campaign against him by prison officers.

Now new evidence has been passed to The Observer and to the Liberal home affairs spokesman, Alex Carlisle. According to reliable sources:

■ Officials in the Prison department wanted to oust Mr Anderson because they were politically embarrassed by his public support for prison reform. They were furious at speeches and newspaper interviews he gave. “It’s a political move to get rid of him,” a senior source said. “The Department has no time for a man who is prepared to speak out and speak the truth. We’ve always been told that the greatest sin you can commit is to embarrass the Home Office.”

■ Mr Anderson was undermined in the prison by a small group of officers who are gay women, had affairs with each other and with inmates, and feared that he would stop them. “Many of the staff are lesbian and are loyal and hard-working,” we were told. “But this group brings it into the prison, and they want to run things their way. They certainly don’t want a man running things. They couldn’t manipulate him.”

This same group of officers is said to have taken delight in enforcing an unnecessarily strict regime and to have fought Mr Anderson’s attempts to dismantle it, intimidating other officers and blocking the execution of his orders.

The new evidence suggests that they also blocked the flow of information to the governor’s office. If there was a rumour that there was going to be trouble with a particular group of inmates, we were told, they would stop junior officers reporting it to the governor. Then, when the trouble erupted, he would be left with egg on his face.

These officers are also blamed for leaking inaccurate stories to the press to discredit Mr Anderson. National and local officials of the Prison Officers Association also gave newspapers information which is bitterly contested by Mr Anderson. Two POA officials at Styal who supported him resigned in the face of the machinations.

Six of the women officers involved have been named in the new evidence, and the allegations against them have been substantially confirmed by former members of staff, ex-inmates, and a senior source in the Prison Department.

Mr Carlisle has sent an outline of the new evidence to the Home Office minister responsible for prisons, Lord Glenarthur He is calling for the suspension of the named officers, the reinstatement of Mr Anderson and an independent inquiry. He is also pressing for a House of Commons debate.

The disclosure of Mr Anderson’s transfer has caused a furore in the prison. Long-term prisoners have been trying to organise a petition in his support. Staff are deeply split, with a majority supporting Mr Anderson. Last week, there was talk of taking him hostage to register physically the fact that they want him to stay.

Staff who support Mr Anderson are planning a vote of no confidence in their local POA officials. Some are threatening to leave to leave the POA in protest.

Mr Anderson is due to start tomorrow in his new job as governor of a youth custody centre in Lancashire. He had been aware that some officers opposed his attempts at reform, he said. “But you don’t expect the Home Office to cut the ground from under your feet. That undermines any credibility you might have and it leaves the door wide open to mischief-makers and all the people who have been causing the problem It’s pretty awful.

“I feel so disillusioned any disenchanted at working for an organisation that treats people this way that I don’t really want to work for them any more. Being prudent, though, I don’t want to chuck in my hand – that would look like an agreement that I was at fault. But I don’t see any future for myself at all.”