The BBC is under increasing pressure to make a clean breast of its covert links with the intelligence community as more evidence of the close relationship emerges.
The Observer has established that, as well as allowing MI5 to investigate the political background of its staff, the corporation
* receives daily intelligence material – some of it highly classified – from the Foreign Office at secret meetings in the headquarters of the External Services at Bush House
* allowed the head of the Defence Intelligence Agency to preview a ‘Panorama’ documentary which he wanted to change – an unprecedented concession and
* has regularly received secret MI5 briefing papers on ‘subversive’ political groups – an arrangement which, the BBC claims, has now been scrapped.
The regular flow of Foreign Office intelligence material into Bush House has been one of the BBC’s best-kept secrets. Last week, BBC executives who have handled the material denied knowing anything about it. Then a crisis meeting was called to try to prevent further leaks.
The material includes telex traffic from British ambassadors around the world and analysis of secret intelligence collated from MI6 and GCHQ in Cheltenham.
“Reading it,” according to one source, “you can see that they have some very well-placed people in foreign governments, and it’s obvious they’re reading their letters and so on.”
Each morning it is brought to Bush House by a Foreign Office courier, sealed in different envelopes for each part of the world. At 10 am, the heads of services hold their daily meeting in the third floor conference room and then go into closed session to open the envelopes. All those in the room have signed the Official Secrets Act.
Although such a unique flow of high-grade intelligence seems to be a journalistic bonus for Bush House, some experienced figures there believe it is dangerous and hope its disclosure will neutralise the threat.
The concern is that it allows the Foreign Office to outweigh alternative views of world news and to distort coverage by being selective in the presentation of their own intelligence. It is argued that the secrecy of the arrangement makes it more dangerous, since a reporter will not know why his head of service is criticising or altering his story.
Defenders of the system concede the danger but say it has always been held at bay. “Foreign correspondents are going to be worried and understandably suspicious when they find out about this,” said one experienced BBC executive, “but their fear will be groundless.
“The basis of the independence of the External Services is the frame of mind of the people in charge. If they are determined not to be bent, then it is fine – and it always has been. If you have people who are going to lie down in front of the Foreign Office, then it’s a different matter.”
As more evidence of BBC links with intelligence services is disclosed, senior journalists are warning executives that the BBC has given too much ground in the face of pressure.
Last month’s decision to stage a private preview of a ‘Panorama’ documentary for Defence Intelligence is being seen as a catastrophic error. It is believed to be the first time that the BBC has acceded to a demand, which is often made by Government departments who are nervous about a future programme’s content.
The documentary, Family of Spies, examined the Walker family, who are alleged to have passed US naval secrets to the Russians. On Saturday 6 July – two days before it was due to be shown – the Ministry of Defence told the BBC that it wanted to see the programme in case it “inadvertently breached national security.”
The Assistant Director General, Mr Alan Protheroe, overrode the programme-makers and agreed. A viewing was arranged in Sunday at Television Centre. Those who attended were asked to give an undertaking that they would tell no one what was going on.
The viewing was attended by Air Marshal Sir Michael Armitage, chief of the DIA; Mr John Ledley, formerly assistant to the chief of intelligence in Northern Ireland and now head of MoD information; and also the head of naval warfare. They took notes of the programme’s content.
The BBC claims that this was “an exceptional and strictly one-off occasion”. Senior staff say it was a dangerous precedent and that they have no confidence that it will not be repeated.
The disclosure in last week’s Observer that MI5 had been giving the BBC secret reports on the activities of ‘subversive’ groups has provoked a public reply from the BBC’s Director-General, Mr Alasdair Milne.
In an open letter to The Observer, he denied that the reports were received by his chief assistant, Margaret Douglas, and described the claim as ‘professionally damaging’ to her. On Friday night, the corporation announced that “the BBC is not receiving these MI5 briefs” but refused to say when the arrangement had been ended.
In a reply to Mr Milne, The Observer’s Editor, Mr Donald Trelford, said: “I note your comment that Margaret Douglas is not receiving information from MI5. However, your letter makes no comment on the central thrust of our story: that it has been the established practice for MI5 to send three-monthly security surveys to the BBC and that it has hitherto been the job of the Chief Assistant to the Director-General to receive these secret briefings and also to liaise with MI5 on behalf of the Director-General.
“I am surprised that you should describe such a procedure as ‘professionally damaging’ when the BBC has required her predecessors to engage in it. Am I right in thinking that the main point of your letter is to advise us that this system has recently been changed in some way?”