The lonely death of a woman with problems

The Observer, 22 December 1985

Ann Margaret Franklyn, aged 44, died – friendless and locked away – by her own hand in the psychiatric wing of Holloway prison last week.

But her death – and her life in which she struggled against overwhelming emotional problems – may prove to be a milestone in the unhappy history of the notorious C1 wing of the women’s jail.

For a year now it has been dogged by controversy over living conditions and over the self-mutilations and suicide attempts apparently exacerbated by its stark regime.

Franklyn was typical of the women who sit in solitary confinement behind the locked doors of the wing – mentally disturbed but not ill enough to earn a place in a mental hospital.

Less than a year ago, she had her own flat in Bedford and had never been in trouble with the police, but she was already suffering from the problems which were eventually to defeat her.

Since her twenties, she had been suffering from depression and confusion over her identity. She sought help; and was diagnosed as a transexual. A minor facial operation went horribly wrong, paralysing one side of her body.

She was given a special council flat for the disabled and lived with a girlfriend. But earlier this year that relationship ended.

After a series of minor offences, including an assault on her former girlfriend, she was remanded to Holloway.

There, she set fire to her nightdress and tried to hang herself. She fell in love with another prisoner, who did not return her affections. Eventually, magistrates gave her a conditional discharge and ordered her release.

A visiting psychiatrist in Holloway decided she was suffering from depression and a personality disorder but was not mentally ill in law, and could not be recommended for transfer to hospital.

Outside prison she immediately re-offended, apparently desperate to go back into custody to see the girl she had fallen for. Within days she was back inside for a six-week remand before magistrates conditionally discharged her again.

At home, she lit a fire in her garage. Police charged her with criminal damage to the windscreen wiper of one of their vehicles and sent her back to Holloway. This time, she was sent to the psychiatric wing, C1.

Instead of enjoying the company she craved, she was held in isolation. The girl she wanted to see had been transferred. Prison staff were warned that she had a history of suicide attempts and was clearly a suicide risk.

She was left lone in her cell for 24 hours a day with a mattress for company, her meals pushed through a hatch in the door. Every 15 minutes, according to the suicide risk procedure, an officer came to check on her through the spy hole. On Monday afternoon she hanged herself, using her own cardigan.

An inquest is to be held and the pressure group Women In Prison intend to sue the Home Office for negligence over her death.

Six months ago, the then Home Secretary, Mr Leon Brittan, said urgent steps would be taken to improve conditions on the wing. None has yet been taken.