The Home Office was under pressure last night to launch a full inquiry into the police use of firearms after a five-year-old Birmingham boy, John Shorthouse, was shot dead by police who burst into the house and arrested his father.
Police said that an officer was searching under John’s bed, without realising he was hidden under the blankets, when his gun accidentally went off, fatally wounding John in the chest.
Last night a constable from West Midlands Tactical Firearms Unit was suspended from duty while a senior officer from the Lancashire force began an official inquiry. The constable, who is 35, is married with three children and was treated for shock after the shooting.
Labour home affairs spokesman Mr Alf Dubs said: “I am horrified that there has been yet another incident where the police seem to have been trigger-happy. The time has come for a thorough review of the way police use guns – when they are issued and why, how they are trained, whether there is enough discipline. We will be pushing the Home Office very hard to do more than just mouth platitudes to stop this sort of dreadful incident.”
Yesterday’s incident began soon after six in the morning when a four-man team from the force’s tactical firearms unit broke down the front door of the Shorthouse home in Barretts Road, Walkers Heath on the outskirts of Birmingham. Inside the house were three children – John, five; Danny, three; and Dennis, two – with their parents, John, 26, and Jacqueline. The officers were carrying standard issue .357 police revolvers.
Their target was John Shorthouse senior. They wanted to question him about a robbery four days ago in Kidwelly, North Wales, when three men with a shotgun threatened a restaurateur and stole £170 in cash. They arrested Mr Shorthouse without difficulty and then started to search the house.
One of the officers, still carrying his gun in his hand, went into John junior’s room. According to the assistant chief constable of West Midlands, Mr Paul Leopold: “On the bed was a bundle of rags and the officer stooped to search under the bed. His revolver, which has no safety catch, was in his hand.
“As he searched, the gun discharged into the bundle of rags. There was a noise from the bundle, and when the officer looked he found the little boy. Other officers had been in the room and they had no idea that there was anybody there.”
John was rushed to Selly Oak hospital where he was certified dead at 6.40. His mother and her other two children were taken to relatives. His father was taken into custody.
The central issue for the inquiry now is to establish why the officer’s gun was fired. West Midlands police said the revolver had no safety catch, but they acknowledged that the gun should not have been cocked.
Peter Elliot, a firearms instructor and former member of Essex tactical firearn unit, said: “It is hard to believe that an officer was conducting a search with his hammer cocked. That would be grossly negligent to a degree that I wouldn’t accept from a trained police officer. If the hammer was not cocked, it comes down to the man’s psychological attitude. If an officer is expecting to be shot at at any moment, he can fire his weapon on reflex without even knowing that he’s done it.”
Yesterday’s incident caused little surprise in police circles. There has been a series of what police call ‘negligent discharges’ culminating in the shooting of Steven Waldorf in central London in January 1983.
In Birmingham last night Chief Constable Geoffrey Dear said: “On behalf of West Midlands police, I tender my deepest regret and sincere sympathy to the family of the boy.” Birmingham MP Clare Short said it was “outrageous and unforgivable.”
Police said later that a firearm had been recovered in the course of the day’s operation, but they would not say whether it came from the Shorthouse home. Two other homes were also raided in the same operation, and last night a total of three men, including Mr Shorthouse, were being questioned about the Welsh robbery.
UPDATE: PC Brian Chester was charged with manslaughter in relation to the boy’s death and was found Not Guilty at trial. The dead boy’s father admitted taking part in the Welsh robbery and was jailed for three and a half years. His two accomplices were given longer sentences.