MI5 regularly provides the BBC with background briefs on industrial disputes and the alleged involvement of subversives in trade union activity.
This intelligence is delivered by hand every three months in a sealed envelope stamped ‘secret’. It is circulated among a handful of the most senior BBC executives, including the heads of news and current affairs.
The Corporation is now likely to face demands for an explanation of how this information is used and whether it affects coverage of industrial disputes. This follows last week’s disclosures in The Observer that the security service has been vetting staff.
The BBC’s Director of Personnel, Mr Christopher Martin, has ordered an internal review of the vetting system to decide whether it can be scaled down or even stopped. The review will also examine the current practice by which many editorial staff are required to sign the Official Secrets Act.
Broadcasting unions have privately told the BBC’s Director General, Mr Alasdair Milne, that they are determined to have the vetting system completely scrapped. When they met Mr Milne on Friday, they warned him that anything less would provoke a head-on conflict.
The unions are calling a national conference to review BBC policy on MI5 and on the banning of the ‘Real Lives’ documentary. The Corporation has been told that, unless both issues have been satisfactorily resolved by then, they must expect a massive and concerted campaign of stoppages.
One senior source commented: “It will be Doomsday.”
Mr Milne has now agreed to minor amendments in the Real Lives programme, which includes an interview with Martin McGuinness of Provisional Sinn Fein. Mr Milne is expected to ask the government for their consent to broadcast it when they meet in two weeks.
BBC staff are confident that the documentary will be shown. To avoid rubbing salt into the wounds of the Board of Governors, they have agreed to a management request to scrap a full-page advertisement which was due to appear in The Times on Wednesday attacking the Board’s position.
The security service briefs go to Ms Margaret Douglas, chief assistant to the Director General. She has the unspoken but formal role of liaising with MI5 on behalf of the DG. The lists contain details of left-wing, right-wing and other radical groups, including terrorists, with a summary of their recent known activities.
They outline the background to the terrorist attacks in Britain, describe changes in the leadership and policy of political groups and trace the involvement of ‘subversive’ groups in industrial disputes and ad hoc campaigns.
The chief assistant is supposed to show them only to the DG and to the heads of news and current affairs, but senior journalists claim to have been shown material which they believed came from MI5.
Senior BBC executives agree that the briefs could colour the perception of a particular story but insist that any attempt by MI5 to interfere directly in news would be firmly rebuffed.
MI5 officers who specialise in monitoring domestic politics also hold occasional private meetings with the chief assistant. These meetings have been used to raise questions about the loyalty of members of BBC staff – particularly those on short contracts, who are not covered by the vetting system.
Some senior BBC staff fear that the board of management would find it hard to shake off MI5 if they decided to scrap the vetting system or refuse further back-ground briefs. The last D-G, Sir Ian Trethowan, was blocked by MI5 when he tried to make a public statement admitting the existence of the vetting.
At the meeting with broadcasting union leaders on Friday, some senior executives conceded their embarrassment over the affair. One said they were fighting a ‘guerrilla war’ with the governors; another suggested that they had not themselves realised the extent of MI5’s activities.