The roots of rioting in Brixton

The Observer, 6 October 1985

In an extraordinary public statement yesterday, nine Anglican clergymen in Brixton came together to issue a joint declaration in the wake of the Brixton riots, deploring the policing of the area, the behaviour of the rioters and the social and economic conditions that lay behind the explosion of violence.

Their concern echoes the findings of Observer reporters who spent last week talking to protagonists on all sides in Brixton as they analysed the events of last weekend. Our investigations have found:

* A new police strategy, using armed raids to extract targeted suspects from the community, has acted as a repeated irritant;

* A severe slide in the economy of the area, aggravated by the withdrawal of central government funds, has left Brixton at the top of a league table of inner city deprivation;

* A log-lam of conflicting local interests has blocked efforts to improve police-community liaison.

The armed raid which led to the shooting of Mrs Cherry Groce and sparked Brixton’s night of violence was one of 50 already carried out in the Lambeth area by armed police so far this year. The raids are the cutting edge of new strategy signalled by a targeting and surveillance operation introduce by police in Brixton in January for six weeks. The aim was to identify criminals without engaging in the mass stop-and-search exercises like SWAMP ’81 which were widely blamed for the 1981 riots.

The raids can, however, be extremely violent. One woman on the receiving end described her experience. Paula Belsham was lying in the bath at her home just off Brixton Road at 4 p.m. on 30 August. She was alone in the house. Suddenly the front door caved in under a sledgehammer blow.

“This man in jeans holding a sledgehammer kicked in the door of my front room. Then a second man rushed in pointing a gun at me and crouching down like they do on TV. I started screaming and a third guy grabbed hold of me, pushed me to the floor and held a gun to my temple. I couldn’t believe it. I was so scared I wet myself.

“None of them wore uniforms. You wouldn’t guess they were police. They showed me a warrant and I stopped screaming and they threw me my African dress to cover me up. One of the dogs bit one of them and they threatened to kill it with the sledgehammer. I begged them not to.

“They examined me internally while there was a man in the room. Apart from asking where the heroin was, they hardly said anything. They ransacked the place, pulled up the carpets and the lino, split open some stuffed toys. One guy even put his hand in the goldfish bowl. They left after an hour.”

The raid was the second on Paula Belsham’s home, and was part of the same strategy which led armed officers to the door of Mrs Cherry Groce last Saturday. The leader of Lambeth Council, Mr Ted Knight, argues that the operation is “comparable in scale and sensitivity” to SWAMP ’81.

Commander Alex Marnoch, head of Brixton police, disputes the comparison. He argues that his present tactic involves having 55 extra officers on the streets compared to the 300 involved in SWAMP ’81. He also cites improved crime figures: 20% fall in burglary; 15% fall in robbery; murders down from 17 last year to one so far this year.

Commander Marnoch has survived in the hottest police seat in London, but he acknowledges that his contribution is limited. “What can we, the police, offer? We can talk to them, we can play cricket with them, we can go to their youth clubs. But we can’t give them money and jobs. “

The statistics tell the story:

* Since the 1981 riots, unemployment has doubled in the borough of Lambeth and now stands at 22%. In Brixton it is 33%.

* The rate of house-building has fallen. In 1981, 1,022 new homes were completed. Last year, it was only 552. In 1981, the council spent £51 million on housing. This year it is spending £34 million.

* Central Government’s contribution has fallen dramatically. Although Lambeth’s spending on services has risen – from £91.6 million in 1980 to £114.3 million in 1984 – the central contribution has fallen from £56.4 million to only £39 million. Last year, central Government gave the council £13 million aid from the urban programme – and took away £19 million in penalties for overspending.

Yesterday, the nine Brixton Anglican priests were forthright in their condemnation: “We deplore the conditions of life which have persisted and worsened in Brixton since the 1981 riots. We deplore the fact that no effective steps have been taken by the government in the past four years to alleviate unemployment.”

One Brixton clergyman has told The Observer that during Saturday’s riot he personally saw police enter a looted off-licence and leave clutching bottles of alcohol. He has asked not to be named because he says that although he is a priest, he fears police reaction.

There have been other reports of uncontrolled police behaviour during the weekend’s violence. On Friday, a tenants’ meeting at the Angell Town estate conducted an angry post-mortem. Residents claimed that police had moved through blocks of flats systematically breaking glass in their front doors. They say that this happened early on Sunday after the rioting had died away.

Resident Janet Morris said: “A policeman called me a black bastard. They smashed the glass in my door. They kept shouting ‘Nigger, go home.’ I’ve lived here for 10 years and never seen anything like it.”

Other tenants told similar stories. Despite the best efforts of Commander Marnoch and senior community leaders, it is clear that a gulf still separates the police from large swathes of the community.

On one side, there is the police consultative group, established in 1982 in the wake of Lord Scarman’s report, which is supported by the Home Office, the police and older members of the community. On the other, there is Lambeth Council police committee set up early in 1984, which is supported by the council, younger and more radical Brixton groups, and boycotted by the mainstream consultative groups supporters.

Last Tuesday night, Lambeth Town Hall played host to a symbolic ritual. Upstairs, the council’s police committee met to call for a public inquiry into the riot. So far, the call has been ignored. Downstairs, the official consultative group became a trial of strength between Commander Marnoch and angry locals including anarchists, who tried to disrupt the meeting. There was no communication between the two meetings.