Holloway – the scandal gets worse

The Observer, 11 October 1985

Disturbing evidence is emerging of the plight of mentally ill women in Holloway Prison as the Home Office comes under increasing pressure to make radical changes at the north London jail.

The Observer has established that:

* Women with severe mental disorders are regularly being punished at disciplinary hearings – in defiance of a demand from the Prisons Inspector that the practice should end.

* Inmates in the controversial psychiatric wing, C 1, have again been mutilating themselves – there have been 15 incidents in the last month.

* Although the Home Secretary promised the House of Commons four months ago that immediate steps will be taken to improve conditions on the wing, there have been no changes yet on the psychiatric wing.

The problem of mentally ill women being tried and punished at internal hearings was pinpointed by HM Inspector of Prisons, Sir James Hennessy, in a report on Holloway to the Home Secretary last November.

Sir James reported that his staff had taken a random sample of 40 women who had been tried by the prison’s Board of Visitors. They found that only eight were mentally normal. “The remaining 32 had a wide range of conditions including brain damage and mental impairment,” he wrote.

“We found it difficult to accept that the normal adjudicating procedures could be applied to abnormal prisoners who were actually manifesting their disorders in bizarre behaviour at the time. . . . All had been certified by a medical officer to be fit for adjudication but many, according to their records and the testimony of staff, were extremely disturbed.”

Sir James’s call for urgent action to end this unfortunate practice was referred to the Director General of the Prison Service, who passed it on to an internal committee on Holloway. It then found its way to a Home Office inquiry into Boards of Visitors, who had no brief to study Holloway and made no comment.

The chairman of Holloway’s Board of Visitors, lawyer Jeffrey Bayes, confirmed last week that nothing had changed. “I would say more than half the women who came before us are suffering mental disorder. We have complained repeatedly about it. Many of them cannot have a grasp of the proceedings.”

Most of the mentally disturbed women are held on the psychiatric wing, C 1 , which has become the focus of controversy since conditions there were first disclosed by The Observer in July last year. Last week, it was the subject of a debate in the House of Lords.

A woman who has recently been held on the wing has smuggled out a diary of her experiences to the pressure group Women In Prison. It begins on a Sunday in September….

“The room I’m in is disturbing. You see, I hear voices in my head. I saw one doctor who just said: ‘We’ll have to keep an eye on you.’

“Monday. I was locked in my cell all day. I could not have my things from Reception. That night I heard voices again. One nurse said that I hear them all the time when people talk to me. I got really upset. I felt like cutting my wrist. A screw said: ‘Say a prayer.’

“Wednesday. I was seen by another doctor who asked if I was mad when I told him my problem. I have been locked away since I was a child in different places – children’s homes, Rampton, Moss Side. A girl rang her bell, was told by a nurse: ‘You’re a pain in the arse.’

“I do really need help. Someone please me. Before they kill me by not helping me. The nurses will not give me a sink plug. I have to use toilet paper to hold the water in. My furnitures is all cardboard, except the bed. Under the lino is full of water.

“Thursday. Girl banging, ringing her bell, gets no answer from nurses. The same day, a girl ripped her T-shirt up. The nurse said: ‘If you want to tie your neck up, go ahead.’ She went back into her office.

“Friday. Seen by a donor again. He gave me more Valium — three times a day now.

“Saturday. Was going to get into bed when I noticed three bed bugs. We have covers on our mattresses. They come out of there. My cover had sick stains on.”