Inquiry fails to deal with Holloway scandal

The Observer, 21 July 1985

The findings of the inquiry into Holloway prison are a damning testament to the log jam of conflicting pressures and policies which now beset the prison service.

The inquiry was set up last December after chilling outbreaks of self-mutilation and attempted suicide among women on the prison’s psychiatric wing were disclosed by this newspaper. A succession of visitors to the wing, including MPs of all parties and the Bishop of Stepney, roundly condemned the cramped conditions, the prolonged isolation of the women, the lack of adequate treatment for their illnesses.

The inquiry first tried to close down the wing. But where to send the inmates? The National Health Service would not help; other women’s prisons are already overloaded. The inquiry tried instead to improve conditions within Holloway, but there again they could do nothing.

One of the worst features of Holloway, they acknowledge, is the physical design of the buildings: but there is no money to replace them. There are chronic staff shortages: but again there is no money for more overtime. Part-time staff might be a solution: but will the Prison Officers’ Association agree? The mixture of sentenced and unsentenced prisoners is undesirable, they say: but there is too much pressure on the system to change it. Meanwhile the drug therapy unit will have to close so that the cells can be used for remand prisoners.

As for the psychiatric wing, the inquiry concludes that it is “totally unsuitable for its task” and so, in a classic civil service response, there is to be a feasibility study to assess whether a new unit should be built within the prison. The regime on the wing will be altered – but at an unspecified time with funds which have not yet been allocated.

The 39 women locked away in the wing this weekend can take little comfort. In a wretched footnote to the affair, the Prison Department said last week that there had been 20 incidents of self-mutilation and three attempted suicides on the wing in the past four weeks alone.