Six Irishmen who have spent 11 years in prison for the 1974 Birmingham pub bombings may have been wrongly convicted, innocent victims of a simple scientific error.
The six have always protested their innocence and, unlike other terrorist prisoners, they have never been acknowledged by the IRA. Now the Home Office is being pressed to reopen their case after the discovery of new evidence supporting their claim.
The evidence – to be broadcast on Granada TV’s World In Action tomorrow night – shows that a key forensic test was unreliable. It is now believed that the test, regarded then as evidence that the men had been handling explosives, showed only that they had been handling playing cards.
The men’s case has been taken up by Conservative MP Sir John Farr, who is passing Granada’s evidence to the Home Office and demanding a new trial.
The men, all Irish residents of Birmingham, were arrested as they boarded the Irish ferry on November 21 1974, within hours of the explosions which destroyed two city centre pubs, killing 21 people and injuring 166. The incident remains the worst IRA attack on the mainland.
At first they were held simply because they were Irishmen travelling together to Northern Ireland. But later that night they became prime suspects after a Home Office forensic claimed he had found traces of nitroglycerine on the hands of two detainees.
Dr Frank Skuse made his claim after taking swabs from the men’s hands and submitting them to an established procedure known as the Griess Test. He concluded, as he later said at the trial, that it was 99% certain that the men had been handling explosives.
In the next four days, the men claimed, they were subjected to a sustained campaign of vicious beatings and threats against them and their families, by the end of which five of them had made statements which were inaccurate and contradictory but damning.
Two scientists commissioned by Granada Television have now established independently that the Griess Test can produce a positive result not just for nitroglycerine but also for nitrocellulose – a substance present in the lacquer of many household objects.
One of he scientists, Dr Brian Caddy, who runs the country’s only independent forensic science unit, at the University of Strathclyde, got positive results from a picture postcard, a cigarette packet, a varnished wooded surface, two different makes of cards and – crucially – from the hands of someone who shuffled a pack of cards. The men had been playing cards for two hours before their arrest.
Dr Caddy said: “On the basis of these tests, we have now established that Dr Skuse was wrong to say he was 99% certain. I cannot comment on the rest of the evidence, but as far as the scientific evidence is concerned, I would say that there is considerable reason to doubt whether these men were actually involved.”
At their trial in the summer of 1975, a defence scientist, Dr Hugh Black, said he believed the Griess Test was unreliable and could react to nitrocellulose. But he had not proof of his claim, and his evidence was dismissed by the judge, Mr Justice Bridge.
Dr Black said yesterday: “I felt upset about the trial because I thought the evidence I gave was not being given the weight it merited, and now it seems to have been borne out. Too often at these trials, the word of the prosecution scientist is taken as gospel.”
The six men – Hugh Callaghan, 55; Patrick Hill, 40; Gerrard Hunter, 39 ; Bill Power, 40; and John Walker, 50 – have tried to prove their innocence through the courts. They were refused leave to appeal and then tried but failed to start a civil action against the police for assaulting them in custody.
Under new Home Office guidelines, the men will not be considered for parole until 1995. They have told friends they expect to die in prison.
Dr Skuse has been unable to comment on Granada’s findings because the Home Office has forbidden him to speak to the press.